| 1958 | L | Abilene Christian (TX) | 0 | Southern Mississippi | 22 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Abilene Christian (TX) | 14 | Texas-El Paso | 6 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Abilene Christian (TX) | 28 | West Texas A&M | 21 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Abilene Christian (TX) | 7 | McMurry (TX) | 20 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Abilene Christian (TX) | 6 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 27 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Abilene Christian (TX) | 12 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 22 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Abilene Christian (TX) | 27 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Abilene Christian (TX) | 44 | Texas St. | 18 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Abilene Christian (TX) | 15 | Trinity (TX) | 26 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Abilene Christian (TX) | 49 | Howard Payne (TX) | 30 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 14 | Northern Colorado | 42 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 12 | Colorado College | 20 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 0 | Idaho St. | 26 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 7 | Western New Mexico | 34 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 6 | Colorado School of Mines | 25 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Adams St. (CO) | 21 | Western St. (CO) | 12 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 0 | New Mexico Highlands | 14 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 6 | Eastern New Mexico | 13 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Adams St. (CO) | 7 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 34 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Adrian (MI) | 27 | Ferris St. (MI) | 7 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Adrian (MI) | 0 | Albion (MI) | 39 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Adrian (MI) | 6 | Hillsdale (MI) | 32 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Adrian (MI) | 12 | Alma (MI) | 27 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Adrian (MI) | 0 | Defiance (OH) | 6 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Adrian (MI) | 12 | Olivet (MI) | 7 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Adrian (MI) | 7 | Hope (MI) | 41 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Adrian (MI) | 10 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 7 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 33 | Oklahoma St. | 29 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | T | Air Force (CO) | 13 | Iowa | 13 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 10 | Denver (CO) | 7 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 36 | Colorado St. | 6 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 37 | Detroit (MI) | 6 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 16 | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 16 | Utah | 14 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 21 | Wyoming | 6 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 45 | New Mexico | 7 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force (CO) | 20 | Colorado | 14 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Air Force All-Stars | 60 | Marine Corps All-Stars | 0 | ? | Shuri Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Air Force Team | 20 | Army Team | 0 | Tokyo, Japan | Rice Bowl (3) |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 47 | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Akron (OH) | 0 | Ohio Wesleyan | 13 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 48 | Denison (OH) | 14 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 11 | Heidelberg (OH) | 0 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 18 | Mount Union (OH) | 0 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 8 | Muskingum (OH) | 7 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Akron (OH) | 28 | Wooster (OH) | 20 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Akron (OH) | 6 | Wittenberg (OH) | 28 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Akron (OH) | 0 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 0 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama | 12 | Georgia | 0 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | T | Alabama | 0 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 0 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama | 7 | Tulane (LA) | 13 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama | 29 | Furman (SC) | 6 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama | 3 | Louisiana St. | 13 | Mobile, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama | 7 | Tennessee | 14 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama | 9 | Mississippi St. | 7 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama | 17 | Georgia Tech | 8 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama | 14 | Memphis (TN) | 0 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama | 8 | Auburn (AL) | 14 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 8 | Alabama St. | 20 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 6 | Morehouse (GA) | 14 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 6 | South Carolina St. | 64 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama A&M | 16 | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 6 | Tuskegee (AL) | 18 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 18 | Lane (TN) | 22 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | T | Alabama A&M | 12 | Xavier (LA) | 12 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 6 | Allen (SC) | 44 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama A&M | 14 | Knoxville (TN) | 20 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 20 | Alabama A&M | 8 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 12 | Xavier (LA) | 6 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama St. | 8 | Savannah St. (GA) | 12 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 14 | Lane (TN) | 8 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 10 | Morehouse (GA) | 0 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 12 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 8 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Alabama St. | 20 | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Alabama St. | 20 | Tuskegee (AL) | 24 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Alameda NAS (CA) | 0 | Cal St.-Chico | 46 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Savannah St. (GA) | 0 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Miles (AL) | 20 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Florida N&I | 14 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Albany St. (GA) | 16 | Edward Waters (FL) | 6 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Albany St. (GA) | 32 | Paine (GA) | 0 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Claflin (SC) | 22 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Albany St. (GA) | 30 | Morris (SC) | 12 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Albany St. (GA) | 12 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 16 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 25 | Alma (MI) | 14 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 39 | Adrian (MI) | 0 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 18 | Hope (MI) | 13 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Albion (MI) | 13 | Hillsdale (MI) | 20 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 21 | Wabash (IN) | 0 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 27 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Albion (MI) | 46 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Albion (MI) | 14 | Wooster (OH) | 38 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 12 | Moravian (PA) | 15 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Albright (PA) | 14 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 14 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 20 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 27 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 8 | Lycoming (PA) | 24 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Albright (PA) | 21 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 8 | Gettysburg (PA) | 18 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 14 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 30 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Albright (PA) | 12 | Juniata (PA) | 33 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Albright (PA) | 30 | Scranton (PA) | 14 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | Rust (MS) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | Southern (LA) | 56 | Lorman, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 28 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 9 | Mississippi Valley St. | 13 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Grambling St. (LA) | 48 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Jackson St. (MS) | 69 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | Wiley (TX) | 74 | Lorman, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Alcorn St. (MS) | 8 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 6 | Ithaca (NY) | 26 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 0 | Juniata (PA) | 20 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 14 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 40 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 0 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 0 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 36 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Hobart (NY) | 13 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Trinity (CT) | 18 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Dickinson (PA) | 18 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Allegheny (PA) | 6 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Allegheny (PA) | 6 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 28 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Bethany (WV) | 8 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Allegheny (PA) | 0 | Rochester (NY) | 20 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Allegheny (PA) | 16 | Grove City (PA) | 28 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Thiel (PA) | 12 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Allegheny (PA) | 14 | John Carroll (OH) | 0 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Allen (SC) | 6 | South Carolina St. | 26 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Allen (SC) | 19 | Benedict (SC) | 6 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Allen (SC) | 6 | North Carolina Central | 28 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Allen (SC) | 7 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Allen (SC) | 44 | Alabama A&M | 6 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Allen (SC) | 14 | Florida A&M | 52 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Allen (SC) | 28 | Morris (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Allen (SC) | 3 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 2 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Alma (MI) | 14 | Albion (MI) | 25 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Alma (MI) | 17 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 14 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Alma (MI) | 33 | Ohio Northern | 12 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Alma (MI) | 27 | Adrian (MI) | 12 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Alma (MI) | 26 | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Alma (MI) | 12 | Hope (MI) | 32 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Alma (MI) | 13 | Hillsdale (MI) | 21 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Alma (MI) | 27 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | W | American International (MA) | 18 | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | American International (MA) | 18 | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | American International (MA) | 6 | Connecticut | 55 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | L | American International (MA) | 42 | Southern Connecticut St. | 78 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | American International (MA) | 6 | Northeastern (MA) | 42 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | American International (MA) | 6 | Upsala (NJ) | 0 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | American International (MA) | 24 | Bridgeport (CT) | 26 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | T | American International (MA) | 6 | Springfield (MA) | 6 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | American International (MA) | 38 | Central Connecticut St. | 8 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Amherst (MA) | 7 | Tufts (MA) | 42 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 58 | Union (NY) | 0 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 22 | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 34 | Bowdoin (ME) | 0 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 12 | Springfield (MA) | 0 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 50 | Coast Guard (CT) | 6 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Amherst (MA) | 19 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Amherst (MA) | 7 | Williams (MA) | 12 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Anderson (IN) | 12 | Hanover (IN) | 14 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 26 | Taylor (IN) | 0 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 34 | Defiance (OH) | 8 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 40 | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 34 | Kentucky St. | 0 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 29 | Manchester (IN) | 12 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 55 | Indianapolis (IN) | 7 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 44 | Bethany (WV) | 6 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Anderson (IN) | 31 | North Central (IL) | 18 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Angelo St. (TX) | 6 | Texas-Arlington | 21 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Angelo St. (TX) | 12 | Cameron (OK) | 18 | San Angelo, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 6 | California-Riverside | 33 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 45 | California-Santa Barbara | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 19 | Carbon County JC (UT) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 60 | El Centro JC (CA) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 21 | Oceanside JC (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 10 | Palo Verde JC (CA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 30 | Palomar JC (CA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 21 | Reedley College (CA) | 22 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 48 | West Hills JC (CA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 8 | Long Beach City College (CA) | 28 | Lancaster, CA | Alfafa Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 14 | East Carolina (NC) | 0 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 32 | Elon (NC) | 20 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 13 | Guilford (NC) | 6 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Appalachian St. (NC) | 6 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 28 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 12 | East Tennessee St. | 0 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Appalachian St. (NC) | 22 | Western Carolina (NC) | 32 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 6 | Catawba (NC) | 0 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Appalachian St. (NC) | 0 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 7 | Marion, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Appalachian St. (NC) | 0 | Presbyterian (SC) | 42 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Appalachian St. (NC) | 34 | Tampa (FL) | 26 | Lakeland, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona | 15 | West Texas A&M | 8 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 0 | Tulsa (OK) | 34 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 6 | Texas Tech | 33 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 12 | Colorado | 65 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona | 7 | Utah St. | 6 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 0 | Iowa St. | 14 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 13 | New Mexico | 33 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 16 | Idaho | 24 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona | 14 | Texas-El Paso | 12 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona | 0 | Arizona St. | 47 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 23 | New Mexico St. | 19 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 16 | West Texas A&M | 13 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 27 | Texas-El Paso | 0 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona St. | 6 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 47 | Hawaii | 6 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona St. | 16 | Pacific (CA) | 34 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona St. | 20 | San Jose St. (CA) | 21 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 27 | Detroit (MI) | 6 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 47 | Arizona | 0 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Arizona St. | 42 | Marquette (WI) | 18 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Arizona St. JV | 7 | Western New Mexico | 28 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas | 21 | Texas A&M | 8 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 7 | Texas Christian | 12 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas | 60 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 15 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 0 | Rice (TX) | 24 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 0 | Baylor (TX) | 12 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 14 | Tulsa (OK) | 27 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 6 | Texas | 24 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas | 12 | Mississippi | 14 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas | 13 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 6 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas | 14 | Texas Tech | 8 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas City JC (KS) | 0 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 32 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas St. | 20 | Murray St. (KY) | 14 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas St. | 0 | North Alabama | 19 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas St. | 48 | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas St. | 14 | Tampa (FL) | 20 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas St. | 7 | Louisiana Tech | 14 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas St. | 0 | Mississippi St. | 38 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas St. | 16 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas St. | 7 | Florida | 51 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas St. | 50 | Arkansas Tech | 7 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 13 | Arkansas-Monticello | 7 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas Tech | 12 | Louisiana College | 39 | Stuttgart, AR | Rice Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 21 | Henderson St. (AR) | 6 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 26 | Southern Arkansas | 7 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 12 | Ozarks (AR) | 6 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 59 | Hendrix (AR) | 6 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas Tech | 0 | Central Arkansas | 27 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 18 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 7 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas Tech | 52 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 10 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas Tech | 7 | Arkansas St. | 50 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 13 | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Monticello | 7 | Arkansas Tech | 13 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 33 | Central Arkansas | 13 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 13 | Delta St. (MS) | 7 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 33 | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 35 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 0 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Monticello | 0 | Louisiana Tech | 40 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 21 | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Monticello | 21 | Southern Arkansas | 6 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 13 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 37 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Texas College | 20 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 28 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 6 | Wiley (TX) | 32 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 19 | Lincoln (MO) | 34 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Southern (LA) | 34 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 28 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 14 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 7 | Grambling St. (LA) | 6 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Texas Southern | 40 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 68 | Colgate (NY) | 6 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 26 | Penn St. | 0 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 14 | Rice (TX) | 7 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 14 | Notre Dame (IN) | 2 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 45 | South Carolina | 8 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 35 | Virginia | 6 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Army (NY) | 14 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 14 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 26 | Villanova (PA) | 0 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Army (NY) | 22 | Navy (MD) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Army JV (NY) | 12 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 21 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Army Team | 0 | Air Force Team | 20 | Tokyo, Japan | Rice Bowl (3) |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 6 | Edinboro (PA) | 24 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Findlay (OH) | 14 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 8 | Otterbein (OH) | 23 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 6 | Defiance (OH) | 12 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Wooster (OH) | 19 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 18 | Wilmington (OH) | 20 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ashland (OH) | 21 | Ohio Northern | 18 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 57 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ashland (OH) | 6 | Manchester (IN) | 15 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 6 | Florida | 5 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 30 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 8 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 33 | Mississippi St. | 14 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 8 | Kentucky | 0 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 13 | Tennessee | 0 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | T | Auburn (AL) | 7 | Georgia Tech | 7 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 20 | Maryland | 7 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 21 | Georgia | 6 | Columbus, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 21 | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Auburn (AL) | 14 | Alabama | 8 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 16 | Minnesota-Duluth | 27 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 7 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 12 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 68 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 31 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 13 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 18 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Macalester (MN) | 28 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 14 | Hamline (MN) | 22 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Saint John's (MN) | 8 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 18 | Carroll (WI) | 34 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 12 | Wheaton (IL) | 67 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (IL) | 42 | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 19 | North Central (IL) | 26 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (IL) | 13 | Carthage (WI) | 6 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 6 | Millikin (IL) | 20 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 6 | Illinois Wesleyan | 8 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (IL) | 27 | Lake Forest (IL) | 47 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (SD) | 23 | North Dakota | 10 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (SD) | 6 | South Dakota St. | 20 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (SD) | 26 | Northern Iowa | 15 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (SD) | 20 | Wayne St. (NE) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (SD) | 28 | North Dakota St. | 30 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (SD) | 13 | South Dakota | 12 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Augustana (SD) | 21 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Augustana (SD) | 12 | Morningside (IA) | 20 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Austin (TX) | 7 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 20 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 27 | Mississippi College | 6 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 47 | East Central (OK) | 7 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 33 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 10 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Austin (TX) | 6 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 13 | Denison, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 20 | Henderson St. (AR) | 13 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 54 | Rhodes (TN) | 6 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Austin (TX) | 7 | Eastern New Mexico | 13 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Austin (TX) | 19 | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 12 | Troy (AL) | 10 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 25 | East Tennessee St. | 19 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 26 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Middle Tennessee St. | 12 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 21 | Eastern Illinois | 6 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 6 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 8 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Arkansas St. | 16 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 16 | Western Kentucky | 34 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 13 | North Alabama | 20 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Fort Campbell (KY) | 19 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 20 | Kansas Wesleyan | 7 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 7 | McPherson (KS) | 6 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Baker (KS) | 7 | William Jewell (MO) | 20 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 14 | Friends (KS) | 7 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 6 | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 43 | College of Emporia (KS) | 7 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 14 | Bethany (KS) | 0 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 41 | Bethel (KS) | 20 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Baker (KS) | 6 | Ottawa (KS) | 2 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bakersfield College (CA) | 42 | Mesa St. (CO) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Bakersfield College (CA) | 48 | Cameron (OK) | 6 | Bakersfield, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 50 | Southern Connecticut St. | 22 | Berea, OH | Baldwin-Wallace Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 0 | Heidelberg (OH) | 12 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 26 | Wittenberg (OH) | 6 | Berea, OH | Baldwin-Wallace Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 14 | Kent St. (OH) | 21 | Berea, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 26 | Buffalo (NY) | 0 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 24 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 8 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 12 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 0 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 12 | West Chester (PA) | 69 | Berea, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ball St. (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 14 | Wooster (OH) | 6 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 26 | Indiana St. | 8 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 35 | Evansville (IN) | 16 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 31 | Illinois St. | 14 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Ball St. (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 20 | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Ball St. (IN) | 14 | Butler (IN) | 7 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Baltimore JC (MD) | 6 | Potomac St. (WV) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Baltimore JC (MD) | 0 | Gallaudet (DC) | 26 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | T | Bates (ME) | 14 | Bowdoin (ME) | 14 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bates (ME) | 14 | Tufts (MA) | 24 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Bates (ME) | 18 | Colby (ME) | 25 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bates (ME) | 6 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 18 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Bates (ME) | 27 | Union (NY) | 6 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Bates (ME) | 20 | Middlebury (VT) | 0 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bates (ME) | 0 | Maine | 40 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 0 | Texas Christian | 22 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 8 | Miami (FL) | 14 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 15 | Texas | 20 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 7 | Duke (NC) | 12 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Baylor (TX) | 12 | Arkansas | 0 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Baylor (TX) | 14 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 7 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Baylor (TX) | 26 | Texas Tech | 7 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 27 | Texas A&M | 33 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 29 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 33 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Baylor (TX) | 21 | Rice (TX) | 33 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 0 | Indianapolis (IN) | 12 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Macalester (MN) | 28 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 0 | Loras (IA) | 29 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Lake Forest (IL) | 14 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Northern Illinois | 27 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Beloit (WI) | 25 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Beloit (WI) | 13 | Illinois-Chicago | 7 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Hope (MI) | 26 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 40 | Northern St. (SD) | 7 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 50 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 12 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 48 | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Bemidji St. (MN) | 12 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 13 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 13 | North Dakota | 6 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 36 | Michigan Tech | 21 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 48 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 7 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bemidji St. (MN) | 38 | Winona St. (MN) | 13 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Benedict (SC) | 15 | Miles (AL) | 20 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedict (SC) | 0 | Florida A&M | 68 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedict (SC) | 6 | Allen (SC) | 19 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Benedict (SC) | 30 | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Benedict (SC) | 23 | Morris (SC) | 15 | Sumter, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Benedict (SC) | 20 | Morris Brown (GA) | 14 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Benedict (SC) | 20 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 8 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Benedict (SC) | 24 | Savannah St. (GA) | 12 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Benedict (SC) | 14 | North Carolina Central | 38 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Benedict (SC) | 6 | South Carolina St. | 14 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | North Park (IL) | 34 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 8 | Eureka (IL) | 26 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 14 | Northwestern (WI) | 20 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Concordia (IL) | 6 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 8 | Wisconsin Tech | 12 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 42 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Illinois-Chicago | 18 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 41 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 0 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 34 | Central Oklahoma | 14 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Benedictine (KS) | 14 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 19 | Tulsa, OK | NAIA Semifinal Playoff Game |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 28 | Emporia St. (KS) | 6 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 26 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 19 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 25 | Missouri St. | 21 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 20 | Hastings (NE) | 14 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 27 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 7 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 33 | Washburn (KS) | 2 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 48 | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Benedictine (KS) | 21 | William Jewell (MO) | 20 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (KS) | 7 | College of Emporia (KS) | 16 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (KS) | 7 | McPherson (KS) | 23 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethany (KS) | 26 | Bethel (KS) | 0 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethany (KS) | 20 | Sterling (KS) | 2 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethany (KS) | 13 | Kansas Wesleyan | 0 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (KS) | 0 | Baker (KS) | 14 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (KS) | 14 | Ottawa (KS) | 19 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Bethany (KS) | 7 | Friends (KS) | 7 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethany (WV) | 28 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 20 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 18 | Western Reserve (OH) | 52 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 24 | Grove City (PA) | 26 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 8 | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Bethany (WV) | 7 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 7 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 16 | John Carroll (OH) | 25 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 6 | Anderson (IN) | 44 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Bethany (WV) | 36 | Marietta (OH) | 44 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (KS) | 26 | College of Emporia (KS) | 35 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Bethel (KS) | 6 | Ottawa (KS) | 6 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (KS) | 39 | Kansas Wesleyan | 14 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (KS) | 0 | Bethany (KS) | 26 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (KS) | 14 | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (KS) | 0 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 52 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (KS) | 0 | McPherson (KS) | 34 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (KS) | 21 | Friends (KS) | 7 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (KS) | 20 | Baker (KS) | 41 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (MN) | 8 | Hibbing JC (MN) | 20 | Hibbing, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (MN) | 8 | Lakeland (WI) | 7 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (MN) | 6 | North Iowa Area JC | 7 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (MN) | 19 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 0 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Bethel (MN) | 6 | North Park (IL) | 24 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (MN) | 13 | Northwestern (WI) | 7 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (MN) | 20 | Northland (WI) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bethel (MN) | 32 | Milton (WI) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 38 | Morris (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 8 | Morris Brown (GA) | 44 | Daytona Beach, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 6 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 13 | Daytona Beach, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 0 | South Carolina St. | 24 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 8 | Benedict (SC) | 20 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 0 | Florida A&M | 29 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 20 | Xavier (LA) | 28 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 2 | Allen (SC) | 3 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 26 | Rust (MS) | 18 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 12 | Dillard (LA) | 6 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 30 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 0 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 49 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 12 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 42 | Butler College (TX) | 8 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Bishop (TX) | 8 | Wiley (TX) | 46 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Bishop (TX) | 8 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 18 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 27 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 20 | Texas College | 12 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Bishop (TX) | 51 | Leland (LA) | 0 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | North Dakota Science | 47 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 37 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Bismarck St. (ND) | 6 | Jamestown (ND) | 58 | Bismarck, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Bismarck St. (ND) | 6 | Mayville St. (ND) | 46 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 6 | Bismarck, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 13 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 13 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 23 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 0 | South Dakota-Springfield | 23 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Black Hills St. (SD) | 7 | South Dakota Tech | 7 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 12 | Dakota St. (SD) | 18 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 7 | Northern St. (SD) | 35 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Si Tanka (SD) | 55 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Bloomsburg (PA) | 12 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 12 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bloomsburg (PA) | 32 | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bloomsburg (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 56 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bloomsburg (PA) | 16 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 0 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bloomsburg (PA) | 20 | Shippensburg (PA) | 19 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bloomsburg (PA) | 16 | King's (PA) | 12 | Kingston, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bloomsburg (PA) | 12 | Millersville (PA) | 0 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bloomsburg (PA) | 6 | Lock Haven (PA) | 12 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Blue All-Stars | 16 | Gray All-Stars | 0 | Montgomery, AL | Blue-Gray All-Star Classic |
| 1958 | L | Bluefield St. (WV) | 14 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 28 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Bluefield St. (WV) | 6 | Virginia St. | 14 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Bluefield St. (WV) | 44 | Shaw (NC) | 12 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Bluefield St. (WV) | 22 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Bluefield St. (WV) | 18 | Virginia Union | 0 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Bluefield St. (WV) | 21 | Hampton (VA) | 19 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Bluefield St. (WV) | 0 | West Virginia St. | 0 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Bluefield St. (WV) | 8 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 7 | Wheeling, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 24 | Manchester (IN) | 0 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 34 | Defiance (OH) | 0 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 19 | Centre (KY) | 16 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 42 | Wilmington (OH) | 0 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 14 | Taylor (IN) | 0 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Bluffton (OH) | 6 | Heidelberg (OH) | 20 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 55 | Ohio Northern | 0 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 42 | Findlay (OH) | 30 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bluffton (OH) | 57 | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 51 | Carbon County JC (UT) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 21 | Compton JC (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 75 | Dixie JC (UT) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 29 | Everett JC (WA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 40 | Oakland JC (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 44 | Olympic JC (WA) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 25 | Ricks JC (ID) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 55 | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 22 | Tyler JC (TX) | 0 | Tyler, TX | NJCAA Championship |
| 1958 | W | Boise JC (ID) | 49 | Weber JC (UT) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Boston (MA) | 33 | William & Mary (VA) | 7 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston (MA) | 14 | Navy (MD) | 28 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston (MA) | 0 | Syracuse (NY) | 42 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston (MA) | 36 | West Virginia | 30 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Boston (MA) | 28 | Massachusetts | 14 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston (MA) | 0 | Penn St. | 34 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston (MA) | 8 | Holy Cross (MA) | 16 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston (MA) | 13 | Boston College (MA) | 18 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston (MA) | 36 | Connecticut | 22 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 25 | Pacific (CA) | 12 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston College (MA) | 19 | Villanova (PA) | 21 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 26 | Holy Cross (MA) | 8 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 40 | Detroit (MI) | 0 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 48 | Scranton (PA) | 0 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston College (MA) | 14 | Syracuse (NY) | 24 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 21 | Marquette (WI) | 13 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 6 | Miami (FL) | 2 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Boston College (MA) | 18 | Boston (MA) | 13 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Boston College (MA) | 12 | Clemson (SC) | 34 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | T | Bowdoin (ME) | 14 | Bates (ME) | 14 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 8 | Wesleyan (CT) | 32 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 0 | Maine | 37 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 0 | Amherst (MA) | 34 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 6 | Tufts (MA) | 26 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 28 | Williams (MA) | 48 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowdoin (ME) | 12 | Colby (ME) | 44 | Waterville, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Bowling Green (OH) | 14 | Miami (OH) | 28 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 25 | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 33 | Ohio | 6 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 40 | Western Michigan | 6 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 20 | Wichita St. (KS) | 14 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 27 | Lockbourne AFB (OH) | 6 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 31 | Toledo (OH) | 16 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Bowling Green (OH) | 7 | Kent St. (OH) | 8 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Bowling Green (OH) | 21 | Marshall (WV) | 7 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Bradley (IL) | 6 | Wabash (IN) | 30 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Bradley (IL) | 24 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 19 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Bradley (IL) | 7 | Washington (MO) | 0 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Bradley (IL) | 12 | Northern Iowa | 29 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Bradley (IL) | 19 | Butler (IN) | 39 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | T | Bradley (IL) | 6 | Western Illinois | 6 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Bradley (IL) | 18 | Evansville (IN) | 15 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Bradley (IL) | 12 | Drake (IA) | 14 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | American International (MA) | 18 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Massachusetts | 36 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Bridgeport (CT) | 12 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Brandeis (MA) | 22 | Rhode Island | 52 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Brandeis (MA) | 2 | Colby (ME) | 26 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Brandeis (MA) | 34 | Springfield (MA) | 12 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Brandeis (MA) | 8 | New Hampshire | 18 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 8 | Northeastern (MA) | 36 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Bridgeport (CT) | 42 | Central Connecticut St. | 6 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 12 | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 0 | Hofstra (NY) | 22 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 8 | Norwich (VT) | 24 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 12 | Lycoming (PA) | 20 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Bridgeport (CT) | 26 | American International (MA) | 24 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Bridgeport (CT) | 14 | Upsala (NJ) | 8 | East Orange, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgeport (CT) | 20 | Southern Connecticut St. | 32 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | T | Bridgewater (VA) | 6 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 6 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Guilford (NC) | 28 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Shepherd (WV) | 38 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Bridgewater (VA) | 18 | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 14 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 12 | McDaniel College (MD) | 34 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 6 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 14 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 13 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Bridgton Academy (ME) | 6 | Maine Maritime | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 13 | Utah St. | 6 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Brigham Young (UT) | 6 | Colorado St. | 32 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 36 | New Mexico | 19 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Brigham Young (UT) | 8 | Pacific (CA) | 26 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 29 | Fresno St. (CA) | 7 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 14 | Utah | 7 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Brigham Young (UT) | 6 | North Texas | 12 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 41 | Montana | 12 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Brigham Young (UT) | 22 | Denver (CO) | 7 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Brigham Young (UT) | 14 | Wyoming | 22 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | British Columbia (BC) | 19 | Victoria Drakes | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 19 | Western Washington | 20 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 25 | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 27 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | British Columbia (BC) | 47 | Western Oregon | 26 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | British Columbia (BC) | 13 | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 6 | McGill (QC) | 9 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 6 | Southern Oregon | 25 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 7 | Whitworth (WA) | 28 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | British Columbia (BC) | 14 | Central Washington | 35 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 21 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 20 | Texas Southern | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 7 | Eglin AAB (FL) | 15 | Galveston, TX | Shrimp Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Brooklyn Beachcombers (NY) | 18 | Hunter College Majors (NY) | 6 | New York, NY | Roosevelt Field |
| 1958 | L | Brown (RI) | 18 | Princeton (NJ) | 28 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 35 | Yale (CT) | 29 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 12 | Cornell (NY) | 8 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Brown (RI) | 0 | Dartmouth (NH) | 20 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 22 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Brown (RI) | 20 | Pennsylvania | 21 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 47 | Rhode Island | 6 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 29 | Harvard (MA) | 22 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Brown (RI) | 28 | Colgate (NY) | 6 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 14 | Lehigh (PA) | 35 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 13 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 19 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Bucknell (PA) | 44 | Temple (PA) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Colgate (NY) | 7 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Gettysburg (PA) | 6 | Hershey, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 12 | Rutgers (NJ) | 57 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 6 | Lafayette (PA) | 34 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 8 | Delaware | 28 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Buffalo (NY) | 38 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Buena Vista (IA) | 21 | Central (IA) | 20 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Buena Vista (IA) | 41 | Westmar (IA) | 7 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Buena Vista (IA) | 16 | Simpson (IA) | 0 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Buena Vista (IA) | 7 | Wartburg (IA) | 32 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Buena Vista (IA) | 27 | Parsons (IA) | 7 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Buena Vista (IA) | 0 | Upper Iowa | 13 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Buena Vista (IA) | 0 | Iowa Wesleyan | 17 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Buena Vista (IA) | 20 | Dubuque (IA) | 13 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Buena Vista (IA) | 21 | Luther (IA) | 26 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 54 | Temple (PA) | 6 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 7 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 6 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 44 | Wayne St. (MI) | 14 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 19 | Western Reserve (OH) | 6 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 6 | Harvard (MA) | 3 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Buffalo (NY) | 0 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 26 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 34 | Columbia (NY) | 14 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 34 | Lehigh (PA) | 26 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Buffalo (NY) | 38 | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Bullis Prep School (MD) | 53 | Chowan (NC) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Burlington JC (IA) | 7 | William Penn (IA) | 14 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 28 | Evansville (IN) | 14 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 6 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 30 | DePauw (IN) | 0 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 31 | Indiana St. | 8 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 39 | Bradley (IL) | 19 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 40 | Wabash (IN) | 6 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 34 | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Butler (IN) | 7 | Ball St. (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Butler (IN) | 20 | Washington (MO) | 12 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Butler College (TX) | 6 | Shorter College (AR) | 32 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Butler College (TX) | 6 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 47 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Butler College (TX) | 8 | Bishop (TX) | 42 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Butler College (TX) | 6 | Leland (LA) | 45 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Butler College (TX) | 22 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 24 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Cal Poly-Pomona | 6 | Camp Pendleton (CA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 29 | University of Mexico | 14 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Mexico Poly Institute - White | 14 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 41 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 12 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal Poly-Pomona | 8 | Northern Arizona | 16 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal Poly-Pomona | 18 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 20 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 32 | Occidental (CA) | 20 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Pepperdine (CA) | 22 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Redlands (CA) | 20 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-Pomona | 36 | La Verne (CA) | 0 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 48 | Pacific (OR) | 0 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 53 | College of Idaho | 0 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 16 | Montana St. | 6 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 10 | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 25 | Northern Colorado | 6 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 55 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 0 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 0 | Fresno St. (CA) | 14 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 26 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 2 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 48 | San Diego St. (CA) | 14 | San Luis Obispo, CA | Mustang (Poly) Stadium |
