| 1886 | W | Albany Ridgefield AC (NY) | 25 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | West Troy, NY | |
| 1886 | W | Albany Ridgefield AC (NY) | 32 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | Albany, NY | |
| 1886 | W | Albion (MI) | 9 | Michigan St. | 2 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Albion (MI) | 1 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | ? | Olivet Forfeits |
| 1886 | W | Albion (MI) | 79 | Michigan St. | 0 | Albion, MI | |
| 1886 | L | Albion (MI) | 0 | Michigan | 50 | Albion, MI | |
| 1886 | L | Albion (MI) | 0 | Michigan | 24 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1886 | L | Alexandria Episcopal HS (VA) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 14 | Alexandria, VA | |
| 1886 | W | American All-Stars | 3 | Canadian All-Stars | 2 | East Newark, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 15 | Massachusetts | 5 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 18 | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Amherst (MA) | 0 | Wesleyan (CT) | 47 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 20 | Trinity (CT) | 4 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 22 | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 18 | MIT (MA) | 0 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Amherst (MA) | 0 | MIT (MA) | 22 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 6 | Williams (MA) | 4 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Amherst (MA) | 16 | Trinity (CT) | 8 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Amherst (MA) | 0 | Williams (MA) | 11 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Boston (MA) | 10 | Brown (RI) | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Brooklyn AC (NY) | 0 | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 26 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 20 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | T | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 6 | Staten Island AC (NY) | 6 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1886 | W | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 28 | Brooklyn Poly Institute (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | Yale Freshmen (CT) | 18 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 11 | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 68 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 14 | Hasbrouke Institute (NJ) | 0 | Jersey City, NJ | |
| 1886 | T | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | Staten Island AC (NY) | 0 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Brooklyn Poly Institute (NY) | 0 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 28 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Brown (RI) | 6 | Boston (MA) | 10 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Brown (RI) | 70 | Providence HS (RI) | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Butler (IN) | 2 | Hanover (IN) | 11 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | California | 20 | San Francisco Wasps FBC (CA) | 2 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | California | 10 | Orions | 12 | Oakland, CA | |
| 1886 | W | California | 1 | Hastings Law College (CA) | 0 | Berkeley, CA | Hastings Law College Forfeits |
| 1886 | T | California | 12 | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 12 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | W | California | 10 | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 0 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | W | California | 29 | Orions | 2 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | W | California | 1 | San Francisco Wasps FBC (CA) | 0 | Berkeley, CA | San Francisco Wasps Forfeits |
| 1886 | W | California | 1 | Hastings Law College (CA) | 0 | Berkeley, CA | Hastings Law College Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | California | 4 | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 7 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | Chester Calumet Cricket FBC (PA) | 0 | Widener (PA) | 12 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | T | Chester HS (PA) | 0 | Upland HS (PA) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 18 | Mount Auburn AC (OH) | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 8 | Mount Auburn AC (OH) | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Colorado College | 1 | Colorado Springs HS (CO) | 0 | ? | Colorado Springs HS Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | Colorado Springs HS (CO) | 0 | Colorado College | 1 | ? | Colorado Springs HS Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | Dartmouth (NH) | 11 | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 18 | Andover, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 11 | MIT (MA) | 6 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1886 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 91 | Vermont | 0 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1886 | L | Dartmouth (NH) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 70 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1886 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 5 | Lafayette (PA) | 24 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Lehigh (PA) | 26 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 15 | Swarthmore (PA) | 28 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1886 | L | East Washington Orients FBC (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Gallaudet won - score unknown | |
| 1886 | W | Fordham (NY) | 36 | Hoboken AC (NJ) | 12 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Franklin (IN) | 4 | Wabash (IN) | 8 | ? | |
| 1886 | T | Franklin (IN) | 4 | Wabash (IN) | 4 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | East Washington Orients FBC (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet won - score unknown | |
| 1886 | T | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Wallach School (DC) | 0 | Results and score unknown | |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Washington Dupont AC (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet won - score unknown | |
| 1886 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 30 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 12 | Washington Central HS (DC) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 18 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 14 | Alexandria Episcopal HS (VA) | 0 | Alexandria, VA | |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Washington Central HS (DC) | 0 | Washington, DC | Gallaudet won - score unknown; At Capitol Park |
