| 1869 | L | Princeton (NJ) | 4 | Rutgers (NJ) | 6 | New Brunswick, NJ | Rutgers 6g - Princeton 4g |
| 1869 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 8 | Rutgers (NJ) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | Princeton 8g - Rutgers 0 |
| 1869 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 6 | Princeton (NJ) | 4 | New Brunswick, NJ | Rutgers 6g - Princeton 4g |
| 1869 | L | Rutgers (NJ) | 0 | Princeton (NJ) | 8 | Princeton, NJ | Princeton 8g - Rutgers 0 |