| 1958 | W | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 40 | California-Santa Barbara | 12 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Chico | 0 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 18 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Chico | 22 | Nevada | 18 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Chico | 46 | Alameda NAS (CA) | 0 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Chico | 8 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 28 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Chico | 34 | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Chico | 26 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 20 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 14 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Chico | 8 | California-Davis | 6 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 34 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | Northern Arizona | 40 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 22 | Pepperdine (CA) | 26 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 12 | San Diego St. (CA) | 20 | Long Beach, CA | Veterans Stadium |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 6 | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Long Beach | 28 | Cal St.-Chico | 8 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 0 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 14 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 14 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 26 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Long Beach | 12 | California-Santa Barbara | 7 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach | 2 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 26 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | T | Cal St.-Long Beach | 6 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Long Beach Freshmen | 6 | California-Riverside | 24 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 36 | Mexico Poly Institute - White | 30 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 22 | Pepperdine (CA) | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | At El Centro JC? |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | California-Santa Barbara | 20 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 23 | University of Mexico | 6 | Monterey Park, CA | At East Los Angeles JC |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 8 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 6 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 0 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 55 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 0 | San Diego St. (CA) | 7 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | Fresno St. (CA) | 7 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | T | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 6 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 24 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 27 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Sacramento | 20 | Whittier (CA) | 18 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 18 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 20 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 0 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 9 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 6 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 8 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Sacramento | 26 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 14 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Cal St.-Sacramento | 14 | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 24 | Nevada | 40 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | L | Cal St.-Sacramento | 14 | California-Davis | 22 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California | 8 | Oregon St. | 14 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | W | California | 34 | Washington St. | 14 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California | 20 | UCLA | 17 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California | 36 | Utah | 21 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California | 20 | Pacific (CA) | 24 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California | 12 | Michigan St. | 32 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | W | California | 14 | Southern California | 12 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California | 23 | Oregon | 6 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California | 12 | Washington | 7 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | W | California | 16 | Stanford (CA) | 15 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 34 | Susquehanna (PA) | 12 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 20 | Lock Haven (PA) | 7 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 13 | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 19 | Shippensburg (PA) | 0 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 13 | Indiana (PA) | 0 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 34 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 28 | Clarion (PA) | 0 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | California (PA) | 41 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 6 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | California Tech | 0 | Whittier (CA) | 46 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California Tech | 18 | La Verne (CA) | 39 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | T | California Tech | 42 | US International (CA) | 42 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California Tech | 0 | Redlands (CA) | 52 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California Tech | 8 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 16 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California Tech | 26 | California-Riverside | 7 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California Tech | 6 | Occidental (CA) | 49 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California Tech | 12 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 0 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Davis | 12 | Occidental (CA) | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Davis | 14 | California-Santa Barbara | 8 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Davis | 14 | Nevada | 2 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Davis | 6 | Whittier (CA) | 9 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Davis | 0 | Willamette (OR) | 20 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Davis | 18 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 6 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Davis | 6 | Cal St.-Chico | 8 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Davis | 14 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 27 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Davis | 22 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 14 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | T | California-Davis Freshmen | 12 | California-Riverside | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | California-Davis JV | 8 | San Francisco (CA) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | California-Riverside | 33 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | California-Riverside | 28 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | California-Riverside | 6 | Pomona-Pitzer Freshmen (CA) | 6 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | T | California-Riverside | 12 | California-Davis Freshmen | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | California-Riverside | 29 | US International (CA) | 18 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Riverside | 14 | Chino Institute (CA) | 22 | Chino, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Riverside | 0 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 22 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Riverside | 7 | California Tech | 26 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Riverside | 24 | Cal St.-Long Beach Freshmen | 6 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Santa Barbara | 7 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 45 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | California-Santa Barbara | 6 | Occidental (CA) | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Santa Barbara | 25 | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Santa Barbara | 8 | California-Davis | 14 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Santa Barbara | 20 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Santa Barbara | 25 | San Diego St. (CA) | 0 | Santa Barbara, CA | La Playa Stadium |
| 1958 | L | California-Santa Barbara | 6 | Whittier (CA) | 7 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Santa Barbara | 7 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 12 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | W | California-Santa Barbara | 20 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 14 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | L | California-Santa Barbara | 12 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 40 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 20 | Del Mar JC (TX) | 34 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 7 | Texas-Arlington | 41 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 18 | Wharton County JC (TX) | 21 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Cameron (OK) | 44 | Cisco JC (TX) | 0 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Cameron (OK) | 27 | Ranger JC (TX) | 0 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 6 | Bakersfield College (CA) | 48 | Bakersfield, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 14 | Tyler JC (TX) | 33 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Cameron (OK) | 6 | Victoria JC (TX) | 20 | Victoria, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Cameron (OK) | 26 | Tarleton St. (TX) | 15 | Stephenville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Cameron (OK) | 18 | Angelo St. (TX) | 12 | San Angelo, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Camp Pendleton (CA) | 12 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Capital (OH) | 21 | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Capital (OH) | 15 | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Capital (OH) | 30 | Oberlin (OH) | 21 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Capital (OH) | 18 | Kenyon (OH) | 14 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Capital (OH) | 0 | Mount Union (OH) | 17 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Capital (OH) | 6 | Muskingum (OH) | 35 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Capital (OH) | 8 | Denison (OH) | 39 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Capital (OH) | 18 | Otterbein (OH) | 18 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Carbon County JC (UT) | 12 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Carbon County JC (UT) | 0 | Boise JC (ID) | 51 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Carbon County JC (UT) | 0 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 37 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Carbon County JC (UT) | 13 | Mesa St. (CO) | 40 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Carleton (MN) | 0 | Coe (IA) | 14 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | T | Carleton (MN) | 14 | Cornell College (IA) | 14 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 14 | Grinnell (IA) | 7 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 27 | Monmouth (IL) | 6 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 27 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 21 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 42 | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 24 | Ripon (WI) | 20 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Carleton (MN) | 42 | Knox (IL) | 6 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 6 | Geneva (PA) | 40 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 19 | Bucknell (PA) | 13 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 25 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 14 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 14 | Thiel (PA) | 6 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 15 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 0 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 0 | Indiana (PA) | 21 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 24 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 6 | Westminster (PA) | 0 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (MT) | 58 | Montana Tech | 0 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 7 | Montana St.-Billings | 23 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Westminster College (UT) | 50 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Montana Western | 21 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (MT) | 10 | Eastern Oregon | 0 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 6 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 27 | Montana St.-Northern | 32 | Havre, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (MT) | 12 | Northwest CC (WY) | 46 | Powell, WY | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 34 | Augustana (IL) | 18 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 26 | Illinois Wesleyan | 13 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (WI) | 6 | North Central (IL) | 18 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 32 | Millikin (IL) | 12 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 26 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 13 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 47 | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carroll (WI) | 12 | Lake Forest (IL) | 7 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Carroll (WI) | 12 | Wheaton (IL) | 16 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Carson-Newman (TN) | 13 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 35 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Carson-Newman (TN) | 14 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 28 | Emory, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Carson-Newman (TN) | 13 | Troy (AL) | 6 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Carson-Newman (TN) | 8 | Newberry (SC) | 14 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Carson-Newman (TN) | 20 | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Carson-Newman (TN) | 7 | Southeast Missouri St. | 26 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Carson-Newman (TN) | 12 | Davidson (NC) | 41 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Carson-Newman (TN) | 34 | Georgetown (KY) | 6 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Carson-Newman (TN) | 75 | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 40 | Eureka (IL) | 6 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 21 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 18 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 14 | Illinois-Chicago | 0 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 42 | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Carthage (WI) | 6 | Augustana (IL) | 13 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 40 | Principia (IL) | 7 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 27 | Tarkio (MO) | 7 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Carthage (WI) | 20 | Westmar (IA) | 14 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Carthage (WI) | 20 | William Penn (IA) | 21 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 6 | Ohio Wesleyan | 34 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 7 | Wayne St. (MI) | 7 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 28 | Allegheny (PA) | 6 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 15 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 12 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 6 | Wayne St. (MI) | 21 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 14 | John Carroll (OH) | 32 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 12 | Western Reserve (OH) | 26 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Presbyterian (SC) | 14 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Catawba (NC) | 0 | East Carolina (NC) | 6 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Wofford (SC) | 3 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | T | Catawba (NC) | 6 | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Catawba (NC) | 22 | Davidson (NC) | 17 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Catawba (NC) | 24 | Newberry (SC) | 14 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Catawba (NC) | 0 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 6 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Elon (NC) | 8 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Catawba (NC) | 34 | Guilford (NC) | 16 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Catawba (NC) | 0 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 22 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 20 | Buena Vista (IA) | 21 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Central (IA) | 12 | Simpson (IA) | 12 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 7 | Wartburg (IA) | 26 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 13 | Luther (IA) | 48 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 13 | Dubuque (IA) | 32 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 0 | William Penn (IA) | 21 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 24 | Parsons (IA) | 30 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 7 | Upper Iowa | 27 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Central (IA) | 16 | Iowa Wesleyan | 18 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 27 | Delta St. (MS) | 25 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 14 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Central Arkansas | 13 | Arkansas-Monticello | 33 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 39 | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Central Arkansas | 6 | Tennessee-Martin | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 27 | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 27 | Arkansas Tech | 0 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 33 | Millsaps (MS) | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Central Arkansas | 31 | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | T | Central Connecticut St. | 14 | Massachusetts Maritime | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 6 | Bridgeport (CT) | 42 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 22 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 10 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 6 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 19 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 2 | Kutztown (PA) | 13 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | Southern Connecticut St. | 40 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Central Connecticut St. | 8 | American International (MA) | 38 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 18 | Principia (IL) | 21 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 18 | Principia (IL) | 34 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Central Methodist (MO) | 20 | Illinois College | 19 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 6 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 0 | Illinois College | 20 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 0 | Tarkio (MO) | 37 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Methodist (MO) | 12 | William Penn (IA) | 47 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 27 | Eastern Illinois | 8 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 19 | Hillsdale (MI) | 13 | Saginaw, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 33 | Illinois St. | 6 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Central Michigan | 7 | Louisville (KY) | 40 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 33 | Northern Illinois | 23 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 27 | Northern Michigan | 14 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Central Michigan | 7 | Southern Illinois | 24 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Central Michigan | 23 | Western Illinois | 38 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Central Michigan | 33 | Western Michigan | 32 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 14 | Missouri St. | 19 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 0 | Lincoln (MO) | 41 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 6 | Southeast Missouri St. | 42 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 14 | Missouri S&T | 26 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Central Missouri St. | 26 | Morningside (IA) | 13 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 0 | Emporia St. (KS) | 25 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Central Missouri St. | 19 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 19 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Central Missouri St. | 13 | Truman St. (MO) | 32 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Central Missouri St. | 28 | Northwest Missouri St. | 6 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Central Oklahoma | 6 | Memphis NAS (TN) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Central Oklahoma | 14 | Benedictine (KS) | 34 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Central Oklahoma | 6 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Central Oklahoma | 22 | Langston (OK) | 6 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Central Oklahoma | 8 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Central Oklahoma | 28 | East Central (OK) | 8 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Central Oklahoma | 6 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 20 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Central Oklahoma | 8 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 28 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Central Oklahoma | 18 | Emporia St. (KS) | 20 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 20 | Taylor (IN) | 6 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 26 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Central St. (OH) | 0 | Lincoln (MO) | 38 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 13 | West Virginia St. | 6 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 18 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 12 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 16 | Kentucky St. | 12 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Central St. (OH) | 6 | Tennessee St. | 20 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Central St. (OH) | 26 | Waynesburg (PA) | 13 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 45 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 13 | Ellensburg, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 20 | Puget Sound (WA) | 19 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Central Washington | 13 | Western Washington | 19 | Ellensburg, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 43 | Whitworth (WA) | 13 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 13 | Whitman (WA) | 7 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 27 | Eastern Washington | 6 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | T | Central Washington | 27 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 27 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Central Washington | 35 | British Columbia (BC) | 14 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | Centre (KY) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 20 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Centre (KY) | 27 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 8 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Centre (KY) | 16 | Bluffton (OH) | 19 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Centre (KY) | 7 | Rhodes (TN) | 6 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Centre (KY) | 7 | Wilmington (OH) | 6 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Centre (KY) | 12 | Maryville (TN) | 7 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Centre (KY) | 0 | Georgetown (KY) | 13 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Centre (KY) | 20 | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Cerritos CC (CA) | 27 | California-Riverside | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 12 | Compton JC (CA) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 63 | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 58 | Glendale CC (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 34 | Los Angeles City College (CA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 48 | Los Angeles Pierce JC (CA) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 50 | Pasadena City College (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 66 | Ventura JC (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Cerritos CC (CA) | 59 | Weber JC (UT) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 34 | Doane (NE) | 13 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 32 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 13 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 27 | Wayne St. (NE) | 7 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | South Dakota-Springfield | 20 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 35 | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 45 | Dana (NE) | 6 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 7 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | Peru St. (NE) | 0 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 13 | Shippensburg (PA) | 50 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 14 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Clarion (PA) | 28 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 7 | Millersville (PA) | 41 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Mansfield (PA) | 27 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 6 | New Jersey (NJ) | 58 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 85 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Chino Institute (CA) | 35 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 14 | Chino, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Chino Institute (CA) | 20 | La Verne (CA) | 47 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Chino Institute (CA) | 22 | California-Riverside | 14 | Chino, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 6 | Bullis Prep School (MD) | 53 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 6 | Bullis Prep School (MD) | 53 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 16 | Columbian Prep School (DC) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 16 | Columbian Prep School (DC) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 7 | East Carolina JV (NC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 19 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 19 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 6 | Fork Union Military Academy (VA) | 34 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 0 | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 0 | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 21 | Hargrave Military Academy (VA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Chowan (NC) | 21 | Hargrave Military Academy (VA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 7 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 28 | Richmond Freshmen (VA) | 29 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Chowan (NC) | 12 | Wingate (NC) | 43 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Cincinnati (OH) | 8 | North Texas | 8 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Cincinnati (OH) | 13 | Houston (TX) | 34 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 15 | Tulsa (OK) | 6 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Xavier (OH) | 8 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Cincinnati (OH) | 16 | Wichita St. (KS) | 16 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 12 | Pacific (CA) | 6 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Oklahoma St. | 19 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 15 | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Cincinnati (OH) | 18 | Miami (OH) | 7 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Cisco JC (TX) | 0 | Cameron (OK) | 44 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Richmond (VA) | 20 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 6 | Davidson (NC) | 8 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Citadel (SC) | 38 | Presbyterian (SC) | 0 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 6 | Wofford (SC) | 18 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Newberry (SC) | 16 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Citadel (SC) | 28 | Memphis (TN) | 26 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Citadel (SC) | 24 | Furman (SC) | 6 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Citadel (SC) | 14 | Virginia Military Institute | 6 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 14 | George Washington (DC) | 20 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Georgia | 76 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Claflin (SC) | 28 | Morris (SC) | 12 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Claflin (SC) | 34 | Paine (GA) | 16 | Augusta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Hampton (VA) | 25 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 26 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Livingstone (NC) | 21 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | T | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Florida N&I | 0 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Claflin (SC) | 22 | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Claflin (SC) | 22 | Savannah St. (GA) | 18 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 18 | Redlands (CA) | 34 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 14 | Chino Institute (CA) | 35 | Chino, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 12 | La Verne (CA) | 32 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 16 | El Toro Marines (CA) | 6 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 22 | California-Riverside | 0 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 18 | El Toro Marines (CA) | 14 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 33 | US International (CA) | 14 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 0 | California Tech | 12 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Clarion (PA) | 27 | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 12 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 14 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Clarion (PA) | 28 | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 12 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 20 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 0 | Edinboro (PA) | 19 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 0 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 13 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Clarion (PA) | 12 | Shippensburg (PA) | 7 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 0 | California (PA) | 28 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Clarion (PA) | 6 | Indiana (PA) | 13 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Morehouse (GA) | 0 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 6 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 8 | Griffin, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Xavier (LA) | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 14 | Tuskegee (AL) | 0 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 0 | South Carolina St. | 38 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 8 | Alabama St. | 12 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Savannah St. (GA) | 14 | Savannah, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 0 | Morris Brown (GA) | 3 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 14 | Wake Forest (NC) | 12 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 8 | Maryland | 0 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Clemson (SC) | 0 | Georgia Tech | 13 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 12 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 7 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 20 | Virginia | 15 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 26 | North Carolina | 21 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Clemson (SC) | 6 | South Carolina | 26 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 13 | North Carolina St. | 6 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 34 | Boston College (MA) | 12 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Clemson (SC) | 36 | Furman (SC) | 19 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Coahoma CC (MS) | 19 | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coahoma CC (MS) | 7 | Shorter College (AR) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coahoma CC (MS) | 0 | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coahoma CC (MS) | 6 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 12 | Clarksdale, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Coahoma CC (MS) | 6 | Leland (LA) | 6 | Clarksdale, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Coast Guard (CT) | 8 | Trinity (CT) | 51 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Coast Guard (CT) | 12 | Norwich (VT) | 0 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Coast Guard (CT) | 28 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 8 | New London, CT | Shot Glass Trophy |
| 1958 | L | Coast Guard (CT) | 6 | Wesleyan (CT) | 15 | New London, CT | |
| 1958 | T | Coast Guard (CT) | 30 | Vermont | 30 | New London, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Coast Guard (CT) | 6 | Amherst (MA) | 50 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Coast Guard (CT) | 8 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 14 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Coe (IA) | 21 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 14 | Carleton (MN) | 0 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 12 | Cornell College (IA) | 7 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 14 | Lawrence (WI) | 6 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 14 | Ripon (WI) | 6 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 22 | Knox (IL) | 16 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Coe (IA) | 35 | Monmouth (IL) | 6 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Coe (IA) | 6 | Grinnell (IA) | 21 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 32 | Arkansas City JC (KS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 12 | Dodge City CC (KS) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 20 | El Dorado JC (KS) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 21 | Garden City JC (KS) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 7 | Hutchinson CC (KS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 27 | Independence JC (KS) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 0 | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 42 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 34 | Parsons JC (KS) | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 13 | Pratt JC (KS) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 0 | University Prep School (OK) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Colby (ME) | 16 | Maine | 12 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Colby (ME) | 6 | Williams (MA) | 46 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Colby (ME) | 25 | Bates (ME) | 18 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Colby (ME) | 28 | Springfield (MA) | 8 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Colby (ME) | 26 | Brandeis (MA) | 2 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Colby (ME) | 20 | Trinity (CT) | 30 | Waterville, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Colby (ME) | 44 | Bowdoin (ME) | 12 | Waterville, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 6 | Army (NY) | 68 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 7 | Rutgers (NJ) | 21 | Hamilton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Holy Cross (MA) | 20 | Hamilton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Colgate (NY) | 7 | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Cornell (NY) | 13 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 13 | Princeton (NJ) | 40 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 7 | Yale (CT) | 14 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Syracuse (NY) | 47 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Colgate (NY) | 6 | Brown (RI) | 28 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | W | College All-Stars | 35 | Detroit Lions | 19 | Chicago, IL | Chicago All-Star Football Game |
| 1958 | W | College of Emporia (KS) | 35 | Bethel (KS) | 26 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | W | College of Emporia (KS) | 16 | Bethany (KS) | 7 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | College of Emporia (KS) | 6 | Ottawa (KS) | 26 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | College of Emporia (KS) | 0 | McPherson (KS) | 19 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | College of Emporia (KS) | 28 | Friends (KS) | 14 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | College of Emporia (KS) | 7 | Baker (KS) | 43 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | College of Emporia (KS) | 41 | Sterling (KS) | 14 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | College of Emporia (KS) | 21 | Kansas Wesleyan | 27 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | College of Emporia (KS) | 6 | Missouri Valley | 31 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | W | College of Idaho | 20 | Eastern Oregon | 6 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 0 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 53 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 7 | Whitman (WA) | 26 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | T | College of Idaho | 19 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 19 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 12 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 30 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 6 | Eastern Washington | 20 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | W | College of Idaho | 28 | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 7 | Willamette (OR) | 54 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | L | College of Idaho | 7 | Linfield (OR) | 20 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | College of Idaho | 54 | Western St. (CO) | 12 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado | 7 | Oklahoma | 23 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 31 | Kansas | 0 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado | 9 | Missouri | 33 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 65 | Arizona | 12 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 13 | Kansas St. | 3 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 20 | Iowa St. | 0 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 27 | Nebraska | 16 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado | 7 | Utah | 0 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado | 14 | Colorado St. | 15 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado | 14 | Air Force (CO) | 20 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 18 | Western St. (CO) | 6 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado College | 7 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 13 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 20 | Adams St. (CO) | 12 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 7 | Colorado School of Mines | 6 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 13 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 46 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 12 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado College | 20 | Northern Colorado | 32 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado College | 8 | Idaho St. | 7 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado College | 14 | New Mexico Highlands | 20 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 26 | Western St. (CO) | 12 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado School of Mines | 6 | Colorado College | 7 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado School of Mines | 7 | New Mexico Highlands | 25 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 25 | Adams St. (CO) | 6 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 47 | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 3 | Northern Colorado | 0 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 23 | Idaho St. | 14 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Washburn (KS) | 12 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 7 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado St. | 6 | Air Force (CO) | 36 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 32 | Brigham Young (UT) | 6 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 15 | Colorado | 14 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 9 | Denver (CO) | 8 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 21 | Drake (IA) | 0 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 57 | Montana | 7 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado St. | 12 | New Mexico | 17 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Colorado St. | 20 | Utah | 0 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado St. | 0 | Utah St. | 15 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado St. | 6 | Wyoming | 7 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Colorado St.-Pueblo | 6 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Cornell (NY) | 25 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 8 | Princeton (NJ) | 43 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Dartmouth (NH) | 38 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Columbia (NY) | 13 | Yale (CT) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Brown (RI) | 22 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 26 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 14 | Buffalo (NY) | 34 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Pennsylvania | 42 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Rutgers (NJ) | 61 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Columbian Prep School (DC) | 14 | Chowan (NC) | 16 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Compton JC (CA) | 0 | Boise JC (ID) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Compton JC (CA) | 7 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Compton JC (CA) | 28 | Ventura JC (CA) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Concord (WV) | 14 | Shepherd (WV) | 37 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Concord (WV) | 6 | Glenville St. (WV) | 7 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Concord (WV) | 40 | Maryville (TN) | 12 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Concord (WV) | 7 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 27 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Concord (WV) | 0 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 39 | Richlands, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Concord (WV) | 0 | West Virginia Tech | 51 | Beckley, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Concord (WV) | 14 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 6 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Concord (WV) | 12 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (IL) | 0 | Northwestern (WI) | 27 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (IL) | 6 | Illinois-Chicago | 30 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia (IL) | 6 | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia (IL) | 14 | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (IL) | 0 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 26 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (IL) | 0 | North Park (IL) | 28 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (IL) | 0 | Concordia (NE) | 14 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Peru St. (NE) | 56 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 3 | Nebraska-Kearney | 71 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia (NE) | 26 | Dana (NE) | 12 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 45 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Chadron St. (NE) | 35 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 14 | Doane (NE) | 59 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 14 | Wayne St. (NE) | 61 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 47 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia (NE) | 14 | Concordia (IL) | 0 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 38 | Minnesota-Duluth | 30 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 26 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 14 | Hamline (MN) | 7 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 6 | North Dakota St. | 8 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 18 | Augsburg (MN) | 13 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 13 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 36 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 52 | Macalester (MN) | 0 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 22 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 0 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 40 | Saint John's (MN) | 8 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 34 | New Hampshire | 0 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 55 | American International (MA) | 6 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 38 | Northeastern (MA) | 14 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 28 | Massachusetts | 14 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 41 | Springfield (MA) | 14 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Connecticut | 6 | Yale (CT) | 8 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 21 | Maine | 6 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Connecticut | 0 | Delaware | 28 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Connecticut | 36 | Rhode Island | 8 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Connecticut | 22 | Boston (MA) | 36 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 25 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 21 | Harvard (MA) | 14 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell (NY) | 8 | Brown (RI) | 12 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell (NY) | 0 | Syracuse (NY) | 55 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 13 | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 12 | Yale (CT) | 7 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 34 | Princeton (NJ) | 8 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell (NY) | 15 | Dartmouth (NH) | 32 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell (NY) | 19 | Pennsylvania | 7 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell College (IA) | 12 | Ripon (WI) | 33 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell College (IA) | 8 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 13 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Cornell College (IA) | 14 | Carleton (MN) | 14 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell College (IA) | 7 | Coe (IA) | 12 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell College (IA) | 27 | Knox (IL) | 0 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Cornell College (IA) | 6 | Monmouth (IL) | 14 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell College (IA) | 26 | Grinnell (IA) | 14 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Cornell College (IA) | 15 | Lawrence (WI) | 0 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 18 | Carthage (WI) | 21 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 51 | Eureka (IL) | 7 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | Central Methodist (MO) | 6 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 14 | Missouri Valley | 45 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 0 | Parsons (IA) | 21 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 6 | Graceland (IA) | 27 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | William Jewell (MO) | 34 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | Principia (IL) | 13 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 8 | Illinois College | 0 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 14 | Tarkio (MO) | 2 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 0 | South Dakota Tech | 32 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 0 | Si Tanka (SD) | 32 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Dakota St. (SD) | 18 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 12 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 7 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 18 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 14 | Northern St. (SD) | 20 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Dakota St. (SD) | 40 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 12 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 6 | South Dakota-Springfield | 32 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota St. (SD) | 21 | Yankton (SD) | 40 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 13 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 14 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 7 | Westmar (IA) | 19 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Si Tanka (SD) | 46 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Yankton (SD) | 6 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 12 | South Dakota Tech | 12 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 12 | Dakota St. (SD) | 40 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 20 | Northern St. (SD) | 48 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 6 | South Dakota-Springfield | 38 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 6 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 28 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 12 | Hastings (NE) | 59 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 12 | Concordia (NE) | 26 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 6 | Tarkio (MO) | 19 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 0 | Peru St. (NE) | 62 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 6 | Chadron St. (NE) | 45 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 18 | Doane (NE) | 42 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Dana (NE) | 13 | Nebraska-Kearney | 73 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 0 | Rust (MS) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 8 | Morristown College (TN) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 12 | Tougaloo (MS) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 6 | Edward Waters (FL) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 22 | Yale (CT) | 14 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 13 | Pennsylvania | 12 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 38 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 20 | Brown (RI) | 0 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 20 | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | L | Dartmouth (NH) | 8 | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | L | Dartmouth (NH) | 8 | Harvard (MA) | 16 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 32 | Cornell (NY) | 15 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Dartmouth (NH) | 21 | Princeton (NJ) | 12 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Davidson (NC) | 21 | Wofford (SC) | 20 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Davidson (NC) | 8 | Citadel (SC) | 6 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Davidson (NC) | 16 | William & Mary (VA) | 7 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Davidson (NC) | 7 | Presbyterian (SC) | 6 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Davidson (NC) | 17 | Catawba (NC) | 22 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Davidson (NC) | 41 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 12 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Davidson (NC) | 7 | Virginia Military Institute | 42 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Davidson (NC) | 22 | Richmond (VA) | 27 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Davidson (NC) | 20 | Furman (SC) | 22 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 6 | Salem College (WV) | 0 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Shepherd (WV) | 33 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 13 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Glenville St. (WV) | 30 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 0 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 19 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 20 | Potomac St. (WV) | 6 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Concord (WV) | 12 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Holy Cross (MA) | 26 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Bowling Green (OH) | 25 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 6 | Villanova (PA) | 9 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 8 | Ohio | 27 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Dayton (OH) | 13 | Richmond (VA) | 12 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Dayton (OH) | 26 | Louisville (KY) | 13 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Xavier (OH) | 16 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Miami (OH) | 34 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Dayton (OH) | 7 | Detroit (MI) | 27 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Defiance (OH) | 6 | Waynesburg (PA) | 7 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Defiance (OH) | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 34 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Defiance (OH) | 8 | Anderson (IN) | 34 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Defiance (OH) | 12 | Ashland (OH) | 6 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Defiance (OH) | 6 | Adrian (MI) | 0 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Defiance (OH) | 9 | Findlay (OH) | 19 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Defiance (OH) | 21 | Wilmington (OH) | 12 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Defiance (OH) | 33 | Ohio Northern | 13 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Del Mar JC (TX) | 14 | Henderson JC (TX) | 12 | Longview, TX | Industrial Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Del Mar JC (TX) | 48 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Del Mar JC (TX) | 12 | Texas-Arlington | 12 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Del Mar JC (TX) | 34 | Cameron (OK) | 20 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware | 20 | Rutgers (NJ) | 37 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware | 35 | Temple (PA) | 14 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware | 28 | Massachusetts | 14 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware | 6 | Lafayette (PA) | 7 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware | 7 | Lehigh (PA) | 8 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware | 36 | New Hampshire | 14 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware | 28 | Connecticut | 0 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware | 28 | Bucknell (PA) | 8 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware St. | 46 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware St. | 14 | Hampton (VA) | 28 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware St. | 0 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 44 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware St. | 20 | Howard (DC) | 8 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware St. | 6 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 28 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware St. | 26 | Lincoln (PA) | 8 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware St. | 6 | King's (PA) | 20 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware St. | 0 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 26 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware Valley (PA) | 13 | Gallaudet (DC) | 14 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware Valley (PA) | 13 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 8 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware Valley (PA) | 21 | Lincoln (PA) | 13 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Delaware Valley (PA) | 12 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 12 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware Valley (PA) | 19 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 14 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware Valley (PA) | 12 | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Delaware Valley (PA) | 24 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Delaware Valley (PA) | 0 | New Jersey (NJ) | 40 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 25 | Central Arkansas | 27 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Troy (AL) | 16 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Tennessee-Martin | 14 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 7 | Arkansas-Monticello | 13 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Louisiana-Monroe | 23 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Delta St. (MS) | 6 | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Delta St. (MS) | 13 | Henderson St. (AR) | 6 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Delta St. (MS) | 28 | West Alabama | 0 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Denison (OH) | 0 | Wittenberg (OH) | 37 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Denison (OH) | 15 | Muskingum (OH) | 33 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Denison (OH) | 14 | Akron (OH) | 48 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Denison (OH) | 8 | Wooster (OH) | 27 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Denison (OH) | 27 | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Denison (OH) | 14 | Otterbein (OH) | 0 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Denison (OH) | 6 | Heidelberg (OH) | 26 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Denison (OH) | 39 | Capital (OH) | 8 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Denison (OH) | 35 | Ohio Wesleyan | 14 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 12 | Wyoming | 15 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 7 | Air Force (CO) | 10 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Denver (CO) | 29 | Montana | 0 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 14 | Oklahoma St. | 31 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Denver (CO) | 20 | Utah St. | 8 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 16 | Utah | 20 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 7 | San Jose St. (CA) | 27 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 15 | New Mexico | 21 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 7 | Brigham Young (UT) | 22 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Denver (CO) | 8 | Colorado St. | 9 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Rochester (NY) | 20 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | DePauw (IN) | 16 | Indiana St. | 14 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 30 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 37 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 7 | Wittenberg (OH) | 41 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 8 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 32 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Ball St. (IN) | 20 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | L | DePauw (IN) | 14 | Evansville (IN) | 32 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | DePauw (IN) | 24 | Wabash (IN) | 8 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | T | Detroit (MI) | 14 | Marquette (WI) | 14 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Detroit (MI) | 26 | Quantico Marines (VA) | 13 | Quantico, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Detroit (MI) | 0 | Boston College (MA) | 40 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Detroit (MI) | 0 | Villanova (PA) | 7 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Detroit (MI) | 21 | George Washington (DC) | 6 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Detroit (MI) | 6 | Air Force (CO) | 37 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Detroit (MI) | 31 | Xavier (OH) | 6 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Detroit (MI) | 6 | Arizona St. | 27 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Detroit (MI) | 27 | Dayton (OH) | 7 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Detroit Lions | 19 | College All-Stars | 35 | Chicago, IL | Chicago All-Star Football Game |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson (PA) | 18 | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson (PA) | 12 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Haverford (PA) | 14 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 32 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 14 | Susquehanna (PA) | 39 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson (PA) | 20 | Wagner (NY) | 18 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Dickinson (PA) | 19 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 25 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson (PA) | 34 | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 13 | North Dakota Science | 7 | Wahpeton, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 12 | Minot St. (ND) | 7 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 6 | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | Bismarck, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 7 | Jamestown (ND) | 6 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 20 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 0 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dickinson St. (ND) | 20 | Mayville St. (ND) | 6 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Dickinson St. (ND) | 7 | Valley City St. (ND) | 19 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Dillard (LA) | 34 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Dillard (LA) | 6 | Bishop (TX) | 12 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Dillard (LA) | 24 | Rust (MS) | 8 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Dillard (LA) | 14 | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | T | Dillard (LA) | 12 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 12 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Dillard (LA) | 25 | Fisk (TN) | 8 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Dillard (LA) | 13 | Tuskegee (AL) | 14 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Dillard (LA) | 0 | Texas College | 32 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Dillard (LA) | 6 | Xavier (LA) | 14 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 0 | Howard (DC) | 22 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 21 | Virginia Union | 34 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 8 | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 14 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 19 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 0 | Millersville (PA) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Dixie JC (UT) | 6 | Boise JC (ID) | 75 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Dixie JC (UT) | 12 | Mesa St. (CO) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Doane (NE) | 27 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 20 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 13 | Chadron St. (NE) | 34 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 6 | Peru St. (NE) | 13 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 0 | Nebraska-Kearney | 33 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 13 | Wayne St. (NE) | 20 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 0 | Hastings (NE) | 28 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Doane (NE) | 59 | Concordia (NE) | 14 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Doane (NE) | 42 | Dana (NE) | 18 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Doane (NE) | 7 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 21 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Dodge City CC (KS) | 27 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 20 | Louisville (KY) | 34 | El Paso, TX | Sun Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 16 | Northern Iowa | 20 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Drake (IA) | 28 | Washington (MO) | 21 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 0 | North Texas | 42 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 6 | South Dakota St. | 12 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 0 | Iowa St. | 33 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 0 | Colorado St. | 21 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 0 | Tulsa (OK) | 59 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Drake (IA) | 14 | Bradley (IL) | 12 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drake (IA) | 8 | Wichita St. (KS) | 32 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drake JV (IA) | 13 | Graceland (IA) | 20 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 14 | Scranton (PA) | 33 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 8 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 13 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Juniata (PA) | 52 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Gettysburg (PA) | 27 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Albright (PA) | 21 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 51 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Drexel Institute (PA) | 6 | Widener (PA) | 15 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Drexel Institute (PA) | 20 | McDaniel College (MD) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Dubuque (IA) | 0 | Wartburg (IA) | 21 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Dubuque (IA) | 27 | Luther (IA) | 26 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Dubuque (IA) | 14 | Iowa Wesleyan | 33 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Dubuque (IA) | 7 | Parsons (IA) | 20 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Dubuque (IA) | 32 | William Penn (IA) | 14 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Dubuque (IA) | 32 | Central (IA) | 13 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Dubuque (IA) | 27 | Simpson (IA) | 19 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Dubuque (IA) | 35 | Upper Iowa | 13 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Dubuque (IA) | 13 | Buena Vista (IA) | 20 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 21 | Oklahoma | 48 | Miami, FL | Orange Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 8 | Georgia Tech | 10 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Duke (NC) | 15 | Illinois | 13 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 18 | Louisiana St. | 50 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Duke (NC) | 12 | Baylor (TX) | 7 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 0 | South Carolina | 8 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 12 | Virginia | 15 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Duke (NC) | 7 | Notre Dame (IN) | 9 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Duke (NC) | 20 | North Carolina St. | 13 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Duke (NC) | 29 | Wake Forest (NC) | 0 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Duke (NC) | 7 | North Carolina | 6 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 20 | Oberlin (OH) | 39 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 7 | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Georgetown (KY) | 39 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 7 | Illinois-Chicago | 13 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Taylor (IN) | 28 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 12 | Manchester (IN) | 39 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Earlham (IN) | 12 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 27 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | W | East All-Stars | 26 | West All-Stars | 14 | San Francisco, CA | East-West Shrine Classic |