| 1886 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 16 | Navy (MD) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 4 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 12 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | L | Hanover (IN) | 4 | Wabash (IN) | 22 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Hanover (IN) | 11 | Butler (IN) | 2 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 82 | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 54 | MIT (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 46 | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 44 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 59 | MIT (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 86 | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 0 | Andover, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 70 | Dartmouth (NH) | 0 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 158 | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 0 | Exeter, NH | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 34 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 38 | Harvard Alumni (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Harvard (MA) | 0 | Princeton (NJ) | 12 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 62 | MIT (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Harvard (MA) | 4 | Yale (CT) | 29 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard (MA) | 28 | Pennsylvania | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Harvard Alumni (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 38 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Harvard Prep School (IL) | 32 | Northwestern (IL) | 4 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1886 | L | Hasbrouke Institute (NJ) | 0 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 14 | Jersey City, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Hastings Law College (CA) | 0 | California | 1 | Berkeley, CA | Hastings Law College Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | Hastings Law College (CA) | 0 | California | 1 | Berkeley, CA | Hastings Law College Forfeits |
| 1886 | W | Haverford (PA) | 32 | Tioga AA (NY) | 0 | Tioga, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Haverford (PA) | 4 | Pennsylvania | 16 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Haverford (PA) | 4 | Lehigh (PA) | 18 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | Haverford (PA) | 6 | Swarthmore | 0 | |||
| 1886 | L | Hoboken AC (NJ) | 12 | Fordham (NY) | 36 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 30 | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 18 | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | L | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 0 | Navy (MD) | 6 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 14 | Navy (MD) | 15 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | T | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 9 | Saint John's (MD) | 9 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 12 | Gallaudet (DC) | 4 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 20 | Swarthmore (PA) | 12 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 24 | Rutgers (NJ) | 2 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 24 | Dickinson (PA) | 5 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Pennsylvania | 0 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 5 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lafayette (PA) | 10 | Pennsylvania | 20 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Trinity (CT) | 0 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | Wesleyan (CT) | 26 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 26 | Rutgers (NJ) | 10 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 58 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 4 | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 2 | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 8 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Tioga AA (NY) | 25 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 18 | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Princeton Sophomores (NJ) | 22 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 28 | Rutgers Grammar School "Rats" (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Princeton Sophomores (NJ) | 16 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 4 | Pennsylvania | 26 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 26 | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1886 | T | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 28 | Pennsylvania | 0 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 18 | Haverford (PA) | 4 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 4 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Massachusetts | 5 | Amherst (MA) | 15 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Massachusetts | 7 | Williston Seminary (MA) | 6 | Easthampton, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Massachusetts | 6 | Tufts (MA) | 5 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Michigan | 50 | Albion (MI) | 0 | Albion, MI | |
| 1886 | W | Michigan | 24 | Albion (MI) | 0 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1886 | L | Michigan St. | 2 | Albion (MI) | 9 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Michigan St. | 0 | Albion (MI) | 79 | Albion, MI | |
| 1886 | W | Minnesota | 8 | Shattuck School (MN) | 4 | Faribault, MN | |
| 1886 | L | Minnesota | 8 | Shattuck School (MN) | 22 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 54 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 16 | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 18 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 96 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 59 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 6 | Dartmouth (NH) | 11 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1886 | W | MIT (MA) | 1 | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Boston, MA | Tufts Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Amherst (MA) | 18 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | W | MIT (MA) | 22 | Amherst (MA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | T | MIT (MA) | 14 | Williams (MA) | 14 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | MIT (MA) | 22 | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | MIT (MA) | 26 | Tufts (MA) | 8 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Williams (MA) | 21 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | L | MIT (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 62 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Montclair AC (NJ) | 0 | Seton Hall (NJ) | 63 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Mount Auburn AC (OH) | 6 | Cincinnati (OH) | 18 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Mount Auburn AC (OH) | 6 | Cincinnati (OH) | 8 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Mount Bacon Academy (CT) | 0 | Peekskill Military Academy (NY) | 136 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Navy (MD) | 12 | Saint John's (MD) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Navy (MD) | 6 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | Navy (MD) | 0 | Saint John's (MD) | 10 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Navy (MD) | 15 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 14 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | Navy (MD) | 0 | Princeton B Team (NJ) | 30 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | Navy (MD) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 16 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | L | New York (NY) | 0 | Olympic Club (NY) | 66 | Brooklyn, NY | |
| 1886 | T | New York (NY) | 4 | Staten Island Cricket FBC (NY) | 4 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | New York (NY) | 0 | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 36 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | W | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 20 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | W | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 26 | Brooklyn AC (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 84 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | W | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 36 | New York (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Northwestern (IL) | 4 | Harvard Prep School (IL) | 32 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1886 | T | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 12 | California | 12 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 0 | California | 10 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | W | Oakland Reliance FBC (CA) | 7 | California | 4 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Albion (MI) | 1 | ? | Olivet Forfeits |
| 1886 | W | Olympic Club (NY) | 66 | New York (NY) | 0 | Brooklyn, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Orange AC (NJ) | 0 | Seton Hall (NJ) | 32 | Orange, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Orions | 12 | California | 10 | Oakland, CA | |
| 1886 | L | Orions | 2 | California | 29 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | Oxford Club (PA) | 0 | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 44 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Peekskill Military Academy (NY) | 136 | Mount Bacon Academy (CT) | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 64 | Philadelphia Falls of Schuylkill (PA) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 18 | Tioga AA (NY) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 26 | Lehigh (PA) | 4 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 4 | Pennsylvania Alumni | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Princeton (NJ) | 30 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | T | Pennsylvania | 6 | Philadelphia All-Stars (PA) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 9 | Princeton (NJ) | 55 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 14 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 20 | Lafayette (PA) | 10 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 16 | Haverford (PA) | 4 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 6 | Princeton (NJ) | 28 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 65 | Rutgers (NJ) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Yale (CT) | 75 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania | 96 | Vineland AC (NJ) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Lehigh (PA) | 28 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 28 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania Alumni | 0 | Pennsylvania | 4 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | T | Pennsylvania B Team | 6 | Widener (PA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 0 | Tioga AA (NY) | 35 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 44 | Oxford Club (PA) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 10 | Riverton AC (NJ) | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | T | Philadelphia All-Stars (PA) | 6 | Pennsylvania | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Philadelphia Falls of Schuylkill (PA) | 0 | Pennsylvania | 64 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 0 | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 26 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 18 | MIT (MA) | 16 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 18 | Dartmouth (NH) | 11 | Andover, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 86 | Andover, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 26 | Phillips Andover Academy (MA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 18 | Tufts (MA) | 8 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 158 | Exeter, NH | |
| 1886 | L | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 6 | MIT (MA) | 22 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 58 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 61 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 6 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 30 | Pennsylvania | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 55 | Pennsylvania | 9 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 28 | Pennsylvania | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 12 | Harvard (MA) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 76 | Wesleyan (CT) | 6 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | T | Princeton (NJ) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton B Team (NJ) | 30 | Navy (MD) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 8 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 2 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 18 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 16 | Widener (PA) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 68 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 11 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton Sophomores (NJ) | 22 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Princeton Sophomores (NJ) | 16 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Providence HS (RI) | 0 | Brown (RI) | 70 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Queen's College Association Football Club (ON) | 0 | Victorias (ON) | 1 | Kingston, ON (Canada) | |
| 1886 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 1 | Richmond (VA) | 0 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1886 | L | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 1 | Richmond (VA) | 3 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1886 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | Albany Ridgefield AC (NY) | 25 | West Troy, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | Albany Ridgefield AC (NY) | 32 | Albany, NY | |
| 1886 | W | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 11 | Union (NY) | 4 | West Troy, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Richmond (VA) | 0 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 1 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1886 | W | Richmond (VA) | 3 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 1 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1886 | L | Riverton AC (NJ) | 0 | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 10 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Rutgers (NJ) | 2 | Lafayette (PA) | 24 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 58 | Vineland AC (NJ) | 0 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Rutgers (NJ) | 0 | Pennsylvania | 65 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Rutgers (NJ) | 10 | Lafayette (PA) | 26 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Rutgers Grammar School "Rats" (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 28 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Saint John's (MD) | 0 | Navy (MD) | 12 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Saint John's (MD) | 10 | Navy (MD) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1886 | T | Saint John's (MD) | 9 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 9 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1886 | W | Saint Marks School (MA) | 23 | Worcester Academy (MA) | 16 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1886 | L | San Francisco Wasps FBC (CA) | 2 | California | 20 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1886 | L | San Francisco Wasps FBC (CA) | 0 | California | 1 | Berkeley, CA | San Francisco Wasps Forfeits |