| 1958 | L | East Carolina (NC) | 0 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 14 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 6 | Catawba (NC) | 0 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | East Carolina (NC) | 14 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 59 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 14 | Elon (NC) | 6 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 12 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 0 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | East Carolina (NC) | 16 | Presbyterian (SC) | 24 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 18 | Western Carolina (NC) | 7 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | East Carolina (NC) | 6 | Newberry (SC) | 28 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 36 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 6 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina (NC) | 20 | Guilford (NC) | 0 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Carolina JV (NC) | 12 | Chowan (NC) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | East Carolina JV (NC) | 12 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 7 | Langston (OK) | 20 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 7 | Austin (TX) | 47 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 7 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 33 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 0 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 36 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | W | East Central (OK) | 18 | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 0 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 26 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 8 | Central Oklahoma | 28 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | L | East Central (OK) | 13 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 33 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | W | East Central (OK) | 7 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 6 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | T | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 12 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 12 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | Shippensburg (PA) | 14 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 8 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 42 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | L | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 49 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 19 | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 6 | Ithaca (NY) | 14 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 14 | Millersville (PA) | 20 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | T | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 16 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | East Tennessee St. | 19 | Morehead St. (KY) | 3 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | East Tennessee St. | 19 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 25 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | East Tennessee St. | 25 | Tennessee Tech | 14 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | East Tennessee St. | 0 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 12 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | East Tennessee St. | 12 | Murray St. (KY) | 6 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | W | East Tennessee St. | 8 | Western Kentucky | 0 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | East Tennessee St. | 6 | Eastern Kentucky | 13 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | W | East Tennessee St. | 24 | Wofford (SC) | 20 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | East Tennessee St. | 20 | Middle Tennessee St. | 27 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 6 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 63 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 7 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 7 | Western New Mexico | 40 | Thatcher, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 8 | Central Michigan | 27 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 12 | Northern Illinois | 24 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Illinois | 20 | Illinois St. | 12 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 8 | Southern Illinois | 29 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Illinois | 30 | Indiana St. | 8 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 6 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 21 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 31 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Illinois | 0 | Western Illinois | 34 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 14 | Western Kentucky | 21 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Kentucky | 14 | Murray St. (KY) | 6 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 19 | Tennessee Tech | 20 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 0 | Middle Tennessee St. | 14 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 2 | Toledo (OH) | 19 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 7 | Louisville (KY) | 20 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Kentucky | 13 | East Tennessee St. | 6 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Kentucky | 9 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 14 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Kentucky | 24 | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Michigan | 15 | Northern Illinois | 7 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Michigan | 21 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 12 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Western Illinois | 27 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Central Michigan | 7 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Michigan | 7 | Hope (MI) | 19 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Illinois St. | 0 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Michigan | 31 | Eastern Illinois | 0 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Michigan | 9 | Southern Illinois | 13 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 3 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Washburn (KS) | 26 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Eastern New Mexico | 7 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 7 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern New Mexico | 74 | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 6 | Western St. (CO) | 16 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 21 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern New Mexico | 13 | Austin (TX) | 7 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern New Mexico | 13 | Adams St. (CO) | 6 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 6 | Northern Colorado | 16 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern New Mexico | 27 | McMurry (TX) | 42 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 6 | College of Idaho | 20 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 7 | Western Oregon | 19 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 12 | Southern Oregon | 19 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 6 | Oregon Tech | 27 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 6 | Whitman (WA) | 33 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 0 | Carroll (MT) | 10 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 12 | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Oregon | 14 | Portland St. (OR) | 34 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Oregon | 20 | Grays Harbor JC (WA) | 13 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Washington | 20 | Whitworth (WA) | 7 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Washington | 21 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Washington | 0 | Western Washington | 6 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Washington | 7 | Idaho St. | 30 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Washington | 20 | College of Idaho | 6 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Washington | 6 | Central Washington | 27 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Eastern Washington | 14 | Puget Sound (WA) | 32 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Eastern Washington | 34 | Southern Oregon | 0 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Edinboro (PA) | 24 | Ashland (OH) | 6 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | Indiana (PA) | 27 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | California (PA) | 13 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Edinboro (PA) | 19 | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Edinboro (PA) | 19 | Clarion (PA) | 0 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Edinboro (PA) | 6 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Edinboro (PA) | 26 | Lock Haven (PA) | 33 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Edinboro (PA) | 26 | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Corry, PA | Beaver Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Edward Waters (FL) | 21 | Florida N&I | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Edward Waters (FL) | 24 | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Edward Waters (FL) | 12 | Voorhees College (SC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Edward Waters (FL) | 6 | Savannah St. (GA) | 24 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Edward Waters (FL) | 34 | South Carolina Trade | 12 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Edward Waters (FL) | 6 | Albany St. (GA) | 16 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Edward Waters (FL) | 28 | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Eglin AAB (FL) | 15 | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 7 | Galveston, TX | Shrimp Bowl |
| 1958 | L | El Centro JC (CA) | 26 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 60 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | El Dorado JC (KS) | 7 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | El Toro Marines (CA) | 18 | La Verne (CA) | 42 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | El Toro Marines (CA) | 6 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 16 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | El Toro Marines (CA) | 14 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 18 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 8 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 12 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 14 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 32 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 0 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 8 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 28 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 36 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 26 | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 24 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 0 | Shaw (NC) | 38 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 38 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 8 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 42 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 7 | Lake Forest (IL) | 68 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 12 | Millikin (IL) | 58 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Augustana (IL) | 42 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 6 | Wheaton (IL) | 90 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Concordia (IL) | 14 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Carroll (WI) | 47 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | North Central (IL) | 86 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Elmhurst (IL) | 7 | Illinois Wesleyan | 47 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Elon (NC) | 15 | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 20 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 32 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Elon (NC) | 21 | Newberry (SC) | 6 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 6 | East Carolina (NC) | 14 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Elon (NC) | 14 | Guilford (NC) | 7 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 16 | Wofford (SC) | 22 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 6 | Presbyterian (SC) | 34 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 8 | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Elon (NC) | 6 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 36 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 13 | West Virginia Tech | 6 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 28 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 14 | Emory, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 6 | Western Carolina (NC) | 0 | Emory, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Emory & Henry (VA) | 0 | Guilford (NC) | 14 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Emory & Henry (VA) | 0 | East Carolina (NC) | 12 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 39 | Concord (WV) | 0 | Richlands, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 26 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 22 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 42 | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Emory & Henry (VA) | 7 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 0 | Marion, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Emory & Henry Freshmen (VA) | 12 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Emporia St. (KS) | 14 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 20 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Emporia St. (KS) | 32 | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Emporia St. (KS) | 6 | Benedictine (KS) | 28 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Emporia St. (KS) | 27 | Washburn (KS) | 6 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Emporia St. (KS) | 25 | Central Missouri St. | 0 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Emporia St. (KS) | 0 | Missouri St. | 14 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Emporia St. (KS) | 13 | Southwestern (KS) | 6 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Emporia St. (KS) | 7 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 7 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Emporia St. (KS) | 20 | Central Oklahoma | 18 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Emporia St. (KS) | 0 | Lincoln (MO) | 21 | Excelsior Springs, MO | Mineral Water Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 6 | Carthage (WI) | 40 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Eureka (IL) | 26 | Benedictine (IL) | 8 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 7 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 51 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 6 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 78 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 0 | William Penn (IA) | 28 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 8 | Illinois College | 20 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 0 | North Park (IL) | 34 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Eureka (IL) | 7 | Principia (IL) | 27 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Evansville (IN) | 14 | Butler (IN) | 28 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Evansville (IN) | 22 | Valparaiso (IN) | 8 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Evansville (IN) | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 28 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Evansville (IN) | 16 | Ball St. (IN) | 35 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Evansville (IN) | 14 | Southern Illinois | 34 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Evansville (IN) | 21 | Indiana St. | 6 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Evansville (IN) | 15 | Bradley (IL) | 18 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Evansville (IN) | 32 | DePauw (IN) | 14 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Evansville (IN) | 27 | Murray St. (KY) | 8 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Everett JC (WA) | 20 | Boise JC (ID) | 29 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fairmont St. (WV) | 6 | Glenville St. (WV) | 18 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fairmont St. (WV) | 31 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 6 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fairmont St. (WV) | 20 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 13 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fairmont St. (WV) | 27 | Concord (WV) | 7 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | T | Fairmont St. (WV) | 7 | Shepherd (WV) | 7 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fairmont St. (WV) | 19 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 0 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fairmont St. (WV) | 26 | Salem College (WV) | 7 | Salem, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Fairmont St. (WV) | 0 | West Virginia Tech | 23 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 28 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 14 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 0 | Howard (DC) | 26 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 0 | Virginia St. | 30 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Hampton (VA) | 18 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 24 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 8 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 18 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 54 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 14 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 42 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Ferris St. (MI) | 7 | Adrian (MI) | 27 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ferris St. (MI) | 7 | Michigan Tech | 35 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ferris St. (MI) | 0 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 13 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Ferris St. (MI) | 6 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Ferris St. (MI) | 20 | Illinois-Chicago | 6 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Ferris St. (MI) | 26 | Illinois College | 7 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ferris St. (MI) | 13 | Grand Rapids JC (MI) | 35 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ferrum JC (VA) | 6 | Chowan (NC) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Ferrum JC (VA) | 13 | Emory & Henry Freshmen (VA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ferrum JC (VA) | 6 | Hargrave Military Academy (VA) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ferrum JC (VA) | 12 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ferrum JC (VA) | 0 | Virginia Military Institute Freshmen | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Ferrum JC (VA) | 7 | Washington & Lee JV (VA) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Ferrum JC (VA) | 26 | Wesley (DE) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Findlay (OH) | 26 | Ohio Northern | 6 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Findlay (OH) | 14 | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Findlay (OH) | 0 | Northern Michigan | 43 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Findlay (OH) | 15 | Muskingum (OH) | 48 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Findlay (OH) | 0 | Otterbein (OH) | 0 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Findlay (OH) | 19 | Defiance (OH) | 9 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Findlay (OH) | 30 | Bluffton (OH) | 42 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Findlay (OH) | 57 | Wilmington (OH) | 6 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Findlay (OH) | 10 | Heidelberg (OH) | 34 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Fisk (TN) | 20 | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Tuskegee (AL) | 26 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Lane (TN) | 8 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Alabama A&M | 16 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 8 | Dillard (LA) | 25 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 8 | Howard (DC) | 28 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Alabama St. | 20 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Fisk (TN) | 22 | Morehouse (GA) | 33 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Florida | 5 | Auburn (AL) | 6 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 7 | Georgia | 6 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 21 | UCLA | 14 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 34 | Tulane (LA) | 14 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida | 7 | Mississippi St. | 14 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | T | Florida | 6 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 6 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida | 7 | Louisiana St. | 10 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 51 | Arkansas St. | 7 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 21 | Florida St. | 7 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida | 12 | Miami (FL) | 9 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida | 3 | Mississippi | 7 | Jacksonville, FL | Gator Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 28 | South Carolina St. | 8 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 68 | Benedict (SC) | 0 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 37 | North Carolina A&T | 22 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 13 | Morris Brown (GA) | 12 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 29 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 0 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 52 | Allen (SC) | 14 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida A&M | 6 | Southern (LA) | 35 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida A&M | 22 | Texas Southern | 18 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida A&M | 8 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 26 | Miami, FL | Orange Blossom Classic |
| 1958 | W | Florida N&I | 24 | Edward Waters (FL) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Florida N&I | 6 | Morris (SC) | 3 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Florida N&I | 22 | Paine (GA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Florida N&I | 14 | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida N&I | 20 | Savannah St. (GA) | 22 | Savannah, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida N&I | 6 | South Carolina Trade | 0 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | T | Florida N&I | 0 | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 43 | Tampa (FL) | 0 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 27 | Wake Forest (NC) | 24 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 17 | Miami (FL) | 6 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida St. | 13 | Georgia | 28 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 22 | Tennessee Tech | 7 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 42 | Furman (SC) | 6 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida St. | 3 | Georgia Tech | 17 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 28 | Virginia Tech | 0 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Florida St. | 10 | Tennessee | 0 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Florida St. | 7 | Florida | 21 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Florida St. | 6 | Oklahoma St. | 15 | Louisville, KY | Bluegrass Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Fork Union Military Academy (VA) | 34 | Chowan (NC) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fork Union Military Academy (VA) | 21 | Wingate (NC) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Campbell (KY) | 19 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 0 | Benedictine (KS) | 41 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 13 | Colorado College | 7 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 6 | Washburn (KS) | 19 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 21 | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 7 | Nebraska-Kearney | 35 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 13 | Northwest Missouri St. | 0 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 16 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 7 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 7 | Emporia St. (KS) | 7 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 14 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 34 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Hays St. JV (KS) | 20 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hood (TX) | 0 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 53 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Hood (TX) | 6 | Texas Southern | 47 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 37 | Carbon County JC (UT) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 25 | Colorado St.-Pueblo | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 14 | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Lewis (CO) | 7 | La Junta JC (CO) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Lewis (CO) | 6 | Mesa St. (CO) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 21 | New Mexico Freshmen | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 23 | Phoenix College (AZ) | 22 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 28 | Scottsbluff JC (NE) | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 14 | Sterling JC (CO) | 2 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Lewis (CO) | 23 | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 18 | Miles (AL) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | Tuskegee (AL) | 6 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 8 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 6 | Griffin, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 22 | Morris Brown (GA) | 12 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 13 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 6 | Daytona Beach, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | Allen (SC) | 7 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | South Carolina St. | 20 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 16 | Albany St. (GA) | 12 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 22 | McDaniel College (MD) | 8 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 8 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 20 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 14 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 25 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 14 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 13 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 32 | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 18 | Tufts (MA) | 28 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 30 | Albright (PA) | 14 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 18 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 13 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 13 | Gettysburg (PA) | 32 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin (IN) | 21 | Indianapolis (IN) | 19 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Earlham (IN) | 7 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Anderson (IN) | 40 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Taylor (IN) | 19 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Georgetown (KY) | 19 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 7 | Manchester (IN) | 21 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 12 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | San Diego St. (CA) | 20 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | California-Santa Barbara | 25 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 6 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Fresno St. (CA) | 7 | Brigham Young (UT) | 29 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | San Diego Marines (CA) | 20 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Fresno St. (CA) | 14 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 0 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Fresno St. (CA) | 7 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 6 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | San Jose St. (CA) | 48 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Fresno St. (CA) | 35 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 0 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | Pacific (CA) | 52 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 0 | Kansas Wesleyan | 27 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 0 | Sterling (KS) | 18 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 7 | Baker (KS) | 14 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 12 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 13 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 14 | College of Emporia (KS) | 28 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 7 | Ottawa (KS) | 39 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 7 | Bethel (KS) | 21 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friends (KS) | 27 | McPherson (KS) | 54 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Friends (KS) | 7 | Bethany (KS) | 7 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Friendship JC (SC) | 13 | Kittrell College (NC) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Friendship JC (SC) | 13 | Morris (SC) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | Morristown College (TN) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 20 | Rock Hill, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | South Carolina Trade | 34 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 0 | Penn St. | 36 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 7 | South Carolina | 32 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 6 | Alabama | 29 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 6 | Florida St. | 42 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 8 | George Washington (DC) | 11 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Furman (SC) | 40 | Wofford (SC) | 39 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 6 | Citadel (SC) | 24 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Furman (SC) | 22 | Davidson (NC) | 20 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Furman (SC) | 19 | Clemson (SC) | 36 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 14 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 13 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 8 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 55 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 16 | Montgomery JC (MD) | 18 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 0 | Bridgewater (VA) | 18 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 8 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | Gallaudet (DC) | 26 | Baltimore JC (MD) | 0 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 26 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Garden City JC (KS) | 19 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 21 | Chowan (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 13 | Wingate (NC) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 0 | Wingate (NC) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Geneva (PA) | 40 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 6 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Geneva (PA) | 12 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 12 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Geneva (PA) | 20 | Indiana (PA) | 14 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Geneva (PA) | 34 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Geneva (PA) | 0 | Muskingum (OH) | 13 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Geneva (PA) | 27 | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Geneva (PA) | 0 | Westminster (PA) | 6 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Geneva (PA) | 40 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 20 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Geneva (PA) | 12 | Lycoming (PA) | 14 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | L | George Washington (DC) | 12 | West Virginia | 35 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | George Washington (DC) | 6 | Richmond (VA) | 26 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | George Washington (DC) | 6 | Detroit (MI) | 21 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | George Washington (DC) | 11 | Furman (SC) | 8 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | W | George Washington (DC) | 7 | William & Mary (VA) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | George Washington (DC) | 8 | Navy (MD) | 28 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | George Washington (DC) | 20 | Citadel (SC) | 14 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | George Washington (DC) | 12 | Wichita St. (KS) | 26 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 35 | Wilmington (OH) | 13 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 33 | Hanover (IN) | 14 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 39 | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 25 | Maryville (TN) | 12 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Georgetown (KY) | 7 | Tennessee-Martin | 33 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 19 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Georgetown (KY) | 13 | Centre (KY) | 0 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Georgetown (KY) | 6 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 34 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 0 | Alabama | 12 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 14 | South Carolina | 24 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 6 | Florida | 7 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia | 28 | Florida St. | 13 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 8 | Texas | 13 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 14 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 21 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia | 28 | Kentucky | 0 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia | 6 | Auburn (AL) | 21 | Columbus, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia | 76 | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia | 16 | Georgia Tech | 3 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Military Academy (GA) | 8 | Maryville (TN) | 6 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Military College | 20 | West Georgia | 0 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Tech | 10 | Duke (NC) | 8 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Tech | 14 | Tulane (LA) | 0 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Tech | 13 | Clemson (SC) | 0 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Tech | 21 | Tennessee | 7 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia Tech | 0 | Kentucky | 13 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Georgia Tech | 17 | Florida St. | 3 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | T | Georgia Tech | 7 | Auburn (AL) | 7 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia Tech | 0 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia Tech | 8 | Alabama | 17 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Georgia Tech | 3 | Georgia | 16 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Gettysburg (PA) | 13 | Lafayette (PA) | 19 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Gettysburg (PA) | 14 | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 20 | Hofstra (NY) | 12 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 27 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 6 | Bucknell (PA) | 0 | Hershey, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 18 | Albright (PA) | 8 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 7 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 6 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 22 | Temple (PA) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Gettysburg (PA) | 32 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 13 | Lancaster, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Glendale CC (CA) | 0 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 58 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Glendale CC (CA) | 12 | Ventura JC (CA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 18 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 6 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 7 | Concord (WV) | 6 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 30 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 13 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Wellsburg, WV | |
| 1958 | T | Glenville St. (WV) | 0 | Potomac St. (WV) | 0 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 20 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 0 | Weston, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Glenville St. (WV) | 14 | Salem College (WV) | 7 | West Union, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Gordon (GA) | 20 | West Georgia | 12 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Graceland (IA) | 20 | Drake JV (IA) | 13 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Graceland (IA) | 22 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Dodge City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Graceland (IA) | 34 | William Penn (IA) | 13 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Graceland (IA) | 20 | Missouri Valley | 39 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Graceland (IA) | 27 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 6 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Graceland (IA) | 7 | Truman St. (MO) | 27 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Graceland (IA) | 0 | William Jewell (MO) | 25 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Graceland (IA) | 13 | Tarkio (MO) | 19 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 21 | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 72 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 8 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Grambling St. (LA) | 7 | Texas Southern | 21 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 7 | Tennessee St. | 6 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 48 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 19 | Wiley (TX) | 15 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Grambling St. (LA) | 6 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 44 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Grambling St. (LA) | 6 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 7 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Grambling St. (LA) | 52 | Mississippi Valley St. | 7 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Grand Rapids JC (MI) | 35 | Ferris St. (MI) | 13 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Grand Rapids JC (MI) | 34 | Olivet (MI) | 12 | Grand Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Gray All-Stars | 0 | Blue All-Stars | 16 | Montgomery, AL | Blue-Gray All-Star Classic |
| 1958 | T | Grinnell (IA) | 12 | Monmouth (IL) | 12 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Grinnell (IA) | 0 | Ripon (WI) | 42 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Grinnell (IA) | 7 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Grinnell (IA) | 7 | Carleton (MN) | 14 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Grinnell (IA) | 25 | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Grinnell (IA) | 14 | Cornell College (IA) | 26 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Grinnell (IA) | 12 | Knox (IL) | 12 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Grinnell (IA) | 21 | Coe (IA) | 6 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Clarion (PA) | 27 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Grove City (PA) | 26 | Bethany (WV) | 24 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Edinboro (PA) | 19 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Grove City (PA) | 15 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 14 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Grove City (PA) | 28 | Allegheny (PA) | 16 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Susquehanna (PA) | 12 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Hiram (OH) | 2 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 0 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 6 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Guilford (NC) | 28 | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 6 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 13 | Boone, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Guilford (NC) | 14 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 0 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 7 | Elon (NC) | 14 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 0 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 30 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 16 | Catawba (NC) | 34 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Guilford (NC) | 15 | Western Carolina (NC) | 0 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Guilford (NC) | 0 | East Carolina (NC) | 20 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 38 | Macalester (MN) | 10 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 26 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 12 | Northern Arizona | 41 | Tucson, AZ | NAIA Semifinal Playoff Game |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 68 | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 34 | Minnesota-Duluth | 20 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 36 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 13 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 18 | Saint John's (MN) | 7 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 24 | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 26 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 12 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 34 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 14 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Hamilton (NY) | 12 | Hobart (NY) | 12 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 20 | Wagner (NY) | 13 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 25 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 6 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 34 | Swarthmore (PA) | 8 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 20 | Haverford (PA) | 6 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Hamilton (NY) | 18 | Union (NY) | 0 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 14 | Macalester (MN) | 34 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Saint John's (MN) | 20 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 7 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 14 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 14 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 28 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Hamline (MN) | 6 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 36 | Saint Paul, MN | Saint Thomas Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Minnesota-Duluth | 22 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Hamline (MN) | 22 | Augsburg (MN) | 14 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 24 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 6 | Guilford (NC) | 0 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 20 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 23 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 20 | Sewanee (TN) | 44 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 14 | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 22 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 26 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 22 | McDaniel College (MD) | 6 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 34 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 8 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 12 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 6 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 24 | Widener (PA) | 18 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 42 | Lincoln (PA) | 0 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 28 | Delaware St. | 14 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Hampton (VA) | 12 | Howard (DC) | 18 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 25 | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 18 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Hampton (VA) | 19 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 21 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 16 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 6 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 21 | Virginia St. | 18 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Hampton (VA) | 0 | Morgan St. (MD) | 60 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Hampton (VA) | 21 | Virginia Union | 12 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Hanover (IN) | 14 | Anderson (IN) | 12 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Hanover (IN) | 14 | Georgetown (KY) | 33 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Franklin (IN) | 6 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Hanover (IN) | 40 | Taylor (IN) | 19 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Hanover (IN) | 20 | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Hanover (IN) | 7 | Wabash (IN) | 24 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Centre (KY) | 20 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Indiana St. | 19 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | Texas-El Paso | 6 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 6 | Louisiana St. | 20 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 15 | Arkansas | 60 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | Arizona St. | 6 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | Tulsa (OK) | 0 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 7 | Baylor (TX) | 14 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 0 | Mississippi | 24 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 13 | Wichita St. (KS) | 6 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 26 | West Texas A&M | 6 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 26 | New Mexico St. | 20 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 6 | Wyoming | 14 | El Paso, TX | Sun Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Hardin-Simmons Freshmen (TX) | 19 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 32 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Hargrave Military Academy (VA) | 20 | Chowan (NC) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Hargrave Military Academy (VA) | 13 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Harvard (MA) | 6 | Pennsylvania | 19 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Harvard (MA) | 14 | Cornell (NY) | 21 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Harvard (MA) | 14 | Princeton (NJ) | 16 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Harvard (MA) | 20 | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Harvard (MA) | 3 | Buffalo (NY) | 6 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Harvard (MA) | 26 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Harvard (MA) | 16 | Dartmouth (NH) | 8 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Harvard (MA) | 22 | Brown (RI) | 29 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Harvard (MA) | 28 | Yale (CT) | 0 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Wayne St. (NE) | 21 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Hastings (NE) | 31 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 0 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Hastings (NE) | 59 | Dana (NE) | 12 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Hastings (NE) | 26 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 6 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Hastings (NE) | 14 | Benedictine (KS) | 20 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Hastings (NE) | 28 | Doane (NE) | 0 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Nebraska-Kearney | 35 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Peru St. (NE) | 17 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Haverford (PA) | 14 | Wagner (NY) | 15 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Haverford (PA) | 38 | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Haverford (PA) | 14 | Dickinson (PA) | 0 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Haverford (PA) | 24 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 38 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Haverford (PA) | 6 | Hamilton (NY) | 20 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Haverford (PA) | 8 | Susquehanna (PA) | 7 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Haverford (PA) | 28 | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 6 | Hawaii Rams | 8 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 20 | Utah | 47 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii | 12 | Hawaii Marines | 8 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 0 | San Diego Marines (CA) | 27 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 0 | Kentucky | 51 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii | 6 | Honolulu All-Stars (HI) | 0 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 6 | Arizona St. | 47 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii | 8 | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii | 12 | Hawaii Rams | 7 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 23 | Hawaii Marines | 28 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii | 6 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 12 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii | 40 | Idaho St. | 19 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii Marines | 8 | Hawaii | 12 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii Marines | 28 | Hawaii | 23 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Hawaii Rams | 8 | Hawaii | 6 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Hawaii Rams | 7 | Hawaii | 12 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 14 | Otterbein (OH) | 7 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Heidelberg (OH) | 20 | Wittenberg (OH) | 27 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 12 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 0 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Heidelberg (OH) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 11 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 20 | Bluffton (OH) | 6 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 39 | Ohio Wesleyan | 21 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 26 | Denison (OH) | 6 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Heidelberg (OH) | 0 | Muskingum (OH) | 22 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Heidelberg (OH) | 34 | Findlay (OH) | 10 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson JC (TX) | 12 | Del Mar JC (TX) | 14 | Longview, TX | Industrial Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Henderson JC (TX) | 13 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Arkansas-Monticello | 13 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Ozarks (AR) | 0 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 6 | Arkansas Tech | 21 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Henderson St. (AR) | 27 | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 13 | Austin (TX) | 20 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Central Arkansas | 27 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Henderson St. (AR) | 38 | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 6 | Delta St. (MS) | 13 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Central Arkansas | 31 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 7 | Rhodes (TN) | 26 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 6 | Ozarks (AR) | 25 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Tennessee-Martin | 34 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Arkansas-Monticello | 33 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 6 | Arkansas Tech | 59 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Henderson St. (AR) | 38 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Hendrix (AR) | 7 | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | T | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 0 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Hibbing JC (MN) | 20 | Bethel (MN) | 8 | Hibbing, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 24 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 44 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 32 | Adrian (MI) | 6 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 20 | Albion (MI) | 13 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 21 | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Hillsdale (MI) | 13 | Central Michigan | 19 | Saginaw, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 21 | Alma (MI) | 13 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Hillsdale (MI) | 13 | Hope (MI) | 16 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hillsdale (MI) | 9 | Northern Michigan | 7 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 47 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Capital (OH) | 15 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Hiram (OH) | 15 | Kenyon (OH) | 14 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 14 | Marietta (OH) | 34 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 6 | Oberlin (OH) | 19 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Otterbein (OH) | 50 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 6 | Mount Union (OH) | 40 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hiram (OH) | 2 | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Hobart (NY) | 0 | Rochester (NY) | 24 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Hobart (NY) | 12 | Hamilton (NY) | 12 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hobart (NY) | 18 | Vermont | 14 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hobart (NY) | 20 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 7 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hobart (NY) | 13 | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hobart (NY) | 42 | Union (NY) | 0 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Hobart (NY) | 12 | Upsala (NJ) | 27 | East Orange, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Hofstra (NY) | 0 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 12 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 34 | Upsala (NJ) | 8 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Hofstra (NY) | 12 | Gettysburg (PA) | 20 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 22 | Bridgeport (CT) | 0 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 34 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Hofstra (NY) | 14 | Northeastern (MA) | 24 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Hofstra (NY) | 0 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 8 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 14 | Springfield (MA) | 13 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 34 | Temple (PA) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Hofstra (NY) | 22 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 0 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 26 | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Syracuse (NY) | 13 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Holy Cross (MA) | 8 | Boston College (MA) | 26 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 20 | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Hamilton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Holy Cross (MA) | 0 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 17 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Dartmouth (NH) | 8 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 16 | Boston (MA) | 8 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Holy Cross (MA) | 0 | Penn St. | 32 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Honolulu All-Stars (HI) | 0 | Hawaii | 6 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 61 | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 14 | Northern Michigan | 13 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Hope (MI) | 13 | Albion (MI) | 18 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 27 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 19 | Eastern Michigan | 7 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 32 | Alma (MI) | 12 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 41 | Adrian (MI) | 7 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 16 | Hillsdale (MI) | 13 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Hope (MI) | 26 | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Houston (TX) | 20 | Tulsa (OK) | 25 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Houston (TX) | 34 | Cincinnati (OH) | 13 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Houston (TX) | 7 | Mississippi | 56 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Houston (TX) | 44 | Wichita St. (KS) | 0 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Houston (TX) | 39 | Texas A&M | 7 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Houston (TX) | 0 | Oklahoma St. | 7 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Houston (TX) | 6 | North Texas | 10 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Houston (TX) | 37 | Miami (FL) | 26 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Houston (TX) | 22 | Texas Tech | 17 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 22 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 26 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 0 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 18 | Hampton (VA) | 12 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Howard (DC) | 8 | Delaware St. | 20 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 20 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Howard (DC) | 0 | Morgan St. (MD) | 48 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 28 | Fisk (TN) | 8 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | T | Howard (DC) | 6 | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Howard (DC) | 40 | Lincoln (PA) | 0 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 6 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 26 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 12 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 32 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 13 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 27 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Howard Payne (TX) | 13 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 7 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 8 | McMurry (TX) | 21 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 7 | Texas St. | 12 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Howard Payne (TX) | 24 | Lamar (TX) | 19 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 6 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 21 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Howard Payne (TX) | 30 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 49 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 18 | Cal St.-Chico | 0 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 13 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 12 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Humboldt St. (CA) | 12 | Nevada | 22 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 9 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 0 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 30 | College of Idaho | 12 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 29 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Humboldt St. (CA) | 6 | California-Davis | 18 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | T | Humboldt St. (CA) | 27 | Central Washington | 27 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 12 | Hawaii | 6 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | W | Humboldt St. (CA) | 20 | Whitworth (WA) | 12 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Hunter College Majors (NY) | 6 | Brooklyn Beachcombers (NY) | 18 | New York, NY | Roosevelt Field |