| 1886 | W | Seton Hall (NJ) | 32 | Orange AC (NJ) | 0 | Orange, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Seton Hall (NJ) | 63 | Montclair AC (NJ) | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Seton Hall Football Club (NJ) | 32 | South Orange FC (NJ) | 0 | South Orange, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Shattuck School (MN) | 4 | Minnesota | 8 | Faribault, MN | |
| 1886 | W | Shattuck School (MN) | 22 | Minnesota | 8 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1886 | L | South Orange FC (NJ) | 0 | Seton Hall Football Club (NJ) | 32 | South Orange, NJ | |
| 1886 | T | Staten Island AC (NY) | 6 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 6 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1886 | T | Staten Island AC (NY) | 0 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1886 | T | Staten Island Cricket FBC (NY) | 4 | New York (NY) | 4 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Princeton (NJ) | 58 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 6 | Princeton (NJ) | 61 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 44 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 54 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 5 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | T | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 58 | Easton, PA | |
| 1886 | Swarthmore | 0 | Haverford (PA) | 6 | |||
| 1886 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 12 | Lafayette (PA) | 20 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Swarthmore (PA) | 28 | Dickinson (PA) | 15 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Tioga AA (NY) | 0 | Pennsylvania | 18 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Tioga AA (NY) | 35 | Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA | 0 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Tioga AA (NY) | 25 | Lawrenceville School (NJ) | 0 | Lawrenceville, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Tioga AA (NY) | 0 | Haverford (PA) | 32 | Tioga, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Trinity (CT) | 4 | Amherst (MA) | 20 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Trinity (CT) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 12 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Trinity (CT) | 8 | Amherst (MA) | 16 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 82 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Williams (MA) | 33 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 46 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Amherst (MA) | 18 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Amherst (MA) | 22 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Williams (MA) | 61 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 8 | Phillips Exeter Academy (NH) | 18 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 0 | MIT (MA) | 1 | Boston, MA | Tufts Forfeits |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 8 | MIT (MA) | 26 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Tufts (MA) | 5 | Massachusetts | 6 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Albany Medical College (NY) | 8 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1886 | L | Union (NY) | 4 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 11 | West Troy, NY | |
| 1886 | T | Upland HS (PA) | 0 | Chester HS (PA) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Upland HS (PA) | 0 | Widener (PA) | 18 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Vermont | 0 | Dartmouth (NH) | 91 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1886 | W | Victorias (ON) | 1 | Queen's College Association Football Club (ON) | 0 | Kingston, ON (Canada) | |
| 1886 | L | Vineland AC (NJ) | 0 | Rutgers (NJ) | 58 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1886 | L | Vineland AC (NJ) | 6 | Pennsylvania | 96 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | T | Wabash (IN) | 4 | Franklin (IN) | 4 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Wabash (IN) | 8 | Franklin (IN) | 4 | ? | |
| 1886 | W | Wabash (IN) | 22 | Hanover (IN) | 4 | ? | |
| 1886 | T | Wallach School (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Results and score unknown | |
| 1886 | L | Washington Central HS (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 12 | Washington, DC | |
| 1886 | L | Washington Central HS (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Washington, DC | Gallaudet won - score unknown; At Capitol Park |
| 1886 | L | Washington Dupont AC (DC) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Gallaudet won - score unknown | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 75 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 62 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 47 | Amherst (MA) | 0 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Pennsylvania | 14 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 136 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 34 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 26 | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1886 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 6 | Princeton (NJ) | 76 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1886 | T | Widener (PA) | 6 | Pennsylvania B Team | 6 | ? | |
| 1886 | L | Widener (PA) | 0 | Princeton Freshmen (NJ) | 16 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Widener (PA) | 12 | Chester Calumet Cricket FBC (PA) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Widener (PA) | 18 | Upland HS (PA) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1886 | W | Williams (MA) | 33 | Tufts (MA) | 4 | Medford, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Williams (MA) | 61 | Tufts (MA) | 0 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Williams (MA) | 0 | Yale (CT) | 76 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Williams (MA) | 4 | Amherst (MA) | 6 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | T | Williams (MA) | 14 | MIT (MA) | 14 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Williams (MA) | 11 | Amherst (MA) | 0 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Williams (MA) | 21 | MIT (MA) | 0 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Williston Seminary (MA) | 6 | Massachusetts | 7 | Easthampton, MA | |
| 1886 | L | Worcester Academy (MA) | 16 | Saint Marks School (MA) | 23 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 75 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 62 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 96 | MIT (MA) | 0 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 54 | Stevens Tech (NJ) | 0 | Hoboken, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 76 | Williams (MA) | 0 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 136 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 84 | New York Crescent AC (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 75 | Pennsylvania | 0 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1886 | W | Yale (CT) | 29 | Harvard (MA) | 4 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1886 | T | Yale (CT) | 0 | Princeton (NJ) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1886 | W | Yale Freshmen (CT) | 18 | Brooklyn Hills FBC (NY) | 0 | New York, NY |