| 1958 | L | Hunter College Majors (NY) | 6 | Brooklyn Beachcombers (NY) | 18 | New York, NY | Roosevelt Field |
| 1958 | L | Hutchinson CC (KS) | 0 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho | 6 | San Jose St. (CA) | 41 | Boise, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho | 20 | Utah | 0 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho | 14 | Montana | 6 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho | 0 | Washington St. | 8 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho | 0 | Oregon | 27 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho | 10 | Missouri | 14 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho | 6 | Oregon St. | 20 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho | 24 | Arizona | 16 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho | 34 | Utah St. | 7 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho St. | 14 | Northern Colorado | 6 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho St. | 26 | Adams St. (CO) | 0 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho St. | 30 | Eastern Washington | 7 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Idaho St. | 7 | Western St. (CO) | 0 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho St. | 6 | Montana St. | 17 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho St. | 7 | Colorado College | 8 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho St. | 14 | Colorado School of Mines | 23 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho St. | 0 | San Diego (CA) | 24 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Idaho St. | 19 | Hawaii | 40 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois | 8 | Purdue (IN) | 31 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois | 13 | Duke (NC) | 15 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois | 21 | Michigan | 8 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois | 13 | Ohio St. | 19 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois | 14 | UCLA | 18 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois | 20 | Minnesota | 8 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois | 16 | Michigan St. | 0 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois | 12 | Wisconsin | 31 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois | 27 | Northwestern (IL) | 20 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois College | 7 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 40 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois College | 14 | William Penn (IA) | 28 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois College | 19 | Central Methodist (MO) | 20 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois College | 24 | Principia (IL) | 8 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois College | 20 | Central Methodist (MO) | 0 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois College | 20 | Eureka (IL) | 8 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois College | 7 | Ferris St. (MI) | 26 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois College | 0 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 8 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 10 | Western Illinois | 16 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 6 | Central Michigan | 33 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 12 | Eastern Illinois | 20 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 6 | Wabash (IN) | 13 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 14 | Ball St. (IN) | 31 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois St. | 0 | Eastern Michigan | 13 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois St. | 21 | Southern Illinois | 8 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois St. | 33 | Northern Illinois | 18 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois St. | 14 | Illinois Wesleyan | 7 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois Wesleyan | 13 | Millikin (IL) | 6 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois Wesleyan | 13 | Carroll (WI) | 26 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois Wesleyan | 14 | Wheaton (IL) | 37 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois Wesleyan | 14 | Lake Forest (IL) | 7 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois Wesleyan | 0 | North Central (IL) | 15 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois Wesleyan | 8 | Augustana (IL) | 6 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois Wesleyan | 47 | Elmhurst (IL) | 7 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois Wesleyan | 7 | Illinois St. | 14 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois-Chicago | 30 | Concordia (IL) | 6 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois-Chicago | 0 | Carthage (WI) | 14 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois-Chicago | 13 | Earlham (IN) | 7 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois-Chicago | 6 | Ferris St. (MI) | 20 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Illinois-Chicago | 18 | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois-Chicago | 7 | Beloit (WI) | 13 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Illinois-Chicago | 6 | North Park (IL) | 19 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Independence JC (KS) | 12 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana | 6 | Minnesota | 0 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana | 13 | West Virginia | 12 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana | 6 | Michigan St. | 0 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana | 13 | Iowa | 34 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana | 0 | Notre Dame (IN) | 18 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana | 8 | Ohio St. | 49 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana | 12 | Miami (OH) | 7 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana | 8 | Michigan | 6 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Indiana | 15 | Purdue (IN) | 15 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana (PA) | 7 | Westminster (PA) | 34 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana (PA) | 27 | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana (PA) | 14 | Geneva (PA) | 20 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana (PA) | 13 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 0 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana (PA) | 0 | California (PA) | 13 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana (PA) | 21 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 0 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana (PA) | 17 | Lock Haven (PA) | 7 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana (PA) | 13 | Clarion (PA) | 6 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana St. | 14 | Valparaiso (IN) | 12 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 14 | DePauw (IN) | 16 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 8 | Ball St. (IN) | 26 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 8 | Butler (IN) | 31 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 8 | Eastern Illinois | 30 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 6 | Evansville (IN) | 21 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indiana St. | 0 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 44 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indiana St. | 19 | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 19 | Franklin (IN) | 21 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indianapolis (IN) | 12 | Beloit (WI) | 0 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso (IN) | 78 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indianapolis (IN) | 15 | Manchester (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 2 | North Central (IL) | 6 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Alma (MI) | 26 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Hanover (IN) | 20 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Indianapolis (IN) | 7 | Anderson (IN) | 55 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Indianapolis (IN) | 26 | Taylor (IN) | 13 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 37 | Michigan | 14 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Iowa | 13 | Air Force (CO) | 13 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 28 | Minnesota | 6 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 34 | Indiana | 13 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 17 | Texas Christian | 0 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 20 | Wisconsin | 9 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 26 | Northwestern (IL) | 20 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa | 28 | Ohio St. | 38 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa | 31 | Notre Dame (IN) | 21 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa St. | 53 | South Dakota | 0 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 6 | Nebraska | 7 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 0 | Oklahoma | 20 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 0 | Kansas | 7 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa St. | 33 | Drake (IA) | 0 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa St. | 14 | Arizona | 0 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 0 | Colorado | 20 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 6 | Missouri | 14 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa St. | 6 | Kansas St. | 14 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa St. | 9 | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa Wesleyan | 27 | William Jewell (MO) | 33 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 27 | Parsons (IA) | 21 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 33 | Dubuque (IA) | 14 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 14 | Upper Iowa | 6 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 14 | Simpson (IA) | 0 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa Wesleyan | 16 | Luther (IA) | 19 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 17 | Buena Vista (IA) | 0 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Iowa Wesleyan | 19 | Wartburg (IA) | 34 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Iowa Wesleyan | 18 | Central (IA) | 16 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 26 | Alfred (NY) | 6 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 22 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 8 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 46 | King's (PA) | 6 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 27 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 14 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 6 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Ithaca (NY) | 6 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 16 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Ithaca (NY) | 18 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Grambling St. (LA) | 21 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 42 | Mississippi Valley St. | 0 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 23 | Wiley (TX) | 4 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 26 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 0 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Jackson St. (MS) | 14 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 14 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 69 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Jackson St. (MS) | 6 | Southern (LA) | 30 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Kentucky St. | 0 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Tennessee St. | 13 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 35 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 13 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 28 | Maryville (TN) | 8 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Tampa (FL) | 12 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 20 | Troy (AL) | 7 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Louisiana College | 26 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 0 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 55 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Middle Tennessee St. | 18 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 8 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 6 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 22 | West Alabama | 6 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Jamestown (ND) | 58 | Bismarck St. (ND) | 6 | Bismarck, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Jamestown (ND) | 19 | North Dakota Science | 7 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Jamestown (ND) | 0 | Si Tanka (SD) | 34 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Jamestown (ND) | 13 | Valley City St. (ND) | 19 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Jamestown (ND) | 6 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 7 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Jamestown (ND) | 19 | Minot St. (ND) | 0 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Jamestown (ND) | 7 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 0 | Ellendale, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Jamestown (ND) | 28 | Mayville St. (ND) | 12 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 26 | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 26 | Shorter College (AR) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 8 | Tougaloo (MS) | 13 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 0 | Bishop (TX) | 30 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 6 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 54 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 0 | Leland (LA) | 40 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 12 | Coahoma CC (MS) | 6 | Clarksdale, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 24 | Butler College (TX) | 22 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | L | John Carroll (OH) | 12 | Western Reserve (OH) | 31 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | John Carroll (OH) | 7 | Thiel (PA) | 0 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | John Carroll (OH) | 20 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 21 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | John Carroll (OH) | 20 | Wayne St. (MI) | 33 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | John Carroll (OH) | 25 | Bethany (WV) | 16 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | W | John Carroll (OH) | 32 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 14 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | John Carroll (OH) | 0 | Allegheny (PA) | 14 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 12 | Del Mar JC (TX) | 48 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | John Tarleton College (TX) | 32 | Hardin-Simmons Freshmen (TX) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | Henderson JC (TX) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 0 | Kilgore College (TX) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | San Angelo JC (TX) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | Texarkana JC (TX) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 13 | Victoria JC (TX) | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | John Tarleton College (TX) | 14 | Wharton County JC (TX) | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 0 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 13 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 20 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 8 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 24 | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 12 | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 38 | Haverford (PA) | 24 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 8 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 34 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 25 | Dickinson (PA) | 19 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 13 | McDaniel College (MD) | 20 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 14 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 14 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 22 | Livingstone (NC) | 6 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 36 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 28 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 28 | Delaware St. | 6 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 0 | Shaw (NC) | 12 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 0 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 12 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 42 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 14 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 47 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 20 | Alfred (NY) | 0 | Alfred, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 52 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 28 | Moravian (PA) | 6 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 24 | Scranton (PA) | 0 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 27 | Lycoming (PA) | 7 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Juniata (PA) | 21 | Westminster (PA) | 21 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Juniata (PA) | 33 | Albright (PA) | 12 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Hillsdale (MI) | 24 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 14 | Alma (MI) | 17 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 13 | Olivet (MI) | 20 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Hope (MI) | 27 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 20 | Ohio Wesleyan | 35 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Albion (MI) | 27 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 0 | Beloit (WI) | 25 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Kalamazoo (MI) | 7 | Adrian (MI) | 10 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas | 21 | Kansas St. | 12 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas | 0 | Colorado | 31 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas | 29 | Nebraska | 7 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas | 7 | Iowa St. | 0 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas | 0 | Texas Christian | 42 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas | 0 | Oregon St. | 12 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas | 0 | Oklahoma | 43 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas | 14 | Tulane (LA) | 9 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas | 3 | Oklahoma St. | 6 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | T | Kansas | 13 | Missouri | 13 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 12 | Kansas | 21 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 13 | Utah St. | 20 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 7 | Oklahoma St. | 14 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas St. | 23 | Nebraska | 6 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas St. | 17 | Wyoming | 14 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 3 | Colorado | 13 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 8 | Missouri | 32 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 6 | Oklahoma | 40 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas St. | 14 | Iowa St. | 6 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas St. | 7 | Michigan St. | 26 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas Wesleyan | 7 | Baker (KS) | 20 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas Wesleyan | 27 | Friends (KS) | 0 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas Wesleyan | 14 | Bethel (KS) | 39 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas Wesleyan | 14 | Ottawa (KS) | 7 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas Wesleyan | 20 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 15 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas Wesleyan | 0 | Bethany (KS) | 13 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Kansas Wesleyan | 0 | McPherson (KS) | 19 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Kansas Wesleyan | 27 | College of Emporia (KS) | 21 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Kansas Wesleyan | 6 | Southwestern (KS) | 6 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Keesler Field (MS) | 14 | Maxwell Field (AL) | 8 | Key West, FL | Conch Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 32 | Toledo (OH) | 6 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 14 | Ohio | 6 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Louisville (KY) | 21 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Miami (OH) | 35 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 6 | Xavier (OH) | 0 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 21 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 14 | Berea, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 24 | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 8 | Bowling Green (OH) | 7 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kent St. (OH) | 32 | Western Michigan | 6 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kentucky | 33 | Mississippi St. | 12 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | T | Kentucky | 0 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 0 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky | 0 | Auburn (AL) | 8 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Kentucky | 51 | Hawaii | 0 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Kentucky | 13 | Georgia Tech | 0 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky | 6 | Mississippi | 27 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky | 7 | Louisiana St. | 32 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky | 0 | Georgia | 28 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Kentucky | 20 | Xavier (OH) | 6 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Kentucky | 6 | Tennessee | 2 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 2 | Knoxville (TN) | 6 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 6 | Lincoln (MO) | 24 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 0 | Anderson (IN) | 34 | Anderson, IN | |
| 1958 | T | Kentucky St. | 18 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 18 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 12 | Central St. (OH) | 16 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 0 | Morris Brown (GA) | 20 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 0 | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Kentucky St. | 6 | Tennessee St. | 19 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Kenyon (OH) | 12 | Mount Union (OH) | 22 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kenyon (OH) | 16 | Otterbein (OH) | 8 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Kenyon (OH) | 14 | Hiram (OH) | 15 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Kenyon (OH) | 14 | Capital (OH) | 18 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Kenyon (OH) | 0 | Wooster (OH) | 33 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kenyon (OH) | 6 | Marietta (OH) | 0 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kenyon (OH) | 16 | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Kilgore College (TX) | 8 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Kilgore College (TX) | 0 | Texas-Arlington | 21 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 10 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 14 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 7 | West Chester (PA) | 63 | Kingston, PA | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 6 | Ithaca (NY) | 46 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 12 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 16 | Kingston, PA | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 0 | Scranton (PA) | 26 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | King's (PA) | 0 | McDaniel College (MD) | 30 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | King's (PA) | 20 | Delaware St. | 6 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Kittrell College (NC) | 26 | Friendship JC (SC) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Kittrell College (NC) | 0 | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Kittrell College (NC) | 0 | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Kittrell College (NC) | 12 | South Carolina Trade | 8 | Kittrell, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Kittrell College (NC) | 13 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 26 | Kittrell, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Knox (IL) | 20 | Lawrence (WI) | 18 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Knox (IL) | 30 | Monmouth (IL) | 12 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Knox (IL) | 0 | Ripon (WI) | 67 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Knox (IL) | 21 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Knox (IL) | 0 | Cornell College (IA) | 27 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Knox (IL) | 16 | Coe (IA) | 22 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | T | Knox (IL) | 12 | Grinnell (IA) | 12 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Knox (IL) | 6 | Carleton (MN) | 42 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | Fisk (TN) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Knoxville (TN) | 6 | Kentucky St. | 2 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | Morehouse (GA) | 18 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | Benedict (SC) | 30 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 6 | Tuskegee (AL) | 44 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 0 | Xavier (LA) | 28 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Knoxville (TN) | 10 | Lane (TN) | 16 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Knoxville (TN) | 20 | Alabama A&M | 14 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Kutztown (PA) | 16 | Mansfield (PA) | 14 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | Millersville (PA) | 6 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Kutztown (PA) | 13 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Kutztown (PA) | 6 | New Jersey (NJ) | 6 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 19 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Kutztown (PA) | 13 | Central Connecticut St. | 2 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 12 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | La Junta JC (CO) | 13 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | La Verne (CA) | 42 | El Toro Marines (CA) | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | La Verne (CA) | 39 | California Tech | 18 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | W | La Verne (CA) | 32 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 12 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | L | La Verne (CA) | 0 | Northern Arizona | 37 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | La Verne (CA) | 47 | Chino Institute (CA) | 20 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | L | La Verne (CA) | 7 | Redlands (CA) | 18 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | W | La Verne (CA) | 34 | US International (CA) | 6 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | T | La Verne (CA) | 18 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 18 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | La Verne (CA) | 0 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 36 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 19 | Gettysburg (PA) | 13 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 27 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 14 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | Rutgers (NJ) | 18 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 7 | Delaware | 6 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | Dartmouth (NH) | 20 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 35 | Temple (PA) | 0 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lafayette (PA) | 34 | Bucknell (PA) | 6 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lafayette (PA) | 8 | Tufts (MA) | 16 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | T | Lafayette (PA) | 14 | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lake Forest (IL) | 68 | Elmhurst (IL) | 7 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Lake Forest (IL) | 18 | North Central (IL) | 6 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Lake Forest (IL) | 30 | Millikin (IL) | 19 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Lake Forest (IL) | 7 | Illinois Wesleyan | 14 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Lake Forest (IL) | 14 | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lake Forest (IL) | 0 | Wheaton (IL) | 48 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Lake Forest (IL) | 7 | Carroll (WI) | 12 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Lake Forest (IL) | 47 | Augustana (IL) | 27 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 7 | Bethel (MN) | 8 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 6 | Northwestern (WI) | 18 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | North Park (IL) | 19 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Carthage (WI) | 42 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Hillsdale (MI) | 21 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Lakeland (WI) | 13 | Northland (WI) | 7 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Lakeland (WI) | 32 | Milton (WI) | 13 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Wisconsin Tech | 18 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lamar (TX) | 7 | Texas St. | 8 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 35 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 6 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 14 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 0 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 21 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 0 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 26 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 20 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 7 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Lamar (TX) | 19 | Howard Payne (TX) | 24 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lamar (TX) | 46 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 7 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Lane (TN) | 0 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 26 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Lane (TN) | 14 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Lane (TN) | 8 | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Lane (TN) | 8 | Alabama St. | 14 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Lane (TN) | 22 | Alabama A&M | 18 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Lane (TN) | 16 | Miles (AL) | 22 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Lane (TN) | 16 | Knoxville (TN) | 10 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Lane (TN) | 6 | Morris (SC) | 27 | Sumter, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Langston (OK) | 20 | East Central (OK) | 7 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Langston (OK) | 42 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 20 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Langston (OK) | 22 | Texas College | 6 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Langston (OK) | 6 | Central Oklahoma | 22 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Langston (OK) | 14 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 24 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Langston (OK) | 8 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 28 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Langston (OK) | 8 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 18 | Knox (IL) | 20 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Lawrence (WI) | 14 | Monmouth (IL) | 0 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Ripon (WI) | 27 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 6 | Coe (IA) | 14 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Grinnell (IA) | 25 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Carleton (MN) | 42 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 0 | Cornell College (IA) | 15 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Lawrence (WI) | 14 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 35 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 7 | Thiel (PA) | 26 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 14 | Albright (PA) | 14 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 7 | Widener (PA) | 27 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 16 | Upsala (NJ) | 6 | East Orange, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 42 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 14 | Moravian (PA) | 0 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lees-McRae JC (NC) | 0 | Wingate (NC) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Lees-McRae JC (NC) | 12 | Wingate (NC) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 35 | Bucknell (PA) | 14 | Lewisburg, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Gettysburg (PA) | 14 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Lehigh (PA) | 7 | Virginia Military Institute | 7 | Lynchburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 20 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 8 | Delaware | 7 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lehigh (PA) | 47 | Western Reserve (OH) | 0 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 13 | Rutgers (NJ) | 44 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lehigh (PA) | 26 | Buffalo (NY) | 34 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Lehigh (PA) | 14 | Lafayette (PA) | 14 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Leland (LA) | 6 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 26 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Leland (LA) | 0 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 26 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Leland (LA) | 8 | Mississippi Valley St. | 14 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Leland (LA) | 18 | Rust (MS) | 12 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Leland (LA) | 2 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Leland (LA) | 40 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 0 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Leland (LA) | 45 | Butler College (TX) | 6 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | T | Leland (LA) | 6 | Coahoma CC (MS) | 6 | Clarksdale, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Leland (LA) | 0 | Bishop (TX) | 51 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 66 | Maryville (TN) | 7 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 28 | Newberry (SC) | 6 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 59 | East Carolina (NC) | 14 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 28 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 6 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 20 | Wofford (SC) | 0 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 6 | Presbyterian (SC) | 8 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 30 | Guilford (NC) | 0 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 36 | Western Carolina (NC) | 30 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 36 | Elon (NC) | 6 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 22 | Catawba (NC) | 0 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 40 | Whitman (WA) | 27 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 60 | Southern Oregon | 13 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 0 | Willamette (OR) | 27 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | T | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 19 | College of Idaho | 19 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 12 | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 20 | Cal St.-Chico | 26 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 0 | San Diego (CA) | 33 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 6 | Linfield (OR) | 13 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 33 | Pacific (OR) | 13 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 41 | Central Missouri St. | 0 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 38 | Central St. (OH) | 0 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 24 | Kentucky St. | 6 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 46 | Missouri S&T | 0 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 34 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 19 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (MO) | 14 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 21 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 24 | Tennessee St. | 12 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (MO) | 21 | Emporia St. (KS) | 0 | Excelsior Springs, MO | Mineral Water Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 0 | Hampton (VA) | 42 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 12 | New Jersey (NJ) | 38 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Lincoln (PA) | 16 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 13 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 21 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 6 | Virginia Union | 50 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 8 | Delaware St. | 26 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 8 | Shaw (NC) | 54 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lincoln (PA) | 0 | Howard (DC) | 40 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 34 | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 21 | Whitman (WA) | 14 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | T | Linfield (OR) | 7 | Pacific (OR) | 7 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Linfield (OR) | 0 | Willamette (OR) | 33 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 32 | Western Oregon | 6 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 24 | Whitworth (WA) | 13 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 37 | Western Washington | 14 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 13 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 6 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Linfield (OR) | 20 | College of Idaho | 7 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 10 | Voorhees College (SC) | 6 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 28 | Morristown College (TN) | 18 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Livingstone (NC) | 6 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 22 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 38 | Paine (GA) | 0 | Augusta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 21 | Claflin (SC) | 0 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Livingstone (NC) | 2 | South Carolina Trade | 8 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 30 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 14 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Livingstone (NC) | 28 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Lock Haven (PA) | 13 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lock Haven (PA) | 7 | California (PA) | 20 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lock Haven (PA) | 32 | Millersville (PA) | 0 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lock Haven (PA) | 19 | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lock Haven (PA) | 0 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lock Haven (PA) | 33 | Edinboro (PA) | 26 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lock Haven (PA) | 7 | Indiana (PA) | 17 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lock Haven (PA) | 12 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 6 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Lockbourne AFB (OH) | 6 | Bowling Green (OH) | 27 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Long Beach City College (CA) | 28 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 8 | Lancaster, CA | Alfafa Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 6 | Southern Connecticut St. | 42 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 27 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 22 | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 48 | SUNY-Farmingdale (NY) | 0 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 8 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 6 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Hofstra (NY) | 34 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 14 | New Jersey (NJ) | 6 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Ithaca (NY) | 18 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 24 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Loras (IA) | 26 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 22 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Loras (IA) | 18 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Loras (IA) | 18 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 24 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Loras (IA) | 29 | Beloit (WI) | 0 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Loras (IA) | 8 | Winona St. (MN) | 22 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Loras (IA) | 53 | Wisconsin Tech | 0 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Loras (IA) | 38 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 53 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Loras (IA) | 14 | Luther (IA) | 28 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Los Angeles City College (CA) | 12 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 34 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Los Angeles City College (CA) | 20 | Ventura JC (CA) | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Los Angeles Pierce JC (CA) | 8 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 48 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Los Angeles Pierce JC (CA) | 30 | Ventura JC (CA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 68 | Mississippi College | 0 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 13 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 12 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 39 | Arkansas Tech | 12 | Stuttgart, AR | Rice Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana College | 14 | Memphis (TN) | 27 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana College | 0 | McNeese St. (LA) | 7 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 26 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 14 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 39 | West Alabama | 0 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 27 | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 52 | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana College | 21 | Louisiana-Monroe | 12 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 14 | Mississippi | 0 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 20 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 6 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 50 | Duke (NC) | 18 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 41 | Miami (FL) | 0 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 26 | Rice (TX) | 6 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 13 | Alabama | 3 | Mobile, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 32 | Kentucky | 7 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 10 | Florida | 7 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 7 | Mississippi St. | 6 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana St. | 62 | Tulane (LA) | 0 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana Tech | 12 | Memphis (TN) | 26 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 17 | McNeese St. (LA) | 0 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 10 | Southeastern Louisiana | 6 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 33 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 0 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana Tech | 0 | Southern Mississippi | 14 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 14 | Arkansas St. | 7 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana Tech | 14 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 18 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 40 | Arkansas-Monticello | 0 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 20 | McMurry (TX) | 12 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana Tech | 46 | Louisiana-Monroe | 21 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 7 | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Louisiana-Monroe | 29 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 27 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 0 | Louisiana Tech | 33 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 6 | Southeastern Louisiana | 14 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 0 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 6 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 27 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Lafayette | 22 | Trinity (TX) | 18 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | McNeese St. (LA) | 9 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Monroe | 6 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 42 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 29 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 33 | Southern Arkansas | 12 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 14 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 23 | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 29 | McNeese St. (LA) | 14 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisiana-Monroe | 22 | Southeastern Louisiana | 8 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Monroe | 12 | Louisiana College | 21 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Louisiana-Monroe | 21 | Louisiana Tech | 46 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Louisville (KY) | 34 | Drake (IA) | 20 | El Paso, TX | Sun Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Louisville (KY) | 7 | Toledo (OH) | 13 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Louisville (KY) | 21 | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Louisville (KY) | 27 | Murray St. (KY) | 0 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Louisville (KY) | 20 | Eastern Kentucky | 7 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Louisville (KY) | 13 | Dayton (OH) | 26 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Louisville (KY) | 40 | Central Michigan | 7 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Louisville (KY) | 6 | Ohio | 23 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Louisville (KY) | 10 | North Texas | 21 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Lower Columbia JC (WA) | 18 | Western Oregon | 28 | Longview, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 47 | Parsons (IA) | 14 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Luther (IA) | 26 | Dubuque (IA) | 27 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 29 | Upper Iowa | 13 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 48 | Central (IA) | 13 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Luther (IA) | 6 | Wartburg (IA) | 6 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 19 | Iowa Wesleyan | 16 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 40 | Simpson (IA) | 7 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 28 | Loras (IA) | 14 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Luther (IA) | 26 | Buena Vista (IA) | 21 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 13 | Widener (PA) | 12 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 41 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 9 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 27 | McDaniel College (MD) | 26 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 24 | Albright (PA) | 8 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 20 | Bridgeport (CT) | 12 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Lycoming (PA) | 7 | Juniata (PA) | 27 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 39 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Lycoming (PA) | 14 | Geneva (PA) | 12 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Macalester (MN) | 34 | Hamline (MN) | 14 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 10 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 38 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Macalester (MN) | 28 | Beloit (WI) | 6 | Beloit, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 0 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 20 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 7 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 26 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 14 | Saint John's (MN) | 41 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Macalester (MN) | 28 | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 0 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 52 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Macalester (MN) | 14 | Minnesota-Duluth | 24 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Maine | 12 | Colby (ME) | 16 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 26 | Vermont | 0 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 37 | Bowdoin (ME) | 0 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 14 | New Hampshire | 0 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 19 | Massachusetts | 6 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 37 | Rhode Island | 8 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Maine | 6 | Connecticut | 21 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Maine | 40 | Bates (ME) | 0 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Maine Central Institute | 12 | Maine Maritime | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Maine Freshmen | 28 | Maine Maritime | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Maine Maritime | 6 | Bridgton Academy (ME) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maine Maritime | 7 | Maine Central Institute | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maine Maritime | 0 | Maine Freshmen | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maine Maritime | 7 | Newport NTS (RI) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maine Maritime | 0 | Quonset NAS (RI) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maine Maritime | 18 | Massachusetts Maritime | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Major-College All-Stars | 56 | Tucson Cowboys | 28 | Tucson, AZ | Optimist Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 24 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 7 | Central St. (OH) | 26 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 7 | Taylor (IN) | 13 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis (IN) | 15 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 7 | Hanover (IN) | 13 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Manchester (IN) | 12 | Anderson (IN) | 29 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Manchester (IN) | 21 | Franklin (IN) | 7 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Manchester (IN) | 39 | Earlham (IN) | 12 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Manchester (IN) | 15 | Ashland (OH) | 6 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 14 | Kutztown (PA) | 16 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 32 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Shippensburg (PA) | 54 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Lock Haven (PA) | 19 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Mansfield (PA) | 7 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 19 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Mansfield (PA) | 27 | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Edinboro (PA) | 26 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Capital (OH) | 21 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Mount Union (OH) | 9 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Marietta (OH) | 16 | Muskingum (OH) | 31 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Marietta (OH) | 34 | Hiram (OH) | 14 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Marietta (OH) | 25 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 12 | Parkersburg, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Marietta (OH) | 0 | Wittenberg (OH) | 36 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Marietta (OH) | 0 | Kenyon (OH) | 6 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Otterbein (OH) | 12 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Marietta (OH) | 44 | Bethany (WV) | 36 | Bethany, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Marine Corps All-Stars | 0 | Air Force All-Stars | 60 | ? | Shuri Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Marion Military Institute (AL) | 39 | West Georgia | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Marquette (WI) | 14 | Detroit (MI) | 14 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Wisconsin | 50 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 8 | Texas Christian | 36 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 8 | Penn St. | 40 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Marquette (WI) | 18 | South Dakota St. | 7 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 13 | Boston College (MA) | 21 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Marquette (WI) | 27 | Pacific (CA) | 18 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Cincinnati (OH) | 15 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Marquette (WI) | 18 | Arizona St. | 42 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Mars Hill JC (NC) | 0 | Wingate (NC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mars Hill JC (NC) | 0 | Wingate (NC) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 6 | Xavier (OH) | 14 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 24 | Western Michigan | 30 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Miami (OH) | 26 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Marshall (WV) | 35 | Toledo (OH) | 12 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Marshall (WV) | 9 | West Virginia St. | 0 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Marshall (WV) | 30 | Morehead St. (KY) | 16 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Kent St. (OH) | 24 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Ohio | 22 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Marshall (WV) | 7 | Bowling Green (OH) | 21 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland | 10 | South Carolina | 6 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 0 | Clemson (SC) | 8 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 14 | Navy (MD) | 40 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 10 | Texas A&M | 14 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 0 | Wake Forest (NC) | 34 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland | 21 | North Carolina St. | 6 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 0 | North Carolina | 27 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland | 7 | Auburn (AL) | 20 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland | 26 | Miami (FL) | 14 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland | 44 | Virginia | 6 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 44 | Delaware St. | 0 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 12 | Morgan St. (MD) | 13 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 20 | Virginia St. | 6 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 14 | North Carolina A&T | 16 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 6 | North Carolina Central | 26 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 42 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 8 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 30 | Shaw (NC) | 8 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 7 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 66 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 8 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 28 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 12 | Concord (WV) | 40 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 12 | Georgetown (KY) | 25 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 6 | Georgia Military Academy (GA) | 8 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 7 | Centre (KY) | 12 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 42 | Maryville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 46 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 75 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Massachusetts | 36 | Brandeis (MA) | 14 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 14 | Delaware | 28 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 14 | Connecticut | 28 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 6 | Maine | 19 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 14 | Boston (MA) | 28 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 8 | Rhode Island | 24 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Massachusetts | 0 | Northeastern (MA) | 12 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Massachusetts | 25 | New Hampshire | 24 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Massachusetts Maritime | 26 | Maine Maritime | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Massachusetts Maritime | 14 | Central Connecticut St. | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Maxwell Field (AL) | 8 | Keesler Field (MS) | 14 | Key West, FL | Conch Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Mayville St. (ND) | 35 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 24 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Mayville St. (ND) | 46 | Bismarck St. (ND) | 6 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Mayville St. (ND) | 7 | North Dakota Science | 6 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Mayville St. (ND) | 7 | Minot St. (ND) | 21 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Mayville St. (ND) | 12 | Valley City St. (ND) | 6 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Mayville St. (ND) | 6 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 20 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Mayville St. (ND) | 12 | Jamestown (ND) | 28 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | W | McCook JC (NE) | 32 | Mesa St. (CO) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 8 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 22 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 0 | Widener (PA) | 13 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 26 | Lycoming (PA) | 27 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 6 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 20 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | W | McDaniel College (MD) | 34 | Bridgewater (VA) | 12 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 6 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 22 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | McDaniel College (MD) | 30 | King's (PA) | 0 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | L | McDaniel College (MD) | 0 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 20 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | McDaniel College (MD) | 20 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 13 | Westminster, MD | |
| 1958 | W | McGill (QC) | 9 | British Columbia (BC) | 6 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 63 | Texas Lutheran | 0 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | McMurry (TX) | 7 | New Mexico St. | 10 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 20 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 7 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 34 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 21 | Howard Payne (TX) | 8 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | L | McMurry (TX) | 6 | Northern Arizona | 13 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | McMurry (TX) | 21 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 39 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 21 | McNeese St. (LA) | 0 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | McMurry (TX) | 12 | Louisiana Tech | 20 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McMurry (TX) | 42 | Eastern New Mexico | 27 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | McNeese St. (LA) | 0 | Louisiana Tech | 17 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McNeese St. (LA) | 20 | North Alabama | 0 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | McNeese St. (LA) | 7 | Louisiana College | 0 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McNeese St. (LA) | 21 | Texas St. | 0 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | McNeese St. (LA) | 6 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 12 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McNeese St. (LA) | 25 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 8 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | L | McNeese St. (LA) | 14 | Louisiana-Monroe | 29 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | L | McNeese St. (LA) | 0 | McMurry (TX) | 21 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | McNeese St. (LA) | 6 | Southeastern Louisiana | 7 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McNeese St. (LA) | 9 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 27 | Ottawa (KS) | 0 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | L | McPherson (KS) | 6 | Baker (KS) | 7 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 23 | Bethany (KS) | 7 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 19 | College of Emporia (KS) | 0 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 33 | Sterling (KS) | 7 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 44 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 13 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 34 | Bethel (KS) | 0 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 19 | Kansas Wesleyan | 0 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | W | McPherson (KS) | 54 | Friends (KS) | 27 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Memphis (TN) | 26 | Louisiana Tech | 12 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis (TN) | 22 | Southern Mississippi | 24 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Memphis (TN) | 27 | Louisiana College | 14 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis (TN) | 6 | Mississippi St. | 28 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis (TN) | 0 | Mississippi | 17 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Memphis (TN) | 13 | Tennessee Tech | 0 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis (TN) | 26 | Citadel (SC) | 28 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Memphis (TN) | 22 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 7 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis (TN) | 0 | Alabama | 14 | Tuscaloosa, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis NAS (TN) | 0 | Central Oklahoma | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Memphis NAS (TN) | 14 | Tennessee-Martin | 16 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Memphis NAS (TN) | 7 | Samford (AL) | 2 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Merchant Marine (NY) | 12 | Upsala (NJ) | 31 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Merchant Marine (NY) | 27 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 0 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Merchant Marine (NY) | 18 | Union (NY) | 0 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Merchant Marine (NY) | 32 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 7 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Merchant Marine (NY) | 6 | Hamilton (NY) | 25 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Merchant Marine (NY) | 22 | Wagner (NY) | 16 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Merchant Marine (NY) | 0 | Rochester (NY) | 20 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Merchant Marine (NY) | 28 | New Jersey (NJ) | 22 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Merchant Marine (NY) | 0 | Hofstra (NY) | 22 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Meridian JC (MS) | 7 | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mesa St. (CO) | 0 | Bakersfield College (CA) | 42 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 40 | Carbon County JC (UT) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 13 | Dixie JC (UT) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 7 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mesa St. (CO) | 27 | McCook JC (NE) | 32 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 13 | Otero JC (CO) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 19 | Pueblo JC (CO) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mesa St. (CO) | 34 | Santa Monica College (CA) | 53 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 8 | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mesa St. (CO) | 21 | Weber JC (UT) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mexico Poly Institute - White | 30 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 36 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | L | Mexico Poly Institute - White | 14 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (FL) | 14 | Baylor (TX) | 8 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (FL) | 2 | Oregon | 0 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 6 | Florida St. | 17 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 0 | Louisiana St. | 41 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 0 | Wisconsin | 20 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 2 | Boston College (MA) | 6 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 15 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 28 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 14 | Maryland | 26 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 26 | Houston (TX) | 37 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (FL) | 9 | Florida | 12 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 28 | Bowling Green (OH) | 14 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (OH) | 8 | Xavier (OH) | 22 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 26 | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 35 | Kent St. (OH) | 0 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 34 | Western Michigan | 20 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 14 | Ohio | 10 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (OH) | 7 | Indiana | 12 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Miami (OH) | 34 | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Miami (OH) | 7 | Cincinnati (OH) | 18 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 14 | Iowa | 37 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Michigan | 12 | Michigan St. | 12 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 8 | Illinois | 21 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 14 | Navy (MD) | 20 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan | 20 | Southern California | 19 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 24 | Northwestern (IL) | 55 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan | 20 | Minnesota | 19 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 6 | Indiana | 8 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan | 14 | Ohio St. | 20 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan St. | 7 | Wisconsin | 9 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Michigan St. | 12 | Michigan | 12 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan St. | 0 | Indiana | 6 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan St. | 22 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 8 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan St. | 32 | California | 12 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan St. | 6 | Purdue (IN) | 14 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan St. | 0 | Illinois | 16 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan St. | 12 | Minnesota | 39 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan St. | 26 | Kansas St. | 7 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan Tech | 26 | Winona St. (MN) | 6 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan Tech | 35 | Ferris St. (MI) | 7 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan Tech | 28 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan Tech | 16 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 26 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan Tech | 21 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 36 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Michigan Tech | 20 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 18 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan Tech | 0 | Northern Michigan | 34 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Michigan Tech | 6 | Northern St. (SD) | 28 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Georgia College | 33 | West Georgia | 0 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 34 | North Alabama | 6 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 10 | Western Kentucky | 7 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 40 | Murray St. (KY) | 0 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 14 | Eastern Kentucky | 0 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 12 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 18 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Middle Tennessee St. | 7 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 18 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 34 | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middle Tennessee St. | 27 | East Tennessee St. | 20 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Middle Tennessee St. | 0 | Tennessee Tech | 14 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Middlebury (VT) | 12 | Norwich (VT) | 6 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Middlebury (VT) | 14 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 13 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Middlebury (VT) | 6 | Vermont | 20 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Middlebury (VT) | 0 | Williams (MA) | 31 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Middlebury (VT) | 8 | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Middlebury (VT) | 0 | Bates (ME) | 20 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Middlebury (VT) | 18 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 20 | Doane (NE) | 27 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 0 | Hastings (NE) | 31 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 0 | Wayne St. (NE) | 48 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 20 | Peru St. (NE) | 27 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 45 | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 6 | Nebraska-Kearney | 28 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 7 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 27 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 7 | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Miles (AL) | 12 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Miles (AL) | 9 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 30 | Morris (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 40 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 20 | Benedict (SC) | 15 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 20 | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 14 | Tuskegee (AL) | 7 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Miles (AL) | 22 | Lane (TN) | 16 | Jackson, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Militarizada | 0 | University of Mexico | 56 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Millersville (PA) | 0 | West Chester (PA) | 68 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 6 | Kutztown (PA) | 0 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Millersville (PA) | 0 | Lock Haven (PA) | 32 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 41 | Cheyney (PA) | 7 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 14 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 0 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 20 | New Jersey (NJ) | 0 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 20 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 14 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Millersville (PA) | 0 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 12 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Millersville (PA) | 14 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 6 | Illinois Wesleyan | 13 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Millikin (IL) | 58 | Elmhurst (IL) | 12 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 19 | Lake Forest (IL) | 30 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 12 | Carroll (WI) | 32 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 20 | Missouri Valley | 35 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Millikin (IL) | 20 | Augustana (IL) | 6 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 0 | Wheaton (IL) | 26 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Millikin (IL) | 0 | North Central (IL) | 18 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | West Alabama | 6 | Livingston, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 47 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Henderson St. (AR) | 27 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 6 | Rhodes (TN) | 7 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 13 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Millsaps (MS) | 14 | Samford (AL) | 9 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Mississippi College | 0 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Millsaps (MS) | 7 | Central Arkansas | 33 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Milton (WI) | 13 | Lakeland (WI) | 32 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Milton (WI) | 6 | Bethel (MN) | 32 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 0 | Indiana | 6 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 7 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 13 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 6 | Iowa | 28 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 3 | Northwestern (IL) | 7 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 21 | Washington | 24 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 8 | Illinois | 20 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 19 | Michigan | 20 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota | 39 | Michigan St. | 12 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota | 12 | Wisconsin | 27 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 26 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 48 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 27 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 8 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 20 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 14 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 13 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 12 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 26 | Michigan Tech | 16 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 0 | Northern Iowa | 25 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 33 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 38 | Winona St. (MN) | 12 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 21 | Lincoln (MO) | 14 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota-Duluth | 27 | Augsburg (MN) | 16 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota-Duluth | 30 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 38 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota-Duluth | 29 | Saint John's (MN) | 42 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota-Duluth | 6 | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Minnesota-Duluth | 20 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 34 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota-Duluth | 22 | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota-Duluth | 7 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 6 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Minnesota-Duluth | 24 | Macalester (MN) | 14 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Minot St. (ND) | 13 | Valley City St. (ND) | 20 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Minot St. (ND) | 7 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 12 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | T | Minot St. (ND) | 19 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 19 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Minot St. (ND) | 21 | Mayville St. (ND) | 7 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Minot St. (ND) | 0 | Jamestown (ND) | 19 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Minot St. (ND) | 14 | North Dakota Science | 12 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Minot St.-Bottineau (ND) | 6 | Montana St.-Northern | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 39 | Texas | 7 | New Orleans, LA | Sugar Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi | 0 | Louisiana St. | 14 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 21 | Trinity (TX) | 0 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 56 | Houston (TX) | 7 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 19 | Tulane (LA) | 8 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 17 | Memphis (TN) | 0 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 27 | Kentucky | 6 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 24 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 0 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 14 | Arkansas | 12 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi | 16 | Tennessee | 18 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 21 | Mississippi St. | 0 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi | 7 | Florida | 3 | Jacksonville, FL | Gator Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 0 | Louisiana College | 68 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 6 | Austin (TX) | 27 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 0 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 31 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 0 | Samford (AL) | 26 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 0 | Ozarks (AR) | 12 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 8 | Rhodes (TN) | 28 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi College | 8 | Sewanee (TN) | 48 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Mississippi College | 0 | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 12 | Miles (AL) | 9 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Lane (TN) | 14 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 66 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 6 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 0 | Jackson St. (MS) | 26 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Mississippi Valley St. | 12 | Columbia, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 14 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 28 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 48 | Rust (MS) | 0 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 12 | Kentucky | 33 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 8 | Tennessee | 13 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 14 | Auburn (AL) | 33 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi St. | 28 | Memphis (TN) | 6 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi St. | 14 | Florida | 7 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi St. | 38 | Arkansas St. | 0 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 7 | Alabama | 9 | Starkville, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 6 | Louisiana St. | 7 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi St. | 0 | Mississippi | 21 | Oxford, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Valley St. | 0 | Jackson St. (MS) | 42 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Valley St. | 7 | Wiley (TX) | 25 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Valley St. | 14 | Leland (LA) | 8 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Valley St. | 13 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 9 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Mississippi Valley St. | 12 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 8 | Columbia, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Valley St. | 0 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 13 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Valley St. | 19 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 59 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Mississippi Valley St. | 7 | Grambling St. (LA) | 52 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri | 31 | Nebraska | 0 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri | 0 | Texas A&M | 12 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri | 33 | Colorado | 9 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri | 19 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 32 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri | 8 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 12 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri | 14 | Idaho | 10 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri | 32 | Kansas St. | 8 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri | 14 | Iowa St. | 6 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri | 0 | Oklahoma | 39 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | T | Missouri | 13 | Kansas | 13 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri S&T | 20 | Northwest Missouri St. | 7 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri S&T | 22 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 21 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri S&T | 36 | Missouri St. | 19 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri S&T | 26 | Central Missouri St. | 14 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri S&T | 3 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 20 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri S&T | 0 | Lincoln (MO) | 46 | Jefferson City, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri S&T | 13 | Washington (MO) | 19 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri S&T | 7 | Southeast Missouri St. | 19 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri S&T | 27 | Truman St. (MO) | 20 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri St. | 19 | Central Missouri St. | 14 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri St. | 7 | Missouri Valley | 34 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri St. | 19 | Missouri S&T | 36 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri St. | 7 | Truman St. (MO) | 39 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri St. | 21 | Benedictine (KS) | 25 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri St. | 7 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 6 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri St. | 14 | Emporia St. (KS) | 0 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri St. | 13 | Northwest Missouri St. | 0 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri St. | 6 | Southeast Missouri St. | 19 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | T | Missouri St. JV | 13 | Missouri Southern St. | 13 | Joplin, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 34 | Missouri St. | 7 | Springfield, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 46 | Tarkio (MO) | 0 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 39 | Graceland (IA) | 20 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 45 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 14 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 35 | Millikin (IL) | 20 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 34 | Ottawa (KS) | 13 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 21 | William Jewell (MO) | 3 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Missouri Valley | 31 | College of Emporia (KS) | 6 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Missouri Valley | 7 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 26 | Orlando, FL | Tangerine Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Moffett Field (CA) | 24 | Southern Oregon | 25 | Medford, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Moffett Field (CA) | 40 | Southern Oregon | 25 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | T | Monmouth (IL) | 12 | Grinnell (IA) | 12 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Monmouth (IL) | 12 | Knox (IL) | 30 | Galesburg, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Monmouth (IL) | 0 | Lawrence (WI) | 14 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Monmouth (IL) | 6 | Carleton (MN) | 27 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Monmouth (IL) | 14 | Cornell College (IA) | 6 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Monmouth (IL) | 20 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 12 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Monmouth (IL) | 6 | Coe (IA) | 35 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Monmouth (IL) | 0 | Ripon (WI) | 53 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 13 | San Diego (CA) | 24 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 7 | Colorado St. | 57 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 16 | New Mexico | 44 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 6 | Idaho | 14 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 0 | Denver (CO) | 29 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 6 | Utah | 20 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 14 | Wyoming | 21 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 14 | Utah St. | 27 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 12 | Brigham Young (UT) | 41 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana | 6 | Montana St. | 20 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 39 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 18 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 31 | San Diego (CA) | 6 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St. | 6 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 16 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 33 | North Dakota St. | 20 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 15 | North Dakota | 8 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 23 | South Dakota St. | 6 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 17 | Idaho St. | 6 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 42 | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. | 20 | Montana | 6 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. Freshmen | 13 | Montana St.-Billings | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St. Freshmen | 39 | Montana Western | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St.-Billings | 6 | Montana St. Freshmen | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Billings | 21 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 20 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Billings | 23 | Carroll (MT) | 7 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Billings | 14 | Montana Western | 0 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Billings | 39 | Montana Tech | 0 | Butte, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St.-Billings | 0 | Westminster College (UT) | 19 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Billings | 52 | Montana St.-Northern | 0 | Havre, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Northern | 26 | Minot St.-Bottineau (ND) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St.-Northern | 7 | Montana Western | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St.-Northern | 13 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 37 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Northern | 21 | Montana Tech | 0 | Butte, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana St.-Northern | 0 | Montana St.-Billings | 52 | Havre, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana St.-Northern | 32 | Carroll (MT) | 27 | Havre, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Tech | 0 | Carroll (MT) | 58 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Tech | 0 | Montana St.-Northern | 21 | Butte, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Tech | 0 | Montana St.-Billings | 39 | Butte, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Tech | 0 | Montana Western | 54 | Dillon, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Tech | 0 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 58 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Western | 7 | Montana St. Freshmen | 39 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana Western | 28 | Montana St.-Northern | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana Western | 7 | Ricks JC (ID) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montana Western | 26 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Western | 0 | Montana St.-Billings | 14 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana Western | 21 | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Montana Western | 54 | Montana Tech | 0 | Dillon, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Montana Western | 12 | Westminster College (UT) | 19 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | New Jersey (NJ) | 34 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Montclair St. (NJ) | 14 | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | Kutztown (PA) | 13 | Kutztown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Montclair St. (NJ) | 10 | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Montclair St. (NJ) | 6 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 8 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Montclair St. (NJ) | 12 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 12 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Montclair St. (NJ) | 26 | Gallaudet (DC) | 6 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 16 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Monterey Peninsula College (CA) | 36 | Ventura JC (CA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montgomery JC (MD) | 5 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 36 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Montgomery JC (MD) | 8 | Potomac St. (WV) | 29 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Montgomery JC (MD) | 18 | Gallaudet (DC) | 16 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 8 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 27 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 26 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Michigan Tech | 28 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Nebraska-Kearney | 44 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 6 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 19 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Winona St. (MN) | 42 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Moorhead St. (MN) | 7 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 48 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Moorhead St. (MN) | 20 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 0 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Moravian (PA) | 15 | Albright (PA) | 12 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Moravian (PA) | 30 | Wilkes (PA) | 8 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Moravian (PA) | 8 | Upsala (NJ) | 26 | East Orange, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Moravian (PA) | 6 | Juniata (PA) | 28 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Moravian (PA) | 8 | Widener (PA) | 14 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Moravian (PA) | 0 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 14 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Moravian (PA) | 34 | Wagner (NY) | 6 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Moravian (PA) | 30 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 20 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 3 | East Tennessee St. | 19 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 7 | Tennessee Tech | 22 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 0 | Western Kentucky | 14 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | T | Morehead St. (KY) | 14 | West Virginia Tech | 14 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 20 | Virginia Military Institute | 46 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 16 | Marshall (WV) | 30 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Murray St. (KY) | 34 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Middle Tennessee St. | 34 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Eastern Kentucky | 24 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morehouse (GA) | 0 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morehouse (GA) | 14 | Alabama A&M | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morehouse (GA) | 18 | Knoxville (TN) | 8 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | Dillard (LA) | 14 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Morehouse (GA) | 0 | Alabama St. | 10 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | Tuskegee (AL) | 18 | Columbus, GA | |
| 1958 | T | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | Howard (DC) | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morehouse (GA) | 33 | Fisk (TN) | 22 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Morgan St. (MD) | 2 | North Carolina A&T | 20 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Morgan St. (MD) | 7 | North Carolina Central | 14 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Morgan St. (MD) | 69 | Virginia Union | 0 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Morgan St. (MD) | 13 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 12 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Morgan St. (MD) | 48 | Howard (DC) | 0 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Morgan St. (MD) | 6 | West Virginia St. | 8 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Morgan St. (MD) | 60 | Hampton (VA) | 0 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Morgan St. (MD) | 20 | Virginia St. | 6 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Morningside (IA) | 6 | South Dakota St. | 26 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Morningside (IA) | 12 | North Dakota St. | 0 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Morningside (IA) | 0 | South Dakota | 8 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Morningside (IA) | 13 | Central Missouri St. | 26 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Morningside (IA) | 28 | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Morningside (IA) | 8 | North Dakota | 25 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Morningside (IA) | 26 | Northern Iowa | 18 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Morningside (IA) | 20 | Augustana (SD) | 12 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 3 | Florida N&I | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Morris (SC) | 26 | Friendship JC (SC) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 0 | Miles (AL) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Morris (SC) | 44 | Paine (GA) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 14 | Savannah St. (GA) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 0 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 38 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 12 | Claflin (SC) | 28 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 15 | Benedict (SC) | 23 | Sumter, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 12 | Albany St. (GA) | 30 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Morris (SC) | 0 | Allen (SC) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Morris (SC) | 27 | Lane (TN) | 6 | Sumter, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Morris Brown (GA) | 6 | Tennessee St. | 32 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Morris Brown (GA) | 12 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 22 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morris Brown (GA) | 44 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 8 | Daytona Beach, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Morris Brown (GA) | 24 | North Carolina Central | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Morris Brown (GA) | 14 | Benedict (SC) | 20 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Morris Brown (GA) | 12 | Florida A&M | 13 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morris Brown (GA) | 20 | Kentucky St. | 0 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Morris Brown (GA) | 6 | South Carolina St. | 27 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Morris Brown (GA) | 3 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 0 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | Edward Waters (FL) | 24 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Morristown College (TN) | 6 | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | Kittrell College (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morristown College (TN) | 6 | South Carolina Trade | 28 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Morristown College (TN) | 18 | Livingstone (NC) | 28 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | T | Morristown College (TN) | 8 | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 58 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Mount Union (OH) | 22 | Kenyon (OH) | 12 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 9 | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Wooster (OH) | 33 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Ohio Wesleyan | 41 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 0 | Akron (OH) | 18 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Mount Union (OH) | 17 | Capital (OH) | 0 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 8 | Wittenberg (OH) | 66 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Mount Union (OH) | 40 | Hiram (OH) | 6 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Muskingum (OH) | 7 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muhlenberg (PA) | 12 | Hofstra (NY) | 0 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Muhlenberg (PA) | 14 | Lafayette (PA) | 27 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Muhlenberg (PA) | 27 | Albright (PA) | 20 | Reading, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Muhlenberg (PA) | 21 | Temple (PA) | 18 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Muhlenberg (PA) | 42 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Muhlenberg (PA) | 6 | Gettysburg (PA) | 7 | Gettysburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Muhlenberg (PA) | 13 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 18 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Muhlenberg (PA) | 20 | Moravian (PA) | 30 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 14 | Arkansas St. | 20 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 6 | Eastern Kentucky | 14 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 0 | Middle Tennessee St. | 40 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 0 | Louisville (KY) | 27 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 6 | East Tennessee St. | 12 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Murray St. (KY) | 20 | North Alabama | 6 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Murray St. (KY) | 34 | Morehead St. (KY) | 6 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 14 | Tennessee Tech | 15 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Murray St. (KY) | 8 | Evansville (IN) | 27 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Murray St. (KY) | 12 | Western Kentucky | 7 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 33 | Denison (OH) | 15 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 31 | Marietta (OH) | 16 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 48 | Findlay (OH) | 15 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 13 | Geneva (PA) | 0 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Muskingum (OH) | 7 | Akron (OH) | 8 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 35 | Capital (OH) | 6 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 22 | Heidelberg (OH) | 0 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 34 | Wooster (OH) | 0 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Muskingum (OH) | 7 | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Alliance, OH | |
| 1958 | L | National All-Stars | 13 | Southwest All-Stars | 22 | Tempe, AZ | Copper Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | L | Navarro JC (TX) | 0 | Texas-Arlington | 19 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 20 | Rice (TX) | 7 | Dallas, TX | Cotton Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Navy (MD) | 20 | Notre Dame (IN) | 40 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 28 | Boston (MA) | 14 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 40 | Maryland | 14 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 20 | Michigan | 14 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 14 | William & Mary (VA) | 0 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Navy (MD) | 6 | Tulane (LA) | 14 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 50 | Pennsylvania | 8 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Navy (MD) | 28 | George Washington (DC) | 8 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Navy (MD) | 6 | Army (NY) | 22 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 0 | Missouri | 31 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska | 7 | Iowa St. | 6 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 7 | Kansas | 29 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 6 | Kansas St. | 23 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska | 14 | Penn St. | 7 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 0 | Purdue (IN) | 28 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 0 | Syracuse (NY) | 38 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 16 | Colorado | 27 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska | 14 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 6 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska | 7 | Oklahoma | 40 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska Wesleyan | 28 | Dana (NE) | 6 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska Wesleyan | 13 | Chadron St. (NE) | 32 | Chadron, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska Wesleyan | 6 | Hastings (NE) | 26 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska Wesleyan | 15 | Kansas Wesleyan | 20 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska Wesleyan | 28 | Wayne St. (NE) | 0 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska Wesleyan | 27 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 7 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska Wesleyan | 0 | Nebraska-Kearney | 14 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska Wesleyan | 47 | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska Wesleyan | 21 | Doane (NE) | 7 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 56 | Wayne St. (NE) | 0 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 71 | Concordia (NE) | 3 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 33 | Doane (NE) | 0 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 44 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 35 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 7 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 28 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 6 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 35 | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 14 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 0 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Nebraska-Kearney | 73 | Dana (NE) | 13 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Washington (MO) | 28 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Emporia St. (KS) | 32 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Northern Illinois | 41 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Eastern New Mexico | 74 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Morningside (IA) | 28 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Washburn (KS) | 19 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Colorado School of Mines | 47 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | Montana St. | 42 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | L | Nevada | 18 | Cal St.-Chico | 22 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Nevada | 22 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 12 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | L | Nevada | 2 | California-Davis | 14 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Nevada | 12 | Pepperdine (CA) | 7 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Nevada | 6 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 18 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | W | Nevada | 40 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 24 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 0 | Connecticut | 34 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 13 | Rhode Island | 20 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | W | New Hampshire | 43 | Springfield (MA) | 20 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 0 | Maine | 14 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 0 | Northeastern (MA) | 12 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 14 | Delaware | 36 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | W | New Hampshire | 18 | Brandeis (MA) | 8 | Waltham, MA | |
| 1958 | L | New Hampshire | 24 | Massachusetts | 25 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | New Jersey (NJ) | 34 | Montclair St. (NJ) | 0 | Upper Montclair, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | New Jersey (NJ) | 38 | Lincoln (PA) | 12 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | T | New Jersey (NJ) | 6 | Kutztown (PA) | 6 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | New Jersey (NJ) | 0 | Millersville (PA) | 20 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | New Jersey (NJ) | 6 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 14 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | W | New Jersey (NJ) | 58 | Cheyney (PA) | 6 | Ewing, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | New Jersey (NJ) | 22 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 28 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | New Jersey (NJ) | 40 | Delaware Valley (PA) | 0 | Doylestown, PA | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 44 | Montana | 16 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico | 19 | Brigham Young (UT) | 36 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 34 | Utah St. | 14 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 16 | New Mexico St. | 7 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico | 6 | Texas-El Paso | 15 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 33 | Arizona | 13 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 13 | Wyoming | 12 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 21 | Denver (CO) | 15 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico | 17 | Colorado St. | 12 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico | 7 | Air Force (CO) | 45 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico Freshmen | 0 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | New Mexico Highlands | 7 | Northern Colorado | 7 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico Highlands | 19 | Western New Mexico | 22 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Highlands | 25 | Colorado School of Mines | 7 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Highlands | 18 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 13 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico Highlands | 0 | Northern Arizona | 20 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Highlands | 14 | Adams St. (CO) | 0 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Highlands | 20 | Colorado College | 14 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Highlands | 20 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 12 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico Military Institute | 44 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 19 | Arizona St. | 23 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 12 | North Texas | 43 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico St. | 10 | McMurry (TX) | 7 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico St. | 27 | Western St. (CO) | 24 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 0 | Trinity (TX) | 20 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 7 | New Mexico | 16 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico St. | 28 | University of Mexico | 14 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | W | New Mexico St. | 17 | Texas-El Paso | 16 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 32 | West Texas A&M | 39 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | New Mexico St. | 20 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 26 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Newberry (SC) | 6 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 28 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Newberry (SC) | 6 | Elon (NC) | 21 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Newberry (SC) | 14 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 8 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Newberry (SC) | 16 | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Newberry (SC) | 14 | Catawba (NC) | 24 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Newberry (SC) | 28 | Troy (AL) | 14 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Newberry (SC) | 28 | East Carolina (NC) | 6 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Newberry (SC) | 21 | Wofford (SC) | 13 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Newberry (SC) | 0 | Presbyterian (SC) | 22 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 13 | Chowan (NC) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 30 | East Carolina JV (NC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 26 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 36 | Montgomery JC (MD) | 5 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 7 | Potomac St. (WV) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 0 | West Virginia Tech | 19 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 8 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 0 | Newport News, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 14 | Bridgewater (VA) | 6 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 21 | Shepherd (WV) | 20 | Newport News, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Newport NTS (RI) | 20 | Maine Maritime | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Norfolk St. (VA) | 20 | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | Rock Hill, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Norfolk St. (VA) | 8 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 0 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Norfolk St. (VA) | 8 | South Carolina Trade | 20 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Norfolk St. (VA) | 12 | Central St. (OH) | 18 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Norfolk St. (VA) | 16 | Voorhees College (SC) | 12 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Norfolk St. (VA) | 14 | Livingstone (NC) | 30 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Norfolk St. (VA) | 58 | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Norfolk St. (VA) | 26 | Kittrell College (NC) | 13 | Kittrell, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Alabama | 6 | Middle Tennessee St. | 34 | Murfreesboro, TN | |
| 1958 | W | North Alabama | 19 | Arkansas St. | 0 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | L | North Alabama | 0 | McNeese St. (LA) | 20 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | North Alabama | 34 | West Alabama | 14 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | L | North Alabama | 6 | Murray St. (KY) | 20 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | L | North Alabama | 7 | Southeastern Louisiana | 40 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | North Alabama | 20 | Troy (AL) | 14 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | L | North Alabama | 14 | Tennessee Tech | 20 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | North Alabama | 20 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 13 | Clarksville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | North All-Stars | 15 | South All-Stars | 13 | Mobile, AL | Senior Bowl |
| 1958 | L | North All-Stars | 20 | South All-Stars | 49 | Miami, FL | N-S All-Star Shrine Game |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 21 | Tennessee | 7 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 8 | Southern California | 7 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 42 | Virginia | 0 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 6 | South Carolina | 0 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina | 14 | North Carolina St. | 21 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina | 21 | Clemson (SC) | 26 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 27 | Maryland | 0 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina | 26 | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina | 24 | Notre Dame (IN) | 34 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina | 6 | Duke (NC) | 7 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 20 | Morgan St. (MD) | 2 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 40 | Virginia Union | 6 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina A&T | 22 | Florida A&M | 37 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 16 | South Carolina St. | 14 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina A&T | 6 | Tennessee St. | 23 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 16 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 14 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 14 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 12 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 34 | Virginia St. | 6 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina A&T | 20 | North Carolina Central | 18 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 20 | Shaw (NC) | 12 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 14 | Morgan St. (MD) | 7 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 26 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 0 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina Central | 6 | Morris Brown (GA) | 24 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 28 | Allen (SC) | 6 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 33 | Virginia St. | 0 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 26 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 6 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina Central | 38 | Benedict (SC) | 14 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina Central | 18 | North Carolina A&T | 20 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | T | North Carolina St. | 14 | Virginia Tech | 14 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina St. | 26 | Virginia | 14 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 14 | Southern Mississippi | 26 | Mobile, AL | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 7 | Wake Forest (NC) | 13 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | North Carolina St. | 21 | North Carolina | 14 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 6 | Maryland | 21 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 6 | William & Mary (VA) | 13 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 13 | Duke (NC) | 20 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 6 | Clemson (SC) | 13 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | North Carolina St. | 7 | South Carolina | 12 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | North Central (IL) | 6 | Wheaton (IL) | 33 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | L | North Central (IL) | 6 | Lake Forest (IL) | 18 | Lake Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 18 | Carroll (WI) | 6 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 26 | Augustana (IL) | 19 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 6 | Indianapolis (IN) | 2 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 15 | Illinois Wesleyan | 0 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 86 | Elmhurst (IL) | 0 | Elmhurst, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Central (IL) | 18 | Millikin (IL) | 0 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | North Central (IL) | 18 | Anderson (IN) | 31 | Naperville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota | 10 | Augustana (SD) | 23 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota | 28 | South Dakota | 14 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota | 30 | South Dakota St. | 12 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota | 6 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 13 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota | 8 | Montana St. | 15 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota | 25 | Morningside (IA) | 8 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota | 36 | North Dakota St. | 0 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota | 14 | Northern Iowa | 0 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota Science | 47 | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota Science | 21 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota Science | 7 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 13 | Wahpeton, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota Science | 7 | Jamestown (ND) | 19 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota Science | 6 | Mayville St. (ND) | 7 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota Science | 6 | Valley City St. (ND) | 33 | Wahpeton, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota Science | 12 | Minot St. (ND) | 14 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 6 | Trinity (TX) | 80 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 0 | Morningside (IA) | 12 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 8 | South Dakota | 13 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 20 | Montana St. | 33 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota St. | 8 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 6 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota St. | 30 | Augustana (SD) | 28 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 11 | Northern Iowa | 21 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota St. | 0 | North Dakota | 36 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota St. | 33 | South Dakota St. | 20 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Dakota-Ellendale | 37 | Bismarck St. (ND) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota-Ellendale | 7 | North Dakota Science | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota-Ellendale | 24 | Mayville St. (ND) | 35 | Mayville, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota-Ellendale | 13 | Valley City St. (ND) | 14 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | T | North Dakota-Ellendale | 19 | Minot St. (ND) | 19 | Minot, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota-Ellendale | 0 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 20 | Dickinson, ND | |
| 1958 | L | North Dakota-Ellendale | 0 | Jamestown (ND) | 7 | Ellendale, ND | |
| 1958 | W | North Iowa Area JC | 7 | Bethel (MN) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 34 | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | North Park (IL) | 6 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 21 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 19 | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 24 | Bethel (MN) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 26 | Olivet (MI) | 13 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 34 | Eureka (IL) | 0 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 28 | Concordia (IL) | 0 | River Forest, IL | |
| 1958 | W | North Park (IL) | 19 | Illinois-Chicago | 6 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | T | North Texas | 8 | Cincinnati (OH) | 8 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 43 | New Mexico St. | 12 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | L | North Texas | 13 | Wichita St. (KS) | 15 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 42 | Drake (IA) | 0 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 26 | Texas-El Paso | 8 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | L | North Texas | 14 | Oklahoma St. | 21 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 12 | Brigham Young (UT) | 6 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 8 | Tulsa (OK) | 7 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 10 | Houston (TX) | 6 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | North Texas | 21 | Louisville (KY) | 10 | Louisville, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 36 | Bridgeport (CT) | 8 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Northeastern (MA) | 30 | Springfield (MA) | 32 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Northeastern (MA) | 14 | Connecticut | 38 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 42 | American International (MA) | 6 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 26 | Rhode Island | 6 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 12 | New Hampshire | 0 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 24 | Hofstra (NY) | 14 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern (MA) | 12 | Massachusetts | 0 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 42 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 12 | Santa Monica College (CA) | 30 | Pasadena, CA | Junior Rose Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 34 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 19 | Benedictine (KS) | 14 | Tulsa, OK | NAIA Semifinal Playoff Game |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 33 | East Central (OK) | 7 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 20 | Missouri S&T | 3 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 25 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 14 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 40 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 12 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 34 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 28 | Langston (OK) | 8 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 28 | Central Oklahoma | 8 | Edmond, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 40 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 3 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Northeastern St. (OK) | 19 | Northern Arizona | 13 | Saint Petersburg, FL | Holiday Bowl (2) - NAIA Championship Game |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 30 | Western New Mexico | 7 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 28 | Redlands (CA) | 14 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 41 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 12 | Tucson, AZ | NAIA Semifinal Playoff Game |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 37 | La Verne (CA) | 0 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 25 | San Diego Marines (CA) | 19 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 16 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 8 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 13 | McMurry (TX) | 6 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 20 | New Mexico Highlands | 0 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 41 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 7 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 7 | Willamette (OR) | 0 | Yuma, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Arizona | 40 | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | Chico, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Arizona | 13 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 19 | Saint Petersburg, FL | Holiday Bowl (2) - NAIA Championship Game |
| 1958 | T | Northern Colorado | 7 | New Mexico Highlands | 7 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Colorado | 42 | Adams St. (CO) | 14 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Colorado | 6 | Idaho St. | 14 | Pocatello, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Colorado | 47 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 18 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Colorado | 6 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 25 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Colorado | 25 | Western St. (CO) | 6 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Colorado | 32 | Colorado College | 20 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Colorado | 0 | Colorado School of Mines | 3 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Colorado | 16 | Eastern New Mexico | 6 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Illinois | 7 | Eastern Michigan | 15 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Illinois | 24 | Eastern Illinois | 12 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Illinois | 41 | Nebraska-Omaha | 0 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Illinois | 7 | Western Illinois | 38 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Illinois | 20 | Wheaton (IL) | 40 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Illinois | 27 | Beloit (WI) | 6 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Illinois | 23 | Central Michigan | 33 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Illinois | 18 | Illinois St. | 33 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Illinois | 17 | Southern Illinois | 7 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Iowa | 20 | Drake (IA) | 16 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Iowa | 8 | South Dakota St. | 13 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Iowa | 15 | Augustana (SD) | 26 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Iowa | 29 | Bradley (IL) | 12 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Iowa | 25 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 0 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Iowa | 21 | North Dakota St. | 11 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Iowa | 18 | Morningside (IA) | 26 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Iowa | 0 | North Dakota | 14 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Iowa | 14 | South Dakota | 38 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Michigan | 39 | Wayne St. (MI) | 0 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Michigan | 13 | Hope (MI) | 14 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Michigan | 43 | Findlay (OH) | 0 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Michigan | 28 | Quantico Marines (VA) | 50 | Quantico, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Michigan | 14 | Central Michigan | 27 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Michigan | 13 | Valparaiso (IN) | 18 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Michigan | 27 | Taylor (IN) | 7 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Michigan | 34 | Michigan Tech | 0 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Northern Michigan | 19 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 0 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Northern Michigan | 7 | Hillsdale (MI) | 9 | Hillsdale, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Northern St. (SD) | 7 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 40 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 52 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 7 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 13 | South Dakota-Springfield | 0 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 26 | South Dakota Tech | 13 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 19 | Yankton (SD) | 0 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 35 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 7 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 20 | Dakota St. (SD) | 14 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 28 | Michigan Tech | 6 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northern St. (SD) | 48 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 20 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Northern St. (SD) | 0 | Si Tanka (SD) | 20 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Northland (WI) | 32 | Northwestern (WI) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Northland (WI) | 6 | Wisconsin Tech | 6 | Ashland, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Northland (WI) | 0 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 44 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Northland (WI) | 0 | Wisconsin-Superior | 30 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Northland (WI) | 7 | Lakeland (WI) | 13 | Sheboygan, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Northland (WI) | 6 | Bethel (MN) | 20 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Northwest CC (WY) | 46 | Carroll (MT) | 12 | Powell, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 7 | Missouri S&T | 20 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 7 | William Jewell (MO) | 19 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 19 | Truman St. (MO) | 20 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 14 | Southeast Missouri St. | 33 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 8 | South Dakota | 22 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 0 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 13 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 0 | Missouri St. | 13 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Northwest Missouri St. | 6 | Central Missouri St. | 28 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (IL) | 21 | Ohio St. | 0 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (IL) | 28 | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (IL) | 13 | Wisconsin | 17 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (IL) | 7 | Minnesota | 3 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (IL) | 29 | Washington St. | 28 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (IL) | 55 | Michigan | 24 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (IL) | 20 | Iowa | 26 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (IL) | 6 | Purdue (IN) | 23 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (IL) | 20 | Illinois | 27 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (WI) | 20 | Northland (WI) | 32 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (WI) | 46 | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (WI) | 27 | Concordia (IL) | 0 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (WI) | 18 | Lakeland (WI) | 6 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern (WI) | 20 | Benedictine (IL) | 14 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern (WI) | 7 | Bethel (MN) | 13 | Watertown, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 24 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 20 | Langston (OK) | 42 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 13 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 52 | Bethel (KS) | 0 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 12 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 40 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 27 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 20 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 20 | Central Oklahoma | 6 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 33 | East Central (OK) | 13 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 34 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 14 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 42 | Louisiana-Monroe | 6 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern St. (LA) | 12 | Louisiana College | 13 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 18 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 11 | Natchitoches, LA | Christmas Festival Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 27 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 8 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 36 | East Central (OK) | 0 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Northwestern St. (LA) | 8 | McNeese St. (LA) | 25 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 18 | Louisiana Tech | 14 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 43 | Texas Lutheran | 12 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 64 | West Alabama | 0 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Northwestern St. (LA) | 7 | Southeastern Louisiana | 0 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Norwich (VT) | 6 | Middlebury (VT) | 12 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Norwich (VT) | 0 | Coast Guard (CT) | 12 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Norwich (VT) | 12 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 33 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Norwich (VT) | 6 | Southern Connecticut St. | 36 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Norwich (VT) | 24 | Bridgeport (CT) | 8 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Norwich (VT) | 18 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 8 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Norwich (VT) | 6 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 3 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Norwich (VT) | 16 | Vermont | 12 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 40 | Navy (MD) | 20 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 14 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 6 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Notre Dame (IN) | 26 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 29 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Notre Dame (IN) | 2 | Army (NY) | 14 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 18 | Indiana | 0 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 9 | Duke (NC) | 7 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Notre Dame (IN) | 22 | Purdue (IN) | 29 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 34 | North Carolina | 24 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Notre Dame (IN) | 21 | Iowa | 31 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Notre Dame (IN) | 20 | Southern California | 13 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Oakland JC (CA) | 0 | Boise JC (ID) | 40 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Oberlin (OH) | 39 | Earlham (IN) | 20 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Oberlin (OH) | 21 | Swarthmore (PA) | 12 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Oberlin (OH) | 21 | Capital (OH) | 30 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Oberlin (OH) | 12 | Otterbein (OH) | 18 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Oberlin (OH) | 19 | Hiram (OH) | 6 | Hiram, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Ohio Wesleyan | 48 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Kenyon (OH) | 16 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Wooster (OH) | 28 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Occidental (CA) | 6 | California-Santa Barbara | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Occidental (CA) | 6 | California-Davis | 12 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Occidental (CA) | 18 | Redlands (CA) | 22 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Occidental (CA) | 16 | San Francisco St. (CA) | 25 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Occidental (CA) | 50 | US International (CA) | 8 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Occidental (CA) | 20 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 32 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Occidental (CA) | 14 | Whittier (CA) | 40 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Occidental (CA) | 49 | California Tech | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Occidental (CA) | 39 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 0 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Oceanside JC (CA) | 0 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio | 14 | Western Michigan | 21 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio | 6 | Kent St. (OH) | 14 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio | 6 | Bowling Green (OH) | 33 | Bowling Green, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio | 27 | Dayton (OH) | 8 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio | 38 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 0 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio | 13 | Toledo (OH) | 6 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio | 10 | Miami (OH) | 14 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio | 22 | Marshall (WV) | 0 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio | 23 | Louisville (KY) | 6 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 6 | Findlay (OH) | 26 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Northern | 24 | Wilmington (OH) | 0 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 12 | Alma (MI) | 33 | Alma, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 15 | Waynesburg (PA) | 26 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 55 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 18 | Ashland (OH) | 21 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Northern | 13 | Defiance (OH) | 33 | Defiance, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 10 | Oregon | 7 | Pasadena, CA | Rose Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Ohio St. | 0 | Northwestern (IL) | 21 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 12 | Washington | 7 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Ohio St. | 14 | Purdue (IN) | 14 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 19 | Illinois | 13 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 23 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 49 | Indiana | 8 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Ohio St. | 7 | Wisconsin | 7 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 38 | Iowa | 28 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio St. | 20 | Michigan | 14 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 34 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 6 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 13 | Akron (OH) | 0 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Wesleyan | 6 | Wittenberg (OH) | 7 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 41 | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 35 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 20 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Wesleyan | 21 | Heidelberg (OH) | 39 | Tiffin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 48 | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Ohio Wesleyan | 48 | Wabash (IN) | 22 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ohio Wesleyan | 14 | Denison (OH) | 35 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 48 | Duke (NC) | 21 | Miami, FL | Orange Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 23 | Colorado | 7 | Boulder, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 6 | Oregon | 0 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 20 | Iowa St. | 0 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma | 14 | Texas | 15 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 47 | West Virginia | 14 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 43 | Kansas | 0 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 40 | Kansas St. | 6 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 39 | Missouri | 0 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 40 | Nebraska | 7 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma | 7 | Oklahoma St. | 0 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 34 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 27 | Western New Mexico | 28 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 81 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 18 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 18 | Northern Colorado | 47 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 9 | William Jewell (MO) | 0 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 13 | New Mexico Highlands | 18 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 20 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 27 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 7 | Northern Arizona | 41 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 34 | Adams St. (CO) | 7 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 7 | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma St. | 29 | Air Force (CO) | 33 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 43 | Wichita St. (KS) | 12 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 14 | Kansas St. | 7 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma St. | 16 | Tulsa (OK) | 24 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 31 | Denver (CO) | 14 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 21 | North Texas | 14 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 7 | Houston (TX) | 0 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 19 | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 6 | Kansas | 3 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oklahoma St. | 0 | Oklahoma | 7 | Stillwater, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Oklahoma St. | 15 | Florida St. | 6 | Louisville, KY | Bluegrass Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 6 | Coahoma CC (MS) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 14 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | Shorter College (AR) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 40 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | Rust (MS) | 60 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Hope (MI) | 61 | Holland, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Hillsdale (MI) | 44 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Olivet (MI) | 20 | Kalamazoo (MI) | 13 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Ferris St. (MI) | 6 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 13 | North Park (IL) | 26 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 7 | Adrian (MI) | 12 | Adrian, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Albion (MI) | 46 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 0 | Alma (MI) | 27 | Olivet, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olivet (MI) | 12 | Grand Rapids JC (MI) | 34 | Grand Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Olympic JC (WA) | 19 | Boise JC (ID) | 44 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 7 | Ohio St. | 10 | Pasadena, CA | Rose Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 0 | Washington | 6 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 0 | Oklahoma | 6 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 0 | Miami (FL) | 2 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon | 12 | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon | 25 | Southern California | 0 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon | 27 | Idaho | 0 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 0 | Washington St. | 6 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 6 | California | 23 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon | 3 | UCLA | 7 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon | 20 | Oregon St. | 0 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 14 | California | 8 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 14 | UCLA | 0 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon St. | 0 | Washington St. | 7 | Pullman, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon St. | 0 | Wyoming | 28 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon St. | 0 | Southern California | 21 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 12 | Kansas | 0 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 20 | Idaho | 6 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 14 | Washington | 12 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Oregon St. | 24 | Stanford (CA) | 16 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon St. | 0 | Oregon | 20 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon Tech | 66 | Western Oregon | 7 | Monmouth, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Oregon Tech | 31 | Portland St. (OR) | 21 | Klamath Falls, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Oregon Tech | 27 | Eastern Oregon | 6 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Oregon Tech | 6 | Westminster College (UT) | 0 | Salt Lake City, UT | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Oregon Tech | 40 | Southern Oregon | 0 | Klamath Falls, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Oregon Tech | 7 | Whittier (CA) | 26 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Otero JC (CO) | 7 | Mesa St. (CO) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ottawa (KS) | 0 | McPherson (KS) | 27 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Ottawa (KS) | 6 | Bethel (KS) | 6 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Ottawa (KS) | 26 | College of Emporia (KS) | 6 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Ottawa (KS) | 7 | Kansas Wesleyan | 14 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Ottawa (KS) | 26 | William Jewell (MO) | 32 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Ottawa (KS) | 39 | Friends (KS) | 7 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Ottawa (KS) | 13 | Missouri Valley | 34 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Ottawa (KS) | 19 | Bethany (KS) | 14 | Lindsborg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Ottawa (KS) | 2 | Baker (KS) | 6 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Otterbein (OH) | 7 | Heidelberg (OH) | 14 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Otterbein (OH) | 8 | Kenyon (OH) | 16 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Otterbein (OH) | 23 | Ashland (OH) | 8 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Otterbein (OH) | 18 | Oberlin (OH) | 12 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Otterbein (OH) | 0 | Findlay (OH) | 0 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Otterbein (OH) | 0 | Denison (OH) | 14 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Otterbein (OH) | 50 | Hiram (OH) | 0 | Westerville, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Otterbein (OH) | 12 | Marietta (OH) | 14 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Otterbein (OH) | 18 | Capital (OH) | 18 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 7 | Ozarks (AR) | 27 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 7 | Central Arkansas | 14 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 31 | Mississippi College | 0 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 10 | Austin (TX) | 33 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 13 | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 0 | Arkansas-Monticello | 35 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 10 | Arkansas Tech | 52 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | T | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 0 | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Ozarks (AR) | 27 | Ouachita Baptist (AR) | 7 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ozarks (AR) | 0 | Henderson St. (AR) | 7 | Arkadelphia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Ozarks (AR) | 25 | Hendrix (AR) | 6 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Central Arkansas | 39 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Ozarks (AR) | 12 | Mississippi College | 0 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Ozarks (AR) | 6 | Arkansas Tech | 12 | Clarksville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Tennessee-Martin | 32 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Arkansas-Monticello | 21 | Monticello, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (CA) | 12 | Boston College (MA) | 25 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 26 | San Jose St. (CA) | 13 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 26 | Brigham Young (UT) | 8 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 24 | California | 20 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 34 | Arizona St. | 16 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (CA) | 6 | Cincinnati (OH) | 12 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (CA) | 18 | Marquette (WI) | 27 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (CA) | 0 | Washington St. | 34 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 68 | San Diego St. (CA) | 17 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (CA) | 52 | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 0 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 48 | San Luis Obispo, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Willamette (OR) | 27 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | T | Pacific (OR) | 7 | Linfield (OR) | 7 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 6 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Cal St.-Chico | 34 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 19 | Portland St. (OR) | 20 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 14 | College of Idaho | 28 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 7 | Whitman (WA) | 12 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific (OR) | 13 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 33 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 13 | Central Washington | 45 | Ellensburg, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Eastern Washington | 21 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Puget Sound (WA) | 6 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 6 | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 6 | Puget Sound (WA) | 9 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 29 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 7 | Western Washington | 12 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 26 | Whitworth (WA) | 20 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 12 | Florida N&I | 22 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 14 | Morris (SC) | 44 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 12 | Savannah St. (GA) | 44 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 16 | Claflin (SC) | 34 | Augusta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 0 | Livingstone (NC) | 38 | Augusta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Paine (GA) | 0 | Albany St. (GA) | 32 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Palo Verde JC (CA) | 6 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 10 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Palomar JC (CA) | 6 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Paris JC (TX) | 0 | Texas-Arlington | 19 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 14 | Luther (IA) | 47 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 21 | Iowa Wesleyan | 27 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Parsons (IA) | 33 | Westmar (IA) | 6 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Parsons (IA) | 20 | Dubuque (IA) | 7 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Parsons (IA) | 21 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 0 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 7 | Buena Vista (IA) | 27 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 0 | Wartburg (IA) | 7 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Parsons (IA) | 30 | Central (IA) | 24 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 14 | Simpson (IA) | 28 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons (IA) | 7 | Upper Iowa | 19 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Parsons JC (KS) | 18 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 34 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Pasadena City College (CA) | 0 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 50 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Pasadena City College (CA) | 34 | Ventura JC (CA) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 26 | Leland (LA) | 6 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Paul Quinn (TX) | 8 | Grambling St. (LA) | 72 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 54 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 6 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 22 | Tougaloo (MS) | 14 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Paul Quinn (TX) | 0 | Texas College | 32 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 18 | Bishop (TX) | 8 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 13 | Mississippi Valley St. | 0 | Itta Bena, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Paul Quinn (TX) | 12 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 36 | Furman (SC) | 0 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Penn St. | 0 | Army (NY) | 26 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Penn St. | 14 | West Virginia | 14 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 40 | Marquette (WI) | 8 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Penn St. | 7 | Nebraska | 14 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 43 | Pennsylvania | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 34 | Boston (MA) | 0 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Penn St. | 6 | Syracuse (NY) | 14 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 32 | Holy Cross (MA) | 0 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Penn St. | 25 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 21 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pennsylvania | 19 | Harvard (MA) | 6 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Pennsylvania | 12 | Dartmouth (NH) | 13 | Hanover, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Pennsylvania | 30 | Yale (CT) | 6 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Pennsylvania | 14 | Princeton (NJ) | 20 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Pennsylvania | 0 | Penn St. | 43 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pennsylvania | 21 | Brown (RI) | 20 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Pennsylvania | 8 | Navy (MD) | 50 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pennsylvania | 42 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Pennsylvania | 7 | Cornell (NY) | 19 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pensacola NAS (FL) | 27 | Texas Lutheran | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Pensacola NAS (FL) | 14 | University of Mexico | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Pepperdine (CA) | 26 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 22 | Long Beach, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 6 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 22 | Los Angeles, CA | At El Centro JC? |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 19 | Whittier (CA) | 36 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 7 | Nevada | 12 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 0 | San Diego St. (CA) | 6 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 6 | Redlands (CA) | 12 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 22 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pepperdine (CA) | 13 | San Diego (CA) | 45 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 56 | Concordia (NE) | 0 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 13 | Doane (NE) | 6 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 27 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 20 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 14 | Westmar (IA) | 0 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 62 | Dana (NE) | 0 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 16 | Wayne St. (NE) | 2 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Peru St. (NE) | 17 | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Hastings, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Peru St. (NE) | 0 | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 26 | Lane (TN) | 0 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 26 | Leland (LA) | 0 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 47 | Butler College (TX) | 6 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Philander-Smith (AR) | 12 | Bishop (TX) | 49 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 13 | Friends (KS) | 12 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Philander-Smith (AR) | 12 | Dillard (LA) | 12 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 45 | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Philander-Smith (AR) | 6 | Rust (MS) | 6 | Holly Springs, MS | Rust Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Phoenix College (AZ) | 22 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 23 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Piney Woods College (MS) | 0 | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 50 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 20 | Emporia St. (KS) | 14 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 21 | Missouri S&T | 22 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 25 | Southwestern (KS) | 19 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 19 | Benedictine (KS) | 26 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 21 | Truman St. (MO) | 12 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 6 | Missouri St. | 7 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 19 | Central Missouri St. | 19 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 7 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 16 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 13 | Washburn (KS) | 7 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 3 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 40 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburg St. JV (KS) | 13 | Missouri Southern St. | 22 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburgh (PA) | 13 | Syracuse (NY) | 16 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburgh (PA) | 13 | Minnesota | 7 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburgh (PA) | 29 | Notre Dame (IN) | 26 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburgh (PA) | 8 | Michigan St. | 22 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburgh (PA) | 27 | UCLA | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburgh (PA) | 17 | Holy Cross (MA) | 0 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pittsburgh (PA) | 15 | West Virginia | 8 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Pittsburgh (PA) | 14 | Army (NY) | 14 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburgh (PA) | 6 | Nebraska | 14 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Pittsburgh (PA) | 21 | Penn St. | 25 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 27 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 24 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 34 | US International (CA) | 6 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 15 | Whittier (CA) | 29 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 12 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 41 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 12 | Colorado College | 46 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 16 | California Tech | 8 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 13 | Redlands (CA) | 28 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | T | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 18 | La Verne (CA) | 18 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 0 | Occidental (CA) | 39 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | T | Pomona-Pitzer Freshmen (CA) | 6 | California-Riverside | 6 | Riverside, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Linfield (OR) | 34 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Portland St. (OR) | 21 | Oregon Tech | 31 | Klamath Falls, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Portland St. (OR) | 6 | Whitworth (WA) | 26 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Portland St. (OR) | 14 | Southern Oregon | 21 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 12 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Portland St. (OR) | 20 | Pacific (OR) | 19 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Western Oregon | 22 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Portland St. (OR) | 34 | Eastern Oregon | 14 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Portland St. (OR) | 18 | Westminster College (UT) | 14 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Potomac St. (WV) | 13 | Baltimore JC (MD) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Potomac St. (WV) | 29 | Montgomery JC (MD) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Potomac St. (WV) | 12 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Potomac St. (WV) | 0 | Waynesburg (PA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Potomac St. (WV) | 64 | Wesley (DE) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Potomac St. (WV) | 32 | Salem College (WV) | 2 | Clarksburg, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Potomac St. (WV) | 7 | Shepherd (WV) | 27 | Keyser, WV | |
| 1958 | T | Potomac St. (WV) | 0 | Glenville St. (WV) | 0 | Glenville, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Potomac St. (WV) | 6 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 20 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 53 | Fort Hood (TX) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 6 | Texas Southern | 6 | Houston, TX | Prairie View Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 37 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 13 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 43 | Texas College | 0 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | T | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 14 | Jackson St. (MS) | 14 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 26 | Texas Southern | 19 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 44 | Grambling St. (LA) | 6 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 59 | Mississippi Valley St. | 19 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 13 | Wiley (TX) | 0 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 20 | Southern (LA) | 14 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 26 | Florida A&M | 8 | Miami, FL | Orange Blossom Classic |
| 1958 | W | Pratt JC (KS) | 21 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Prentiss Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 6 | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Presbyterian (SC) | 14 | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 18 | Wofford (SC) | 14 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Presbyterian (SC) | 0 | Citadel (SC) | 38 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Presbyterian (SC) | 6 | Davidson (NC) | 7 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 24 | East Carolina (NC) | 16 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 8 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 6 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 34 | Elon (NC) | 6 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Presbyterian (SC) | 6 | Tampa (FL) | 18 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 42 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 0 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Presbyterian (SC) | 22 | Newberry (SC) | 0 | Clinton, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 28 | Brown (RI) | 18 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 43 | Columbia (NY) | 8 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 16 | Harvard (MA) | 14 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 20 | Pennsylvania | 14 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Princeton (NJ) | 0 | Rutgers (NJ) | 28 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 40 | Colgate (NY) | 13 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Princeton (NJ) | 8 | Cornell (NY) | 34 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Princeton (NJ) | 50 | Yale (CT) | 14 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Princeton (NJ) | 12 | Dartmouth (NH) | 21 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Principia (IL) | 21 | Central Methodist (MO) | 18 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Principia (IL) | 34 | Central Methodist (MO) | 18 | Fayette, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Principia (IL) | 0 | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 24 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Principia (IL) | 8 | Illinois College | 24 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Principia (IL) | 7 | Carthage (WI) | 40 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Principia (IL) | 13 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Principia (IL) | 27 | Eureka (IL) | 7 | Elsah, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Pueblo JC (CO) | 6 | Mesa St. (CO) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | Willamette (OR) | 40 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Puget Sound (WA) | 19 | Central Washington | 20 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Puget Sound (WA) | 6 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 0 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | British Columbia (BC) | 13 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Puget Sound (WA) | 9 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 6 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 27 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Puget Sound (WA) | 13 | Whitworth (WA) | 19 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Puget Sound (WA) | 32 | Eastern Washington | 14 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Puget Sound (WA) | 14 | Western Washington | 0 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 31 | Illinois | 8 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 24 | Rice (TX) | 0 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | T | Purdue (IN) | 14 | Ohio St. | 14 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Purdue (IN) | 6 | Wisconsin | 31 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 28 | Nebraska | 0 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 14 | Michigan St. | 6 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 29 | Notre Dame (IN) | 22 | South Bend, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Purdue (IN) | 23 | Northwestern (IL) | 6 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | T | Purdue (IN) | 15 | Indiana | 15 | West Lafayette, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Quantico Marines (VA) | 13 | Detroit (MI) | 26 | Quantico, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Quantico Marines (VA) | 50 | Northern Michigan | 28 | Quantico, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Quantico Marines (VA) | 31 | Xavier (OH) | 20 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Quantico Marines (VA) | 13 | Rutgers (NJ) | 12 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Quantico Marines (VA) | 19 | Villanova (PA) | 13 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Queen's (ON) | 15 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 0 | Kingston, ON (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | Quonset NAS (RI) | 8 | Maine Maritime | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Quonset NAS (RI) | 8 | Southern Connecticut St. | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 13 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 0 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 55 | Gallaudet (DC) | 8 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 23 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 20 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 20 | McDaniel College (MD) | 6 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 0 | Millersville (PA) | 14 | Ashland, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 0 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 8 | Newport News, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 12 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 13 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 13 | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 6 | East Carolina (NC) | 36 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Ranger JC (TX) | 0 | Cameron (OK) | 27 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 34 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 18 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Redlands (CA) | 14 | Northern Arizona | 28 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 22 | Occidental (CA) | 18 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 52 | California Tech | 0 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 41 | US International (CA) | 0 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 18 | La Verne (CA) | 7 | La Verne, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 12 | Pepperdine (CA) | 6 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Redlands (CA) | 28 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 13 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Redlands (CA) | 20 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 35 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Redlands (CA) | 6 | Whittier (CA) | 27 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Reedley College (CA) | 22 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 6 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 26 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 14 | Hamilton (NY) | 34 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 8 | Coast Guard (CT) | 28 | New London, CT | Shot Glass Trophy |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 7 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 32 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 8 | Norwich (VT) | 18 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 21 | Union (NY) | 0 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 0 | Middlebury (VT) | 18 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 7 | Rochester (NY) | 34 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rhode Island | 28 | Springfield (MA) | 14 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Rhode Island | 20 | New Hampshire | 13 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | W | Rhode Island | 52 | Brandeis (MA) | 22 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Rhode Island | 6 | Northeastern (MA) | 26 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Rhode Island | 8 | Maine | 37 | Orono, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Rhode Island | 24 | Massachusetts | 8 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Rhode Island | 6 | Brown (RI) | 47 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Rhode Island | 8 | Connecticut | 36 | Kingston, RI | |
| 1958 | W | Rhodes (TN) | 20 | Samford (AL) | 12 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Rhodes (TN) | 26 | Hendrix (AR) | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Rhodes (TN) | 28 | Wabash (IN) | 20 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Rhodes (TN) | 6 | Centre (KY) | 7 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Rhodes (TN) | 7 | Millsaps (MS) | 6 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Rhodes (TN) | 28 | Mississippi College | 8 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Rhodes (TN) | 6 | Austin (TX) | 54 | Sherman, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Rhodes (TN) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 47 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 7 | Navy (MD) | 20 | Dallas, TX | Cotton Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 0 | Purdue (IN) | 24 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 7 | Army (NY) | 14 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Rice (TX) | 24 | Arkansas | 0 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 6 | Louisiana St. | 26 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Rice (TX) | 30 | Stanford (CA) | 7 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Rice (TX) | 13 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 7 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Rice (TX) | 34 | Texas | 7 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 21 | Texas A&M | 28 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Rice (TX) | 10 | Texas Christian | 22 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Rice (TX) | 33 | Baylor (TX) | 21 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Richmond (VA) | 20 | Citadel (SC) | 0 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Richmond (VA) | 26 | George Washington (DC) | 6 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 6 | Virginia Military Institute | 12 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 23 | Virginia Tech | 27 | Blacksburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 12 | Rutgers (NJ) | 23 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 22 | West Virginia | 66 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 12 | Dayton (OH) | 13 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 6 | Villanova (PA) | 13 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Richmond (VA) | 27 | Davidson (NC) | 22 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Richmond (VA) | 15 | William & Mary (VA) | 18 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Richmond Freshmen (VA) | 29 | Chowan (NC) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ricks JC (ID) | 7 | Boise JC (ID) | 25 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ricks JC (ID) | 6 | Montana Western | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 33 | Cornell College (IA) | 12 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 42 | Grinnell (IA) | 0 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 67 | Knox (IL) | 0 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 27 | Lawrence (WI) | 8 | Appleton, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 40 | Saint Olaf (MN) | 7 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Ripon (WI) | 6 | Coe (IA) | 14 | Cedar Rapids, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Ripon (WI) | 20 | Carleton (MN) | 24 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Ripon (WI) | 53 | Monmouth (IL) | 0 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 20 | DePauw (IN) | 6 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 24 | Hobart (NY) | 0 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 46 | Tufts (MA) | 6 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 47 | Union (NY) | 0 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 20 | Allegheny (PA) | 0 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 46 | Vermont | 0 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 20 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 0 | Kings Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rochester (NY) | 34 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 7 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 37 | Montana St.-Northern | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 6 | Montana Western | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 18 | Northwestern (WI) | 46 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 20 | Montana St.-Billings | 21 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 6 | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Helena, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Rocky Mountain (MT) | 58 | Montana Tech | 0 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 40 | Illinois College | 7 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 21 | North Park (IL) | 6 | Chicago, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 24 | Principia (IL) | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 78 | Eureka (IL) | 6 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 42 | Benedictine (IL) | 0 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 26 | Concordia (IL) | 0 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 12 | Franklin (IN) | 0 | Franklin, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rose-Hulman Tech (IN) | 27 | Earlham (IN) | 12 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Rust (MS) | 20 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Rust (MS) | 6 | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Rust (MS) | 18 | Bishop (TX) | 26 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Rust (MS) | 8 | Dillard (LA) | 24 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Rust (MS) | 12 | Leland (LA) | 18 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Rust (MS) | 36 | Tougaloo (MS) | 6 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Rust (MS) | 6 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 6 | Holly Springs, MS | Rust Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Rust (MS) | 60 | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Rust (MS) | 0 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 48 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 37 | Delaware | 20 | Newark, DE | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 21 | Colgate (NY) | 7 | Hamilton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 18 | Lafayette (PA) | 0 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 23 | Richmond (VA) | 12 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 28 | Princeton (NJ) | 0 | Princeton, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 57 | Bucknell (PA) | 12 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 44 | Lehigh (PA) | 13 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Rutgers (NJ) | 12 | Quantico Marines (VA) | 13 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | W | Rutgers (NJ) | 61 | Columbia (NY) | 0 | New Brunswick, NJ | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 18 | Montana St. | 39 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 31 | Truman St. (MO) | 25 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 19 | Bradley (IL) | 24 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 32 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 25 | Western Illinois | 32 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 7 | Benedictine (KS) | 27 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 53 | Loras (IA) | 38 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 27 | Southeast Missouri St. | 27 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 12 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 8 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 0 | Shaw (NC) | 6 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 26 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 0 | North Carolina Central | 26 | Durham, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 44 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 18 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 8 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 12 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 0 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 26 | Delaware St. | 0 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 22 | Loras (IA) | 26 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 12 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 50 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | T | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Winona St. (MN) | 6 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 0 | Saint John's (MN) | 33 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 24 | Wisconsin-Stout | 12 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 33 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Wartburg (IA) | 15 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 0 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 20 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 20 | Hamline (MN) | 0 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 42 | Minnesota-Duluth | 29 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 33 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 0 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 41 | Macalester (MN) | 14 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 13 | Saint Thomas (MN) | 0 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint John's (MN) | 7 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 18 | Saint Peter, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint John's (MN) | 8 | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | Minneapolis, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint John's (MN) | 8 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 40 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Ball St. (IN) | 0 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 6 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 28 | Evansville (IN) | 0 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Xavier (OH) | 8 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 14 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 25 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 32 | DePauw (IN) | 8 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 44 | Indiana St. | 0 | Rensselaer, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 15 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 3 | Eastern Michigan | 0 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 7 | Vermont | 26 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 9 | Lycoming (PA) | 41 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 0 | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 0 | Queen's (ON) | 15 | Kingston, ON (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 7 | Hobart (NY) | 20 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 3 | Norwich (VT) | 6 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 21 | Army B Team (NY) | 12 | Canton, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 13 | Fort Hays St. JV (KS) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | New Mexico Military Institute | 44 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Graceland (IA) | 22 | Dodge City, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 18 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 81 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Western New Mexico | 40 | Dodge City, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 13 | McPherson (KS) | 44 | McPherson, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Sterling (KS) | 32 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Tarkio (MO) | 13 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Norbert (WI) | 48 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 26 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | Loras (IA) | 18 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 8 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 34 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 32 | Davenport, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Norbert (WI) | 30 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 14 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 6 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 22 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 18 | Michigan Tech | 20 | Houghton, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 20 | Augustana (SD) | 21 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Norbert (WI) | 0 | Northern Michigan | 19 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Coe (IA) | 21 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Olaf (MN) | 13 | Cornell College (IA) | 8 | Mount Vernon, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Grinnell (IA) | 7 | Grinnell, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Olaf (MN) | 29 | Knox (IL) | 21 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Olaf (MN) | 7 | Ripon (WI) | 40 | Ripon, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Olaf (MN) | 21 | Carleton (MN) | 27 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Olaf (MN) | 12 | Monmouth (IL) | 20 | Monmouth, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Olaf (MN) | 35 | Lawrence (WI) | 14 | Northfield, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Delaware St. | 46 | Dover, DE | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 14 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Lincoln (PA) | 16 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Howard (DC) | 20 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 44 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 0 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 38 | Elizabeth City, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Livingstone (NC) | 28 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 54 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Thomas (MN) | 12 | Augsburg (MN) | 7 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Thomas (MN) | 24 | Loras (IA) | 18 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Thomas (MN) | 20 | Macalester (MN) | 0 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Thomas (MN) | 36 | Hamline (MN) | 6 | Saint Paul, MN | Saint Thomas Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Saint Thomas (MN) | 0 | Saint John's (MN) | 13 | Collegeville, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Thomas (MN) | 6 | Minnesota-Duluth | 7 | Duluth, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Thomas (MN) | 0 | Concordia-Moorhead (MN) | 22 | Moorhead, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Thomas (MN) | 12 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 26 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 14 | King's (PA) | 10 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 12 | Geneva (PA) | 12 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 7 | Westminster (PA) | 30 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 15 | Thiel (PA) | 7 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 13 | Clarion (PA) | 0 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 7 | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 8 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 24 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 0 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 6 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 2 | Potomac St. (WV) | 32 | Clarksburg, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 0 | West Virginia St. | 32 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Salem College (WV) | 19 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 7 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 0 | West Virginia Tech | 13 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 7 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 21 | New Martinsville, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 7 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 26 | Salem, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Salem College (WV) | 7 | Glenville St. (WV) | 14 | West Union, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 26 | Howard Payne (TX) | 6 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 11 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 18 | Natchitoches, LA | Christmas Festival Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 9 | Texas St. | 0 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 20 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 12 | McNeese St. (LA) | 6 | Lake Charles, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 6 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 0 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 7 | Lamar (TX) | 20 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 0 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 52 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Samford (AL) | 12 | Rhodes (TN) | 20 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Samford (AL) | 26 | Mississippi College | 0 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Samford (AL) | 2 | Memphis NAS (TN) | 7 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Samford (AL) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 21 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Samford (AL) | 9 | Millsaps (MS) | 14 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Samford (AL) | 14 | Tennessee-Martin | 14 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Samford (AL) | 12 | Troy (AL) | 33 | Andalusia, AL | |
| 1958 | W | San Angelo JC (TX) | 20 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 24 | Montana | 13 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Diego (CA) | 0 | San Diego Marines (CA) | 35 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | San Diego (CA) | 6 | Montana St. | 31 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 20 | University of Mexico | 6 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 13 | Western New Mexico | 10 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 33 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 0 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 46 | Western St. (CO) | 14 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 45 | Pepperdine (CA) | 13 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego (CA) | 24 | Idaho St. | 0 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Diego Freshmen (CA) | 0 | US International (CA) | 82 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego Marines (CA) | 35 | San Diego (CA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego Marines (CA) | 25 | San Diego St. (CA) | 0 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | W | San Diego Marines (CA) | 27 | Hawaii | 0 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | San Diego Marines (CA) | 19 | Northern Arizona | 25 | Flagstaff, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | San Diego Marines (CA) | 20 | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Diego St. (CA) | 20 | Fresno St. (CA) | 22 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | W | San Diego St. (CA) | 20 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 12 | Long Beach, CA | Veterans Stadium |
| 1958 | L | San Diego St. (CA) | 0 | San Diego Marines (CA) | 25 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | L | San Diego St. (CA) | 0 | California-Santa Barbara | 25 | Santa Barbara, CA | La Playa Stadium |
| 1958 | W | San Diego St. (CA) | 6 | Pepperdine (CA) | 0 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | W | San Diego St. (CA) | 7 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 0 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | L | San Diego St. (CA) | 14 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 48 | San Luis Obispo, CA | Mustang (Poly) Stadium |
| 1958 | L | San Diego St. (CA) | 17 | Pacific (CA) | 68 | San Diego, CA | Aztec Bowl |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco (CA) | 14 | California-Davis JV | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | San Francisco (CA) | 6 | San Francisco St. JV (CA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | San Francisco (CA) | 20 | San Francisco St. JV (CA) | 40 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco (CA) | 18 | Treasure Island Navy (CA) | 15 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | San Francisco St. (CA) | 12 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 13 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 20 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 18 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 25 | Occidental (CA) | 16 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 14 | Cal St.-Long Beach | 0 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 20 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 18 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 18 | Nevada | 6 | Reno, NV | |
| 1958 | L | San Francisco St. (CA) | 14 | California-Santa Barbara | 20 | Santa Barbara, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 27 | California-Davis | 14 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. (CA) | 34 | Cal St.-Chico | 6 | San Francisco, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Francisco St. (CA) | 0 | Fresno St. (CA) | 35 | Fresno, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. JV (CA) | 30 | San Francisco (CA) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Francisco St. JV (CA) | 40 | San Francisco (CA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Jose City JC (CA) | 30 | Ventura JC (CA) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | San Jose St. (CA) | 41 | Idaho | 6 | Boise, ID | |
| 1958 | L | San Jose St. (CA) | 13 | Pacific (CA) | 26 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo | 10 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | Washington | 14 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | Hawaii | 8 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Jose St. (CA) | 21 | Arizona St. | 20 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | San Jose St. (CA) | 27 | Denver (CO) | 7 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | San Jose St. (CA) | 48 | Fresno St. (CA) | 6 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | L | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | Iowa St. | 9 | San Jose, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Santa Monica College (CA) | 53 | Mesa St. (CO) | 34 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Santa Monica College (CA) | 30 | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 12 | Pasadena, CA | Junior Rose Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Santa Monica College (CA) | 30 | Ventura JC (CA) | 16 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Savannah St. (GA) | 28 | Morris (SC) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Savannah St. (GA) | 44 | Paine (GA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Savannah St. (GA) | 0 | Albany St. (GA) | 8 | Albany, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Savannah St. (GA) | 24 | Edward Waters (FL) | 6 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Savannah St. (GA) | 12 | Alabama St. | 8 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Savannah St. (GA) | 22 | Florida N&I | 20 | Savannah, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Savannah St. (GA) | 12 | Benedict (SC) | 24 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Savannah St. (GA) | 14 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Savannah, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Savannah St. (GA) | 18 | Claflin (SC) | 22 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Scottsbluff JC (NE) | 24 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Scranton (PA) | 33 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 14 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Scranton (PA) | 21 | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Scranton (PA) | 0 | Boston College (MA) | 48 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Scranton (PA) | 0 | Juniata (PA) | 24 | Huntingdon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Scranton (PA) | 26 | King's (PA) | 0 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Scranton (PA) | 6 | Temple (PA) | 0 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Scranton (PA) | 25 | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Scranton (PA) | 14 | Albright (PA) | 30 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 16 | Southern Oregon | 12 | Coos Bay, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 27 | British Columbia (BC) | 25 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | W | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 27 | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 20 | Centre (KY) | 0 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 47 | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 12 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 0 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 44 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 20 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 21 | Samford (AL) | 0 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 48 | Mississippi College | 8 | Clinton, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 46 | Maryville (TN) | 0 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Sewanee (TN) | 47 | Rhodes (TN) | 0 | Sewanee, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Shaw (NC) | 12 | North Carolina Central | 20 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 6 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 0 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Shaw (NC) | 12 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 44 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 19 | Virginia St. | 14 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 6 | Virginia Union | 0 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 38 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 0 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 12 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 0 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Shaw (NC) | 54 | Lincoln (PA) | 8 | Lincoln, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Shaw (NC) | 8 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 30 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Shepherd (WV) | 37 | Concord (WV) | 14 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Shepherd (WV) | 33 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Shepherd (WV) | 38 | Bridgewater (VA) | 0 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Shepherd (WV) | 27 | Potomac St. (WV) | 7 | Keyser, WV | |
| 1958 | T | Shepherd (WV) | 7 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 7 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Shepherd (WV) | 6 | Shippensburg (PA) | 10 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Shepherd (WV) | 20 | West Virginia Tech | 14 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Shepherd (WV) | 20 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 21 | Newport News, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Shippensburg (PA) | 50 | Cheyney (PA) | 13 | Cheyney, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Shippensburg (PA) | 14 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Shippensburg (PA) | 54 | Mansfield (PA) | 6 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Shippensburg (PA) | 0 | California (PA) | 19 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Shippensburg (PA) | 19 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 20 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Shippensburg (PA) | 10 | Shepherd (WV) | 6 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Shippensburg (PA) | 7 | Clarion (PA) | 12 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Shippensburg (PA) | 20 | West Chester (PA) | 40 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Shorter College (AR) | 32 | Butler College (TX) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Shorter College (AR) | 6 | Coahoma CC (MS) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Shorter College (AR) | 14 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Shorter College (AR) | 13 | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 44 | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 19 | Winona St. (MN) | 8 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 32 | Dakota St. (SD) | 0 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 26 | Yankton (SD) | 0 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 34 | Jamestown (ND) | 0 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 46 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Si Tanka (SD) | 7 | South Dakota-Springfield | 7 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 55 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 27 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 6 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Si Tanka (SD) | 20 | Northern St. (SD) | 0 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Simpson (IA) | 12 | Central (IA) | 12 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Simpson (IA) | 0 | Buena Vista (IA) | 16 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Simpson (IA) | 0 | Iowa Wesleyan | 14 | Mount Pleasant, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Simpson (IA) | 19 | Dubuque (IA) | 27 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Simpson (IA) | 7 | Luther (IA) | 40 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Simpson (IA) | 28 | Parsons (IA) | 14 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Simpson (IA) | 20 | Upper Iowa | 19 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Simpson (IA) | 12 | Wartburg (IA) | 34 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Sioux Falls (SD) | 7 | Northern St. (SD) | 52 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Sioux Falls (SD) | 23 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 13 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Sioux Falls (SD) | 14 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | T | Sioux Falls (SD) | 6 | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Sioux Falls (SD) | 18 | Dakota St. (SD) | 7 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Sioux Falls (SD) | 0 | South Dakota-Springfield | 21 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Sioux Falls (SD) | 6 | Si Tanka (SD) | 27 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Sioux Falls (SD) | 0 | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Lock Haven (PA) | 13 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Slippery Rock (PA) | 14 | Clarion (PA) | 12 | Clarion, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Westminster (PA) | 7 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 0 | Indiana (PA) | 13 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 0 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 15 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Edinboro (PA) | 6 | Edinboro, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | California (PA) | 34 | California, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Slippery Rock (PA) | 20 | Geneva (PA) | 40 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Edinboro (PA) | 0 | Corry, PA | Beaver Bowl |
| 1958 | L | South All-Stars | 13 | North All-Stars | 15 | Mobile, AL | Senior Bowl |
| 1958 | W | South All-Stars | 49 | North All-Stars | 20 | Miami, FL | N-S All-Star Shrine Game |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina | 6 | Maryland | 10 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 24 | Georgia | 14 | Athens, GA | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 32 | Furman (SC) | 7 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina | 0 | North Carolina | 6 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 8 | Duke (NC) | 0 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina | 8 | Army (NY) | 45 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 26 | Clemson (SC) | 6 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 28 | Virginia | 14 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 12 | North Carolina St. | 7 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina | 24 | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina St. | 8 | Florida A&M | 28 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 26 | Allen (SC) | 6 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 64 | Alabama A&M | 6 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina St. | 14 | North Carolina A&T | 16 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 24 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 0 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 38 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 0 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 20 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | Fort Valley, GA | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 27 | Morris Brown (GA) | 6 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina St. | 14 | Benedict (SC) | 6 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina Trade | 28 | Morristown College (TN) | 6 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina Trade | 8 | Kittrell College (NC) | 12 | Kittrell, NC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina Trade | 12 | Edward Waters (FL) | 34 | Jacksonville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina Trade | 20 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 8 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Carolina Trade | 0 | Florida N&I | 6 | Saint Augustine, FL | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina Trade | 8 | Livingstone (NC) | 2 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | W | South Carolina Trade | 34 | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | T | South Carolina Trade | 6 | Voorhees College (SC) | 6 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota | 0 | Iowa St. | 53 | Ames, IA | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota | 14 | North Dakota | 28 | Grand Forks, ND | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota | 13 | North Dakota St. | 8 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota | 8 | Morningside (IA) | 0 | Sioux City, IA | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota | 2 | Southeast Missouri St. | 6 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota | 22 | Northwest Missouri St. | 8 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota | 12 | Augustana (SD) | 13 | Sioux Falls, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota | 28 | South Dakota St. | 7 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota | 38 | Northern Iowa | 14 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota St. | 26 | Morningside (IA) | 6 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota St. | 20 | Augustana (SD) | 6 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota St. | 13 | Northern Iowa | 8 | Cedar Falls, IA | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota St. | 12 | North Dakota | 30 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota St. | 12 | Drake (IA) | 6 | Brookings, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota St. | 7 | Marquette (WI) | 18 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota St. | 6 | Montana St. | 23 | Bozeman, MT | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota St. | 7 | South Dakota | 28 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota St. | 20 | North Dakota St. | 33 | Fargo, ND | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Si Tanka (SD) | 44 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota Tech | 32 | Dakota St. (SD) | 0 | Madison, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Yankton (SD) | 13 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota Tech | 13 | Northern St. (SD) | 26 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | T | South Dakota Tech | 7 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 7 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | T | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 6 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | T | South Dakota Tech | 12 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 12 | Mitchell, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota Tech | 0 | South Dakota-Springfield | 20 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 19 | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota-Springfield | 0 | Northern St. (SD) | 13 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 23 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 0 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | L | South Dakota-Springfield | 20 | Chadron St. (NE) | 26 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | T | South Dakota-Springfield | 7 | Si Tanka (SD) | 7 | Huron, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 21 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 0 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 20 | South Dakota Tech | 0 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 32 | Dakota St. (SD) | 6 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Dakota-Springfield | 38 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 6 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | W | South Georgia College | 28 | West Georgia | 0 | Douglas, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 48 | Truman St. (MO) | 12 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 42 | Central Missouri St. | 6 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 33 | Northwest Missouri St. | 14 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 6 | South Dakota | 2 | Vermillion, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Southeast Missouri St. | 0 | Western Kentucky | 12 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 26 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 7 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 19 | Missouri S&T | 7 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Southeast Missouri St. | 19 | Missouri St. | 6 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | T | Southeast Missouri St. | 27 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 27 | Cape Girardeau, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Louisiana | 6 | Louisiana Tech | 10 | Ruston, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Louisiana | 6 | Southern Mississippi | 33 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Louisiana | 14 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 6 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Louisiana | 20 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 35 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Louisiana | 40 | North Alabama | 7 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Louisiana | 8 | Louisiana-Monroe | 22 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Louisiana | 7 | McNeese St. (LA) | 6 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Louisiana | 0 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 7 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Louisiana | 19 | Tampa (FL) | 0 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 34 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 13 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 13 | Austin (TX) | 6 | Denison, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Central Oklahoma | 8 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 24 | Langston (OK) | 14 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 11 | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 7 | Arkansas Tech | 18 | Durant, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 6 | East Central (OK) | 7 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southern (LA) | 6 | Texas College | 13 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 56 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | Lorman, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 23 | Tennessee St. | 14 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 50 | Xavier (LA) | 0 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 30 | Texas Southern | 6 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 34 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 30 | Jackson St. (MS) | 6 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 21 | Wiley (TX) | 6 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern (LA) | 35 | Florida A&M | 6 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern (LA) | 14 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 20 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 7 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Arkansas St. | 48 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 7 | Arkansas Tech | 26 | Russellville, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 12 | Louisiana-Monroe | 33 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 0 | East Central (OK) | 18 | Ada, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 34 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Arkansas | 13 | Delta St. (MS) | 6 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Louisiana College | 52 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Hendrix (AR) | 7 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Arkansas | 6 | Arkansas-Monticello | 21 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern California | 29 | Stanford (CA) | 6 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern California | 7 | North Carolina | 8 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern California | 21 | Washington | 6 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern California | 0 | Oregon | 25 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern California | 21 | Oregon St. | 0 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern California | 19 | Michigan | 20 | Ann Arbor, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Southern California | 12 | California | 14 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern California | 14 | Washington St. | 6 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | T | Southern California | 15 | UCLA | 15 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Southern California | 13 | Notre Dame (IN) | 20 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 30 | Quonset NAS (RI) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 42 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 6 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 22 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 50 | Berea, OH | Baldwin-Wallace Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 78 | American International (MA) | 42 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 36 | Norwich (VT) | 6 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Connecticut St. | 15 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 35 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 0 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 40 | Central Connecticut St. | 0 | New Britain, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Connecticut St. | 32 | Bridgeport (CT) | 20 | Bridgeport, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 36 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 7 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 32 | Western Illinois | 31 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 24 | Central Michigan | 7 | Mount Pleasant, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 29 | Eastern Illinois | 8 | Charleston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 34 | Evansville (IN) | 14 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 19 | West Virginia St. | 0 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Illinois | 8 | Illinois St. | 21 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Illinois | 13 | Eastern Michigan | 9 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Illinois | 7 | Northern Illinois | 17 | DeKalb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 26 | Texas | 10 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Methodist (TX) | 6 | Notre Dame (IN) | 14 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 33 | Texas A&M | 0 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 32 | Missouri | 19 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Ohio St. | 23 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Methodist (TX) | 7 | Rice (TX) | 13 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Georgia Tech | 0 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Methodist (TX) | 6 | Arkansas | 13 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 33 | Baylor (TX) | 29 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Texas Christian | 13 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Mississippi | 9 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 10 | Orlando, FL | Tangerine Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 22 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 0 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 24 | Memphis (TN) | 22 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 26 | North Carolina St. | 14 | Mobile, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 33 | Southeastern Louisiana | 6 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 14 | Louisiana Tech | 0 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 15 | Trinity (TX) | 0 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 15 | West Texas A&M | 0 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 41 | Virginia Tech | 0 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Mississippi | 20 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 13 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Oregon | 12 | Seattle Ramblers (WA) | 16 | Coos Bay, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Oregon | 13 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 60 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Oregon | 19 | Eastern Oregon | 12 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Oregon | 21 | Portland St. (OR) | 14 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Oregon | 25 | Moffett Field (CA) | 24 | Medford, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Oregon | 25 | Moffett Field (CA) | 40 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Oregon | 25 | British Columbia (BC) | 6 | Ashland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Southern Oregon | 0 | Oregon Tech | 40 | Klamath Falls, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Southern Oregon | 0 | Western Oregon | 21 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Oregon | 0 | Eastern Washington | 34 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | T | Southern Union College (AL) | 0 | West Alabama | 0 | ? | Game results unknown |
| 1958 | W | Southern Union College (AL) | 34 | West Georgia | 6 | Wadley, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Southern Utah | 0 | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | Cedar City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Southwest All-Stars | 22 | National All-Stars | 13 | Tempe, AZ | Copper Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 19 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 25 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 21 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Bethel (KS) | 14 | North Newton, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Baker (KS) | 6 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Southwestern (KS) | 19 | Sterling (KS) | 13 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 6 | Emporia St. (KS) | 13 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Benedictine (KS) | 48 | Atchison, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Washburn (KS) | 27 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Southwestern (KS) | 6 | Kansas Wesleyan | 6 | Salina, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 34 | Goodwell, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 24 | Northwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Alva, OK | |
| 1958 | T | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 7 | Eastern New Mexico | 7 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Central Oklahoma | 6 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Colorado College | 13 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 26 | East Central (OK) | 0 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 14 | Northeastern St. (OK) | 34 | Tahlequah, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Southeastern Oklahoma St. | 11 | Weatherford, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Southwestern Oklahoma St. | 0 | Langston (OK) | 8 | Langston, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 14 | Rhode Island | 28 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Springfield (MA) | 32 | Northeastern (MA) | 30 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 20 | New Hampshire | 43 | Durham, NH | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 8 | Colby (ME) | 28 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 14 | Connecticut | 41 | Storrs, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 0 | Amherst (MA) | 12 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 12 | Brandeis (MA) | 34 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | T | Springfield (MA) | 6 | American International (MA) | 6 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Springfield (MA) | 13 | Hofstra (NY) | 14 | Springfield, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 6 | Southern California | 29 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Northwestern (IL) | 28 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Oregon | 12 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Stanford (CA) | 22 | Washington | 12 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 6 | Washington St. | 40 | Pullman, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 7 | Rice (TX) | 30 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 0 | Air Force (CO) | 16 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Stanford (CA) | 21 | UCLA | 19 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 16 | Oregon St. | 24 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Stanford (CA) | 15 | California | 16 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 38 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 6 | Lamar (TX) | 35 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 48 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 7 | Howard Payne (TX) | 13 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Louisiana-Monroe | 14 | Monroe, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 34 | Southern Arkansas | 0 | Magnolia, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 13 | Texas St. | 29 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 0 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sterling (KS) | 27 | Tarkio (MO) | 13 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Sterling (KS) | 18 | Friends (KS) | 0 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Sterling (KS) | 26 | Westmar (IA) | 6 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Sterling (KS) | 7 | McPherson (KS) | 33 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Sterling (KS) | 2 | Bethany (KS) | 20 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Sterling (KS) | 13 | Southwestern (KS) | 19 | Winfield, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Sterling (KS) | 14 | College of Emporia (KS) | 41 | Emporia, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Sterling (KS) | 32 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Sterling JC (CO) | 2 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | University of Mexico | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 38 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 27 | Howard Payne (TX) | 13 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 0 | Texas St. | 20 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | McMurry (TX) | 34 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Portales, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 0 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 7 | Lamar (TX) | 46 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 56 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 20 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 8 | Ithaca (NY) | 22 | Ithaca, NY | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 40 | Alfred (NY) | 14 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 20 | Clarion (PA) | 12 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | Mansfield (PA) | 7 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | Lock Haven (PA) | 0 | Lock Haven, PA | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 0 | Southern Connecticut St. | 35 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 20 | SUNY-Brockport (NY) | 6 | Brockport, NY | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 6 | Buffalo (NY) | 7 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 42 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 8 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 0 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 16 | Bloomsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 36 | Alfred (NY) | 0 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 16 | Ithaca (NY) | 6 | Cortland, NY | |
| 1958 | W | SUNY-Cortland (NY) | 8 | Hofstra (NY) | 0 | Hempstead, NY | |
| 1958 | L | SUNY-Farmingdale (NY) | 0 | Long Island-CW Post (NY) | 48 | Brookville, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Susquehanna (PA) | 12 | California (PA) | 34 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Susquehanna (PA) | 6 | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Susquehanna (PA) | 6 | Wagner (NY) | 13 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Susquehanna (PA) | 7 | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Susquehanna (PA) | 39 | Dickinson (PA) | 14 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Susquehanna (PA) | 12 | Grove City (PA) | 14 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Susquehanna (PA) | 7 | Haverford (PA) | 8 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 6 | Wesleyan (CT) | 14 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 12 | Oberlin (OH) | 21 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 24 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Susquehanna (PA) | 7 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 8 | Hamilton (NY) | 34 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Swarthmore (PA) | 24 | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Widener (PA) | 1 | Swarthmore, PA | Swarthmore Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Haverford (PA) | 28 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 16 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 13 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Syracuse (NY) | 13 | Holy Cross (MA) | 14 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 42 | Boston (MA) | 0 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 55 | Cornell (NY) | 0 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 24 | Boston College (MA) | 14 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 38 | Nebraska | 0 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 14 | Penn St. | 6 | State College, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 47 | Colgate (NY) | 0 | Syracuse, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Syracuse (NY) | 15 | West Virginia | 12 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Tampa (FL) | 0 | Florida St. | 43 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 19 | Western Carolina (NC) | 12 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 12 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 6 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 20 | Arkansas St. | 14 | Jonesboro, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 39 | Troy (AL) | 6 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tampa (FL) | 12 | Virginia Military Institute | 13 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 18 | Presbyterian (SC) | 6 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Tampa (FL) | 25 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 19 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tampa (FL) | 26 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 34 | Lakeland, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tampa (FL) | 0 | Southeastern Louisiana | 19 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tarkio (MO) | 13 | Sterling (KS) | 27 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Tarkio (MO) | 0 | Missouri Valley | 46 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Tarkio (MO) | 6 | William Jewell (MO) | 32 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Tarkio (MO) | 19 | Dana (NE) | 6 | Blair, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Tarkio (MO) | 37 | Central Methodist (MO) | 0 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Tarkio (MO) | 7 | Carthage (WI) | 27 | Carthage, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Tarkio (MO) | 19 | Graceland (IA) | 13 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Tarkio (MO) | 2 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 14 | Canton, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Tarkio (MO) | 13 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Tarleton St. (TX) | 15 | Cameron (OK) | 26 | Stephenville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Tarleton St. (TX) | 0 | Texas-Arlington | 34 | Stephenville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 6 | Central St. (OH) | 20 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 0 | Anderson (IN) | 26 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Taylor (IN) | 13 | Manchester (IN) | 7 | North Manchester, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 19 | Hanover (IN) | 40 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 14 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Taylor (IN) | 19 | Franklin (IN) | 13 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 7 | Northern Michigan | 27 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Taylor (IN) | 28 | Earlham (IN) | 0 | Richmond, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Taylor (IN) | 13 | Indianapolis (IN) | 26 | Upland, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 6 | Buffalo (NY) | 54 | Buffalo, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 14 | Delaware | 35 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 6 | Bucknell (PA) | 44 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 18 | Muhlenberg (PA) | 21 | Allentown, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 0 | Lafayette (PA) | 35 | Easton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 0 | Scranton (PA) | 6 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 6 | Gettysburg (PA) | 22 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Temple (PA) | 6 | Hofstra (NY) | 34 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 7 | North Carolina | 21 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee | 13 | Mississippi St. | 8 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 6 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 14 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 7 | Georgia Tech | 21 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 0 | Auburn (AL) | 13 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee | 14 | Alabama | 7 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 0 | Florida St. | 10 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee | 18 | Mississippi | 16 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee | 2 | Kentucky | 6 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee | 10 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee St. | 32 | Morris Brown (GA) | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee St. | 14 | Southern (LA) | 23 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee St. | 6 | Grambling St. (LA) | 7 | Grambling, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee St. | 23 | North Carolina A&T | 6 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee St. | 20 | Central St. (OH) | 6 | Wilberforce, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee St. | 12 | Lincoln (MO) | 24 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee St. | 13 | Jackson St. (MS) | 18 | Jackson, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee St. | 19 | Kentucky St. | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 13 | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 12 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 22 | Morehead St. (KY) | 7 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 20 | Eastern Kentucky | 19 | Richmond, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee Tech | 14 | East Tennessee St. | 25 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee Tech | 7 | Florida St. | 22 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee Tech | 0 | Memphis (TN) | 13 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 7 | Western Kentucky | 3 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 15 | Murray St. (KY) | 14 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 20 | North Alabama | 14 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee Tech | 14 | Middle Tennessee St. | 0 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee Tech JV | 0 | Tennessee-Martin | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 12 | Tennessee Tech | 13 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 8 | Auburn (AL) | 30 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 14 | Tennessee | 6 | Knoxville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 26 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 0 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 55 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 0 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 22 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 12 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 18 | Middle Tennessee St. | 7 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 7 | Memphis (TN) | 22 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 19 | Tampa (FL) | 25 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tennessee-Chattanooga | 13 | Southern Mississippi | 20 | Chattanooga, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 16 | Memphis NAS (TN) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 20 | Tennessee Tech JV | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 14 | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 34 | Hendrix (AR) | 0 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 33 | Georgetown (KY) | 7 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 7 | Central Arkansas | 6 | Conway, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Tennessee-Martin | 32 | Ozarks (AR) | 7 | Martin, TN | |
| 1958 | T | Tennessee-Martin | 14 | Samford (AL) | 14 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Texarkana JC (TX) | 8 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Texarkana JC (TX) | 21 | Wingate (NC) | 6 | ? | Pine Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Texas | 7 | Mississippi | 39 | New Orleans, LA | Sugar Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Texas | 10 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 26 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 12 | Texas Tech | 7 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 20 | Baylor (TX) | 15 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 15 | Oklahoma | 14 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 13 | Georgia | 8 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 21 | Tulane (LA) | 20 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 24 | Arkansas | 6 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas | 7 | Rice (TX) | 34 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas | 8 | Texas Christian | 22 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas | 27 | Texas A&M | 0 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 8 | Arkansas | 21 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M | 12 | Missouri | 0 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 0 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 33 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M | 14 | Maryland | 10 | College Park, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 14 | Texas Tech | 15 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 7 | Houston (TX) | 39 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 8 | Texas Christian | 24 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M | 33 | Baylor (TX) | 27 | Waco, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M | 28 | Rice (TX) | 21 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M | 0 | Texas | 27 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 10 | Southern Mississippi | 9 | Orlando, FL | Tangerine Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 13 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 32 | Howard Payne (TX) | 12 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 48 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 12 | Nacogdoches, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Commerce | 0 | Lamar (TX) | 21 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 27 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 6 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 35 | Southeastern Louisiana | 20 | Hammond, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 39 | McMurry (TX) | 21 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 52 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 0 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 47 | Texas St. | 0 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 56 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Commerce | 26 | Missouri Valley | 7 | Orlando, FL | Tangerine Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 6 | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 20 | Austin (TX) | 7 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 14 | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 14 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 37 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Louisiana College | 14 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Lamar (TX) | 26 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 21 | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Texas Southern | 20 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 12 | New Mexico Highlands | 20 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 13 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 22 | Texas St. | 0 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 0 | Lamar (TX) | 14 | Beaumont, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 20 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 21 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 37 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 14 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 0 | Trinity (TX) | 25 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 26 | Texas Lutheran | 8 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 0 | Alpine, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 7 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 0 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 21 | Howard Payne (TX) | 6 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 27 | University of Mexico | 0 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 22 | Baylor (TX) | 0 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 12 | Arkansas | 7 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 36 | Marquette (WI) | 8 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 26 | Texas Tech | 0 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 42 | Kansas | 0 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Christian | 0 | Iowa | 17 | Iowa City, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 24 | Texas A&M | 8 | College Station, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 22 | Texas | 8 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Christian | 22 | Rice (TX) | 10 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Christian | 13 | Southern Methodist (TX) | 20 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas College | 13 | Southern (LA) | 6 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas College | 20 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas College | 0 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 43 | Prairie View, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas College | 6 | Langston (OK) | 22 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas College | 32 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 0 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas College | 13 | Texas Southern | 12 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas College | 12 | Bishop (TX) | 20 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas College | 32 | Dillard (LA) | 0 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas College | 12 | Wiley (TX) | 19 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Pensacola NAS (FL) | 27 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 0 | McMurry (TX) | 63 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 14 | Corpus Christi, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 0 | Texas St. | 27 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 8 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 26 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Louisiana College | 27 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 12 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 43 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Lutheran | 7 | Austin (TX) | 19 | Seguin, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Southern | 8 | Brooke Army Medical Center (TX) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Texas Southern | 6 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 6 | Houston, TX | Prairie View Bowl |
| 1958 | W | Texas Southern | 14 | Wiley (TX) | 0 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Southern | 21 | Grambling St. (LA) | 7 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Southern | 47 | Fort Hood (TX) | 6 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Southern | 6 | Southern (LA) | 30 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Southern | 19 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 26 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Southern | 12 | Texas College | 13 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Southern | 20 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | 0 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Southern | 40 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 0 | Pine Bluff, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Southern | 18 | Florida A&M | 22 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Texas St. | 8 | Lamar (TX) | 7 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas St. | 0 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 22 | Kingsville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas St. | 0 | Sam Houston St. (TX) | 9 | Huntsville, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas St. | 20 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 0 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas St. | 0 | McNeese St. (LA) | 21 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas St. | 27 | Texas Lutheran | 0 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas St. | 12 | Howard Payne (TX) | 7 | Brownwood, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas St. | 29 | Stephen F. Austin (TX) | 13 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas St. | 18 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 44 | San Marcos, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas St. | 0 | Texas A&M-Commerce | 47 | Commerce, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 7 | Texas | 12 | Austin, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Tech | 33 | Arizona | 6 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 0 | Texas Christian | 26 | Fort Worth, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Tech | 15 | Texas A&M | 14 | Dallas, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas Tech | 32 | West Texas A&M | 7 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 7 | Baylor (TX) | 26 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 0 | Tulane (LA) | 27 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 7 | Tulsa (OK) | 9 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 8 | Arkansas | 14 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas Tech | 17 | Houston (TX) | 22 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | T | Texas-Arlington | 12 | Del Mar JC (TX) | 12 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 19 | Navarro JC (TX) | 0 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 41 | Cameron (OK) | 7 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 32 | Victoria JC (TX) | 0 | Victoria, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 19 | Paris JC (TX) | 0 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-Arlington | 6 | Tyler JC (TX) | 18 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-Arlington | 14 | Wharton County JC (TX) | 33 | Wharton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 21 | Kilgore College (TX) | 0 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 21 | Angelo St. (TX) | 6 | Arlington, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-Arlington | 34 | Tarleton St. (TX) | 0 | Stephenville, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 6 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 6 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 14 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 0 | Arizona St. | 27 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-El Paso | 29 | West Texas A&M | 12 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 8 | North Texas | 26 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Texas-El Paso | 15 | New Mexico | 6 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 16 | New Mexico St. | 17 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 12 | Arizona | 14 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Texas-El Paso | 0 | Trinity (TX) | 49 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Thiel (PA) | 26 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 7 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Thiel (PA) | 0 | John Carroll (OH) | 7 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Thiel (PA) | 6 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 14 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Thiel (PA) | 7 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 15 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Thiel (PA) | 6 | Westminster (PA) | 14 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Thiel (PA) | 19 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Thiel (PA) | 12 | Allegheny (PA) | 12 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Toledo (OH) | 6 | Kent St. (OH) | 32 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Toledo (OH) | 13 | Louisville (KY) | 7 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Toledo (OH) | 8 | Xavier (OH) | 34 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Toledo (OH) | 12 | Marshall (WV) | 35 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Toledo (OH) | 19 | Eastern Kentucky | 2 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Toledo (OH) | 6 | Ohio | 13 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Toledo (OH) | 16 | Bowling Green (OH) | 31 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Toledo (OH) | 21 | Western Michigan | 6 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Toledo (OH) | 21 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 8 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Miles (AL) | 40 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Dillard (LA) | 34 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Tougaloo (MS) | 13 | Jarvis Christian (TX) | 8 | Hawkins, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Mississippi Industrial Training School | 66 | Holly Springs, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Leland (LA) | 2 | Baker, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 14 | Paul Quinn (TX) | 22 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 6 | Rust (MS) | 36 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Philander-Smith (AR) | 45 | Little Rock, AR | |
| 1958 | L | Tougaloo (MS) | 0 | Bishop (TX) | 27 | Tougaloo, MS | |
| 1958 | T | Tougaloo (MS) | 12 | Daniel Payne College (AL) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Treasure Island Navy (CA) | 15 | San Francisco (CA) | 18 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 0 | Boise JC (ID) | 55 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 7 | Fort Lewis (CO) | 23 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Trinidad St. JC (CO) | 7 | Mesa St. (CO) | 8 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (CT) | 51 | Coast Guard (CT) | 8 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Amherst (MA) | 22 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (CT) | 6 | Tufts (MA) | 20 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Denison (OH) | 27 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Williams (MA) | 0 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (CT) | 30 | Colby (ME) | 20 | Waterville, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (CT) | 18 | Alfred (NY) | 8 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (CT) | 18 | Wesleyan (CT) | 22 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 80 | North Dakota St. | 6 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (TX) | 0 | Mississippi | 21 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 20 | New Mexico St. | 0 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 25 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 0 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (TX) | 0 | Southern Mississippi | 15 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 35 | West Texas A&M | 7 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Trinity (TX) | 18 | Louisiana-Lafayette | 22 | Lafayette, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 26 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 15 | San Antonio, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Trinity (TX) | 49 | Texas-El Paso | 0 | El Paso, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 10 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 12 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Troy (AL) | 16 | Delta St. (MS) | 0 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 6 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 13 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 7 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 20 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Troy (AL) | 22 | West Alabama | 6 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 6 | Tampa (FL) | 39 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 14 | Newberry (SC) | 28 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Troy (AL) | 14 | North Alabama | 20 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Troy (AL) | 33 | Samford (AL) | 12 | Andalusia, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Truman St. (MO) | 12 | Southeast Missouri St. | 48 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Truman St. (MO) | 25 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 31 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Truman St. (MO) | 20 | Northwest Missouri St. | 19 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Truman St. (MO) | 39 | Missouri St. | 7 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Truman St. (MO) | 12 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 21 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Truman St. (MO) | 26 | Washburn (KS) | 13 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Truman St. (MO) | 27 | Graceland (IA) | 7 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Truman St. (MO) | 32 | Central Missouri St. | 13 | Warrensburg, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Truman St. (MO) | 20 | Missouri S&T | 27 | Rolla, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Tucson Cowboys | 28 | Major-College All-Stars | 56 | Tucson, AZ | Optimist Bowl (1) |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 42 | Amherst (MA) | 7 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 24 | Bates (ME) | 14 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Tufts (MA) | 6 | Rochester (NY) | 46 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 20 | Trinity (CT) | 6 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 26 | Bowdoin (ME) | 6 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 28 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 18 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Tufts (MA) | 8 | Williams (MA) | 37 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Tufts (MA) | 16 | Lafayette (PA) | 8 | Medford, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 0 | Georgia Tech | 14 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Tulane (LA) | 13 | Alabama | 7 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 8 | Mississippi | 19 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 14 | Florida | 34 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 20 | Texas | 21 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Tulane (LA) | 14 | Navy (MD) | 6 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 9 | Kansas | 14 | Lawrence, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Tulane (LA) | 27 | Texas Tech | 0 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 0 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 12 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tulane (LA) | 0 | Louisiana St. | 62 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 25 | Houston (TX) | 20 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 34 | Arizona | 0 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Tulsa (OK) | 6 | Cincinnati (OH) | 15 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 24 | Oklahoma St. | 16 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Tulsa (OK) | 0 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 14 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 27 | Arkansas | 14 | Fayetteville, AR | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 59 | Drake (IA) | 0 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Tulsa (OK) | 7 | North Texas | 8 | Denton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 9 | Texas Tech | 7 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Tulsa (OK) | 25 | Wichita St. (KS) | 6 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | T | Tuskegee (AL) | 6 | Fort Valley St. (GA) | 6 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 26 | Fisk (TN) | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Tuskegee (AL) | 7 | Miles (AL) | 14 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Tuskegee (AL) | 0 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 14 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 18 | Alabama A&M | 6 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Tuskegee (AL) | 26 | Xavier (LA) | 27 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 44 | Knoxville (TN) | 6 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 18 | Morehouse (GA) | 6 | Columbus, GA | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 14 | Dillard (LA) | 13 | Tuskegee, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Tuskegee (AL) | 24 | Alabama St. | 20 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Tyler JC (TX) | 0 | Boise JC (ID) | 22 | Tyler, TX | NJCAA Championship |
| 1958 | W | Tyler JC (TX) | 18 | Texas-Arlington | 6 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Tyler JC (TX) | 33 | Cameron (OK) | 14 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 20 | Washington St. | 38 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 0 | Oregon St. | 14 | Corvallis, OR | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 17 | California | 20 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 14 | Florida | 21 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 6 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 27 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | UCLA | 18 | Illinois | 14 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | W | UCLA | 20 | Washington | 0 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | UCLA | 19 | Stanford (CA) | 21 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | W | UCLA | 7 | Oregon | 3 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | T | UCLA | 15 | Southern California | 15 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 6 | Williams (MA) | 40 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Amherst (MA) | 58 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 18 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Rochester (NY) | 47 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 6 | Bates (ME) | 27 | Lewiston, ME | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 21 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Hobart (NY) | 42 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Union (NY) | 0 | Hamilton (NY) | 18 | Clinton, NY | |
| 1958 | W | University of Mexico | 56 | Militarizada | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | University of Mexico | 18 | Pensacola NAS (FL) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | University of Mexico | 12 | Sul Ross St. (TX) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | University of Mexico | 14 | Cal Poly-Pomona | 29 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | L | University of Mexico | 6 | Cal St.-Los Angeles | 23 | Monterey Park, CA | At East Los Angeles JC |
| 1958 | L | University of Mexico | 6 | San Diego (CA) | 20 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | University of Mexico | 14 | New Mexico St. | 28 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | L | University of Mexico | 0 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | 27 | Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 1958 | W | University Prep School (OK) | 13 | Coffeyville CC (KS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Upper Iowa | 20 | Wartburg (IA) | 26 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Upper Iowa | 13 | Luther (IA) | 29 | Decorah, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Upper Iowa | 6 | Iowa Wesleyan | 14 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Upper Iowa | 13 | Buena Vista (IA) | 0 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Upper Iowa | 13 | Dubuque (IA) | 35 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Upper Iowa | 27 | Central (IA) | 7 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Upper Iowa | 19 | Simpson (IA) | 20 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Upper Iowa | 19 | Parsons (IA) | 7 | Fayette, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Wagner (NY) | 26 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Susquehanna (PA) | 6 | Selinsgrove, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Haverford (PA) | 38 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Johns Hopkins (MD) | 12 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Wilkes (PA) | 8 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Swarthmore (PA) | 24 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Dickinson (PA) | 34 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 6 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 34 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | T | US International (CA) | 42 | California Tech | 42 | Pasadena, CA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 18 | California-Riverside | 29 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 0 | Redlands (CA) | 41 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 8 | Occidental (CA) | 50 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | US International (CA) | 82 | San Diego Freshmen (CA) | 0 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 6 | La Verne (CA) | 34 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | US International (CA) | 14 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (CA) | 33 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 20 | Wyoming | 25 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 0 | Idaho | 20 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah | 47 | Hawaii | 20 | Honolulu, HI | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 0 | Colorado St. | 20 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 21 | California | 36 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Utah | 20 | Montana | 6 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 7 | Brigham Young (UT) | 14 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah | 20 | Denver (CO) | 16 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 14 | Air Force (CO) | 16 | Denver, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Utah | 0 | Colorado | 7 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah | 12 | Utah St. | 7 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 6 | Brigham Young (UT) | 13 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah St. | 20 | Kansas St. | 13 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 13 | Wyoming | 41 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 14 | New Mexico | 34 | Albuquerque, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 6 | Arizona | 7 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 8 | Denver (CO) | 20 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah St. | 27 | Montana | 14 | Missoula, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Utah St. | 15 | Colorado St. | 0 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 7 | Idaho | 34 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | L | Utah St. | 7 | Utah | 12 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 6 | Coahoma CC (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 27 | Meridian JC (MS) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 40 | Okolona Industrial School (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 50 | Piney Woods College (MS) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Utica Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 25 | Prentiss Normal and Industrial Institute (MS) | 6 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Valley City St. (ND) | 20 | Minot St. (ND) | 13 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Valley City St. (ND) | 14 | North Dakota-Ellendale | 13 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Valley City St. (ND) | 19 | Jamestown (ND) | 13 | Jamestown, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Valley City St. (ND) | 33 | North Dakota Science | 6 | Wahpeton, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Valley City St. (ND) | 6 | Mayville St. (ND) | 12 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | W | Valley City St. (ND) | 19 | Dickinson St. (ND) | 7 | Valley City, ND | |
| 1958 | L | Valparaiso (IN) | 12 | Indiana St. | 14 | Terre Haute, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Valparaiso (IN) | 8 | Evansville (IN) | 22 | Evansville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 78 | Indianapolis (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 37 | DePauw (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 18 | Northern Michigan | 13 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 6 | Ball St. (IN) | 0 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Valparaiso (IN) | 0 | Butler (IN) | 34 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 15 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 6 | Valparaiso, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Valparaiso (IN) | 27 | Wayne St. (MI) | 6 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Vanderbilt (TN) | 0 | Alabama | 0 | Birmingham, AL | |
| 1958 | T | Vanderbilt (TN) | 0 | Kentucky | 0 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Vanderbilt (TN) | 7 | Clemson (SC) | 12 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Vanderbilt (TN) | 12 | Missouri | 8 | Columbia, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Vanderbilt (TN) | 21 | Georgia | 14 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | T | Vanderbilt (TN) | 6 | Florida | 6 | Gainesville, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Vanderbilt (TN) | 39 | Virginia | 6 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Vanderbilt (TN) | 28 | Miami (FL) | 15 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Vanderbilt (TN) | 12 | Tulane (LA) | 0 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Vanderbilt (TN) | 6 | Tennessee | 10 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 0 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 66 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 14 | Compton JC (CA) | 28 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Ventura JC (CA) | 20 | Glendale CC (CA) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Ventura JC (CA) | 24 | Los Angeles City College (CA) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 20 | Los Angeles Pierce JC (CA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 6 | Monterey Peninsula College (CA) | 36 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 26 | Pasadena City College (CA) | 34 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 14 | San Jose City JC (CA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Ventura JC (CA) | 16 | Santa Monica College (CA) | 30 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Vermont | 26 | Saint Lawrence (NY) | 7 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Vermont | 0 | Maine | 26 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Vermont | 20 | Middlebury (VT) | 6 | Burlington, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Vermont | 14 | Hobart (NY) | 18 | Geneva, NY | |
| 1958 | T | Vermont | 30 | Coast Guard (CT) | 30 | New London, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Vermont | 0 | Rochester (NY) | 46 | Rochester, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Vermont | 12 | Norwich (VT) | 16 | Northfield, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Victoria Drakes | 13 | British Columbia (BC) | 19 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Victoria JC (TX) | 24 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Victoria JC (TX) | 0 | Texas-Arlington | 32 | Victoria, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Victoria JC (TX) | 20 | Cameron (OK) | 6 | Victoria, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Villanova (PA) | 6 | Wichita St. (KS) | 21 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 21 | Boston College (MA) | 19 | Chestnut Hill, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 9 | Dayton (OH) | 6 | Dayton, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 7 | Detroit (MI) | 0 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 28 | West Chester (PA) | 14 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Villanova (PA) | 6 | Virginia Military Institute | 33 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 9 | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Villanova (PA) | 13 | Richmond (VA) | 6 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Villanova (PA) | 0 | Army (NY) | 26 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Villanova (PA) | 13 | Quantico Marines (VA) | 19 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 0 | Virginia Military Institute | 33 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 14 | North Carolina St. | 26 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 0 | North Carolina | 42 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 13 | Virginia Tech | 22 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 15 | Clemson (SC) | 20 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia | 15 | Duke (NC) | 12 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 6 | Army (NY) | 35 | West Point, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 6 | Vanderbilt (TN) | 39 | Nashville, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 14 | South Carolina | 28 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia | 6 | Maryland | 44 | Charlottesville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 33 | Virginia | 0 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 12 | Richmond (VA) | 6 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Virginia Military Institute | 7 | Lehigh (PA) | 7 | Lynchburg, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Virginia Military Institute | 6 | William & Mary (VA) | 6 | Bluefield, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 46 | Morehead St. (KY) | 20 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 33 | Villanova (PA) | 6 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 13 | Tampa (FL) | 12 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute | 42 | Davidson (NC) | 7 | Davidson, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Military Institute | 6 | Citadel (SC) | 14 | Charleston, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Military Institute | 16 | Virginia Tech | 21 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Military Institute Freshmen | 27 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 0 | Virginia St. | 20 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia St. | 20 | Virginia Union | 0 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia St. | 14 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 6 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 6 | North Carolina A&T | 40 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia St. | 30 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 0 | Fayetteville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 0 | Morgan St. (MD) | 69 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia St. | 34 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 21 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 14 | Shaw (NC) | 19 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 0 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 18 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 6 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 20 | Princess Anne, MD | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 0 | Shaw (NC) | 6 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia St. | 50 | Lincoln (PA) | 6 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 0 | North Carolina Central | 33 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 18 | Hampton (VA) | 21 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 6 | North Carolina A&T | 34 | Greensboro, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 12 | Hampton (VA) | 21 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia St. | 6 | Morgan St. (MD) | 20 | Petersburg, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Virginia Tech | 14 | North Carolina St. | 14 | Raleigh, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Tech | 27 | William & Mary (VA) | 15 | Blacksburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Tech | 27 | Richmond (VA) | 23 | Blacksburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Tech | 22 | Virginia | 13 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Tech | 28 | West Texas A&M | 12 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Tech | 6 | Wake Forest (NC) | 13 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Tech | 0 | Florida St. | 28 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Tech | 20 | West Virginia | 21 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Tech | 0 | Southern Mississippi | 41 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Tech | 21 | Virginia Military Institute | 16 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 0 | Virginia St. | 20 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 6 | North Carolina A&T | 40 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 0 | Morgan St. (MD) | 69 | Baltimore, MD | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Union | 34 | District of Columbia Teachers (DC) | 21 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 0 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 18 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 0 | Shaw (NC) | 6 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Virginia Union | 50 | Lincoln (PA) | 6 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Virginia Union | 12 | Hampton (VA) | 21 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Voorhees College (SC) | 12 | Edward Waters (FL) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | Friendship JC (SC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | Kittrell College (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | T | Voorhees College (SC) | 0 | Morristown College (TN) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Voorhees College (SC) | 6 | Livingstone (NC) | 10 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Voorhees College (SC) | 12 | Norfolk St. (VA) | 16 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Voorhees College (SC) | 6 | South Carolina Trade | 6 | Denmark, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Wabash (IN) | 30 | Bradley (IL) | 6 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 13 | Washington (MO) | 14 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 20 | Rhodes (TN) | 28 | Memphis, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Wabash (IN) | 13 | Illinois St. | 6 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 0 | Albion (MI) | 21 | Albion, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 6 | Butler (IN) | 40 | Indianapolis, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Wabash (IN) | 24 | Hanover (IN) | 7 | Hanover, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 22 | Ohio Wesleyan | 48 | Delaware, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wabash (IN) | 8 | DePauw (IN) | 24 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Wagner (NY) | 26 | Ursinus (PA) | 6 | Collegeville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Wagner (NY) | 15 | Haverford (PA) | 14 | Haverford, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Wagner (NY) | 13 | Susquehanna (PA) | 6 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Wagner (NY) | 13 | Hamilton (NY) | 20 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Wagner (NY) | 8 | Widener (PA) | 13 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Wagner (NY) | 16 | Merchant Marine (NY) | 22 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Wagner (NY) | 18 | Dickinson (PA) | 20 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wagner (NY) | 6 | Moravian (PA) | 34 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 12 | Clemson (SC) | 14 | Clemson, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 24 | Florida St. | 27 | Tallahassee, FL | |
| 1958 | W | Wake Forest (NC) | 13 | North Carolina St. | 7 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Wake Forest (NC) | 34 | Maryland | 0 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Wake Forest (NC) | 13 | Virginia Tech | 6 | Norfolk, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Villanova (PA) | 9 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | North Carolina | 26 | Chapel Hill, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 0 | Duke (NC) | 29 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | Auburn (AL) | 21 | Auburn, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Wake Forest (NC) | 7 | South Carolina | 24 | Columbia, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 21 | Dubuque (IA) | 0 | Dubuque, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 26 | Upper Iowa | 20 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 26 | Central (IA) | 7 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 32 | Buena Vista (IA) | 7 | Storm Lake, IA | |
| 1958 | T | Wartburg (IA) | 6 | Luther (IA) | 6 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 7 | Parsons (IA) | 0 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 15 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 34 | Iowa Wesleyan | 19 | Waverly, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wartburg (IA) | 34 | Simpson (IA) | 12 | Indianola, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Washburn (KS) | 26 | Eastern New Mexico | 0 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Washburn (KS) | 19 | Fort Hays St. (KS) | 6 | Hays, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Washburn (KS) | 6 | Emporia St. (KS) | 27 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Washburn (KS) | 13 | Truman St. (MO) | 26 | Kirksville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Washburn (KS) | 19 | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Washburn (KS) | 2 | Benedictine (KS) | 33 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Washburn (KS) | 7 | Pittsburg St. (KS) | 13 | Pittsburg, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Washburn (KS) | 27 | Southwestern (KS) | 0 | Topeka, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Washburn (KS) | 12 | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Golden, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Washington | 6 | Oregon | 0 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 7 | Ohio St. | 12 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 6 | Southern California | 21 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 12 | Stanford (CA) | 22 | Stanford, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington | 14 | San Jose St. (CA) | 6 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington | 24 | Minnesota | 21 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 0 | UCLA | 20 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 12 | Oregon St. | 14 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 7 | California | 12 | Seattle, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington | 14 | Washington St. | 18 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 20 | Bethany (WV) | 28 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Allegheny (PA) | 6 | Meadville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 21 | John Carroll (OH) | 20 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 12 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 15 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 14 | Grove City (PA) | 15 | Grove City, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Thiel (PA) | 19 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 0 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 24 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 6 | California (PA) | 41 | Washington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 7 | Southern Illinois | 36 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 8 | Centre (KY) | 27 | Danville, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 0 | Sewanee (TN) | 12 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 13 | Franklin & Marshall (PA) | 14 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington & Lee (VA) | 13 | Randolph-Macon (VA) | 12 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 6 | Washington (MO) | 12 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 6 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 12 | Lexington, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington & Lee (VA) | 0 | Wittenberg (OH) | 51 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | T | Washington & Lee JV (VA) | 7 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 7 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Washington (MO) | 28 | Nebraska-Omaha | 6 | Omaha, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Washington (MO) | 14 | Wabash (IN) | 13 | Crawfordsville, IN | |
| 1958 | L | Washington (MO) | 21 | Drake (IA) | 28 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Washington (MO) | 0 | Bradley (IL) | 7 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Washington (MO) | 19 | Missouri S&T | 13 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Washington (MO) | 2 | Western Michigan | 34 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Washington (MO) | 12 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 6 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Washington (MO) | 12 | Butler (IN) | 20 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 38 | UCLA | 20 | Los Angeles, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington St. | 14 | California | 34 | Berkeley, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 7 | Oregon St. | 0 | Pullman, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 8 | Idaho | 0 | Moscow, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 40 | Stanford (CA) | 6 | Pullman, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Washington St. | 28 | Northwestern (IL) | 29 | Evanston, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 6 | Oregon | 0 | Eugene, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Washington St. | 6 | Southern California | 14 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 34 | Pacific (CA) | 0 | Stockton, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Washington St. | 18 | Washington | 14 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (MI) | 0 | Northern Michigan | 39 | Marquette, MI | |
| 1958 | T | Wayne St. (MI) | 7 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 7 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (MI) | 14 | Buffalo (NY) | 44 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (MI) | 33 | John Carroll (OH) | 20 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (MI) | 21 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 6 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (MI) | 0 | Western Reserve (OH) | 26 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (MI) | 6 | Valparaiso (IN) | 27 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (NE) | 21 | Hastings (NE) | 13 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (NE) | 0 | Nebraska-Kearney | 56 | Kearney, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (NE) | 48 | Midland Lutheran (NE) | 0 | Fremont, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (NE) | 7 | Chadron St. (NE) | 27 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (NE) | 7 | Augustana (SD) | 20 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (NE) | 20 | Doane (NE) | 13 | Crete, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (NE) | 0 | Nebraska Wesleyan | 28 | Lincoln, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Wayne St. (NE) | 2 | Peru St. (NE) | 16 | Wayne, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Wayne St. (NE) | 61 | Concordia (NE) | 14 | Seward, NE | |
| 1958 | W | Waynesburg (PA) | 20 | Potomac St. (WV) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Waynesburg (PA) | 7 | Defiance (OH) | 6 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Westminster (PA) | 46 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Scranton (PA) | 21 | Scranton, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Waynesburg (PA) | 26 | Ohio Northern | 15 | Ada, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Geneva (PA) | 27 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 7 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | East Stroudsburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Waynesburg (PA) | 13 | Central St. (OH) | 26 | Waynesburg, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Weber JC (UT) | 7 | Boise JC (ID) | 49 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Weber JC (UT) | 0 | Cerritos CC (CA) | 59 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Weber JC (UT) | 12 | Mesa St. (CO) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Wesley (DE) | 0 | Ferrum JC (VA) | 26 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Wesley (DE) | 0 | Potomac St. (WV) | 64 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 14 | Swarthmore (PA) | 6 | Swarthmore, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 32 | Bowdoin (ME) | 8 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 7 | Williams (MA) | 16 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 15 | Coast Guard (CT) | 6 | New London, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Middlebury (VT) | 8 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 8 | Worcester Tech (MA) | 20 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Wesleyan (CT) | 0 | Amherst (MA) | 19 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Wesleyan (CT) | 22 | Trinity (CT) | 18 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | T | West Alabama | 0 | Southern Union College (AL) | 0 | ? | Game results unknown |
| 1958 | W | West Alabama | 6 | Millsaps (MS) | 0 | Livingston, AL | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 14 | North Alabama | 34 | Florence, AL | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 6 | Troy (AL) | 22 | Troy, AL | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 0 | Louisiana College | 39 | Pineville, LA | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 6 | Jacksonville St. (AL) | 22 | Jacksonville, AL | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 0 | Northwestern St. (LA) | 64 | Natchitoches, LA | |
| 1958 | L | West Alabama | 0 | Delta St. (MS) | 28 | Cleveland, MS | |
| 1958 | L | West All-Stars | 14 | East All-Stars | 26 | San Francisco, CA | East-West Shrine Classic |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 68 | Millersville (PA) | 0 | Millersville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 63 | King's (PA) | 7 | Kingston, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 56 | Bloomsburg (PA) | 0 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 49 | East Stroudsburg (PA) | 0 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | L | West Chester (PA) | 14 | Villanova (PA) | 28 | Villanova, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 19 | Mansfield (PA) | 0 | Mansfield, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 51 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 0 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 40 | Shippensburg (PA) | 20 | Shippensburg, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 85 | Cheyney (PA) | 0 | West Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Chester (PA) | 69 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 12 | Berea, OH | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 14 | Marion Military Institute (AL) | 39 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 0 | Middle Georgia College | 33 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 6 | Southern Union College (AL) | 34 | Wadley, AL | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 12 | Gordon (GA) | 20 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 0 | South Georgia College | 28 | Douglas, GA | |
| 1958 | L | West Georgia | 0 | Georgia Military College | 20 | Carrollton, GA | |
| 1958 | L | West Hills JC (CA) | 12 | Antelope Valley College (CA) | 48 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | West Liberty St. (WV) | 7 | West Virginia St. | 6 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | West Virginia Tech | 41 | Wheeling, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 13 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 20 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Geneva (PA) | 34 | Beaver Falls, PA | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Glenville St. (WV) | 13 | Wellsburg, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Liberty St. (WV) | 21 | Salem College (WV) | 7 | New Martinsville, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 6 | Concord (WV) | 14 | Athens, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 12 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Liberty St. (WV) | 7 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 8 | Wheeling, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 8 | Arizona | 15 | Tucson, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 13 | Arizona St. | 16 | Tempe, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 21 | Abilene Christian (TX) | 28 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 12 | Texas-El Paso | 29 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 12 | Virginia Tech | 28 | Roanoke, VA | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 7 | Texas Tech | 32 | Lubbock, TX | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 7 | Trinity (TX) | 35 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 0 | Southern Mississippi | 15 | Hattiesburg, MS | |
| 1958 | L | West Texas A&M | 6 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 26 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | West Texas A&M | 39 | New Mexico St. | 32 | Canyon, TX | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia | 35 | George Washington (DC) | 12 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia | 12 | Indiana | 13 | Bloomington, IN | |
| 1958 | T | West Virginia | 14 | Penn St. | 14 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia | 30 | Boston (MA) | 36 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia | 66 | Richmond (VA) | 22 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia | 14 | Oklahoma | 47 | Norman, OK | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia | 8 | Pittsburgh (PA) | 15 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia | 21 | Virginia Tech | 20 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia | 56 | William & Mary (VA) | 6 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia | 12 | Syracuse (NY) | 15 | Morgantown, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia St. | 6 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 7 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia St. | 32 | Salem College (WV) | 0 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia St. | 6 | Central St. (OH) | 13 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia St. | 0 | Marshall (WV) | 9 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia St. | 0 | Southern Illinois | 19 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | T | West Virginia St. | 0 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 0 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia St. | 8 | Morgan St. (MD) | 6 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia St. | 28 | West Virginia Tech | 26 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Tech | 6 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 13 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Tech | 41 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Wheeling, WV | |
| 1958 | T | West Virginia Tech | 14 | Morehead St. (KY) | 14 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Tech | 19 | Newport News Apprentice School (VA) | 0 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Tech | 13 | Salem College (WV) | 0 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Tech | 51 | Concord (WV) | 0 | Beckley, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Tech | 14 | Shepherd (WV) | 20 | Shepherdstown, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Tech | 23 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 0 | Montgomery, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Tech | 26 | West Virginia St. | 28 | Institute, WV | |
| 1958 | T | West Virginia Wesleyan | 6 | Bridgewater (VA) | 6 | Bridgewater, VA | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Wesleyan | 6 | Fairmont St. (WV) | 31 | Fairmont, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Wesleyan | 13 | Davis & Elkins (WV) | 7 | Elkins, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Wesleyan | 7 | Salem College (WV) | 19 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Wesleyan | 12 | Marietta (OH) | 25 | Parkersburg, WV | |
| 1958 | T | West Virginia Wesleyan | 7 | Bethany (WV) | 7 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | West Virginia Wesleyan | 0 | Glenville St. (WV) | 20 | Weston, WV | |
| 1958 | W | West Virginia Wesleyan | 12 | West Liberty St. (WV) | 0 | Buckhannon, WV | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Elon (NC) | 15 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 12 | Tampa (FL) | 19 | Tampa, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 0 | Emory & Henry (VA) | 6 | Emory, VA | |
| 1958 | T | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Catawba (NC) | 6 | Salisbury, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 15 | Wofford (SC) | 29 | Asheville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 6 | Carson-Newman (TN) | 20 | Jefferson City, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Western Carolina (NC) | 32 | Appalachian St. (NC) | 22 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 7 | East Carolina (NC) | 18 | Greenville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 30 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 36 | Hickory, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Western Carolina (NC) | 0 | Guilford (NC) | 15 | Cullowhee, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 16 | Illinois St. | 10 | Normal, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Western Illinois | 31 | Southern Illinois | 32 | Carbondale, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 27 | Eastern Michigan | 6 | Ypsilanti, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 38 | Northern Illinois | 7 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 32 | Saint Ambrose (IA) | 25 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | T | Western Illinois | 6 | Bradley (IL) | 6 | Peoria, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 34 | Eastern Illinois | 0 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Western Illinois | 38 | Central Michigan | 23 | Macomb, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Western Kentucky | 21 | Eastern Kentucky | 14 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Western Kentucky | 7 | Middle Tennessee St. | 10 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Western Kentucky | 14 | Morehead St. (KY) | 0 | Morehead, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Western Kentucky | 6 | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Western Kentucky | 12 | Southeast Missouri St. | 0 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Western Kentucky | 0 | East Tennessee St. | 8 | Johnson City, TN | |
| 1958 | L | Western Kentucky | 3 | Tennessee Tech | 7 | Cookeville, TN | |
| 1958 | W | Western Kentucky | 34 | Austin Peay St. (TN) | 16 | Bowling Green, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Western Kentucky | 7 | Murray St. (KY) | 12 | Murray, KY | |
| 1958 | W | Western Michigan | 21 | Ohio | 14 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Western Michigan | 30 | Marshall (WV) | 24 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Western Michigan | 33 | Western Reserve (OH) | 0 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Western Michigan | 6 | Bowling Green (OH) | 40 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Western Michigan | 32 | Central Michigan | 33 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Western Michigan | 20 | Miami (OH) | 34 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Western Michigan | 34 | Washington (MO) | 2 | Saint Louis, MO | |
| 1958 | L | Western Michigan | 6 | Toledo (OH) | 21 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Western Michigan | 6 | Kent St. (OH) | 32 | Kent, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Western New Mexico | 7 | Northern Arizona | 30 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 28 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 27 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 22 | New Mexico Highlands | 19 | Las Vegas, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 40 | Saint Mary of the Plains (KS) | 0 | Dodge City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 34 | Adams St. (CO) | 7 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | L | Western New Mexico | 10 | San Diego (CA) | 13 | San Diego, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 28 | Arizona St. JV | 7 | Silver City, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Western New Mexico | 40 | Eastern Arizona JC (AZ) | 7 | Thatcher, AZ | |
| 1958 | W | Western Oregon | 7 | Oregon Tech | 66 | Monmouth, OR | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Western Oregon | 19 | Eastern Oregon | 7 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Western Oregon | 26 | British Columbia (BC) | 47 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | Western Oregon | 12 | Whitman (WA) | 19 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Western Oregon | 6 | Linfield (OR) | 32 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Western Oregon | 12 | Western Washington | 33 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Oregon | 22 | Portland St. (OR) | 7 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Western Oregon | 21 | Southern Oregon | 0 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Western Oregon | 28 | Lower Columbia JC (WA) | 18 | Longview, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Reserve (OH) | 31 | John Carroll (OH) | 12 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Western Reserve (OH) | 52 | Bethany (WV) | 18 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Western Reserve (OH) | 0 | Western Michigan | 33 | Kalamazoo, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Western Reserve (OH) | 6 | Buffalo (NY) | 19 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Western Reserve (OH) | 0 | Lehigh (PA) | 47 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Reserve (OH) | 26 | Wayne St. (MI) | 0 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Western Reserve (OH) | 26 | Case Institute of Technology (OH) | 12 | Cleveland, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 6 | Colorado College | 18 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 12 | Colorado School of Mines | 26 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 24 | New Mexico St. | 27 | Las Cruces, NM | |
| 1958 | W | Western St. (CO) | 16 | Eastern New Mexico | 6 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 0 | Idaho St. | 7 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 6 | Northern Colorado | 25 | Greeley, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 12 | Adams St. (CO) | 21 | Alamosa, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 14 | San Diego (CA) | 46 | Gunnison, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Western St. (CO) | 12 | College of Idaho | 54 | Caldwell, ID | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 20 | British Columbia (BC) | 19 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 21 | Whitworth (WA) | 6 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 19 | Central Washington | 13 | Ellensburg, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 6 | Eastern Washington | 0 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 33 | Western Oregon | 12 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Western Washington | 14 | Linfield (OR) | 37 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Western Washington | 12 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 7 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Western Washington | 0 | Puget Sound (WA) | 14 | Bellingham, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 7 | William Penn (IA) | 26 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 7 | Buena Vista (IA) | 41 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 6 | Parsons (IA) | 33 | Fairfield, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 6 | Sterling (KS) | 26 | Sterling, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Westmar (IA) | 19 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 7 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 0 | Peru St. (NE) | 14 | Peru, NE | |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 6 | Yankton (SD) | 7 | LeMars, IA | Westmar Athletic Field |
| 1958 | L | Westmar (IA) | 14 | Carthage (WI) | 20 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 34 | Indiana (PA) | 7 | Indiana, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 46 | Waynesburg (PA) | 0 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 7 | Slippery Rock (PA) | 6 | Slippery Rock, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 30 | Saint Vincent's (PA) | 7 | Latrobe, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 14 | Thiel (PA) | 6 | Greenville, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster (PA) | 6 | Geneva (PA) | 0 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | T | Westminster (PA) | 21 | Juniata (PA) | 21 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Westminster (PA) | 0 | Carnegie Mellon (PA) | 6 | New Wilmington, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | Colorado School of Mines | 13 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 50 | Carroll (MT) | 0 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | Southern Utah | 0 | Cedar City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 0 | Oregon Tech | 6 | Salt Lake City, UT | Oregon Tech Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 19 | Montana St.-Billings | 0 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 20 | Eastern Oregon | 12 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Westminster College (UT) | 19 | Montana Western | 12 | Salt Lake City, UT | |
| 1958 | L | Westminster College (UT) | 14 | Portland St. (OR) | 18 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Wharton County JC (TX) | 24 | John Tarleton College (TX) | 14 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wharton County JC (TX) | 21 | Cameron (OK) | 18 | Lawton, OK | |
| 1958 | W | Wharton County JC (TX) | 33 | Texas-Arlington | 14 | Wharton, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 33 | North Central (IL) | 6 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 67 | Augustana (IL) | 12 | Rock Island, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 37 | Illinois Wesleyan | 14 | Bloomington, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 90 | Elmhurst (IL) | 6 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 40 | Northern Illinois | 20 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 48 | Lake Forest (IL) | 0 | Wheaton, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 26 | Millikin (IL) | 0 | Decatur, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wheaton (IL) | 16 | Carroll (WI) | 12 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Whitman (WA) | 27 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 40 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Whitman (WA) | 14 | Linfield (OR) | 21 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Whitman (WA) | 26 | College of Idaho | 7 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Whitman (WA) | 19 | Western Oregon | 12 | Monmouth, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Whitman (WA) | 33 | Eastern Oregon | 6 | La Grande, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Whitman (WA) | 7 | Central Washington | 13 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitman (WA) | 0 | Willamette (OR) | 39 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Whitman (WA) | 12 | Pacific (OR) | 7 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 46 | California Tech | 0 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Whittier (CA) | 18 | Cal St.-Sacramento | 20 | Sacramento, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 29 | Pomona-Pitzer (CA) | 15 | Claremont, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 36 | Pepperdine (CA) | 19 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 9 | California-Davis | 6 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 7 | California-Santa Barbara | 6 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 40 | Occidental (CA) | 14 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 26 | Oregon Tech | 7 | Whittier, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Whittier (CA) | 27 | Redlands (CA) | 6 | Redlands, CA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 7 | Eastern Washington | 20 | Cheney, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 6 | Western Washington | 21 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Whitworth (WA) | 26 | Portland St. (OR) | 6 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 13 | Central Washington | 43 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 6 | Willamette (OR) | 41 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 13 | Linfield (OR) | 24 | McMinnville, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Whitworth (WA) | 19 | Puget Sound (WA) | 13 | Spokane, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Whitworth (WA) | 28 | British Columbia (BC) | 7 | Vancouver, BC (Canada) | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 20 | Pacific Lutheran (WA) | 26 | Tacoma, WA | |
| 1958 | L | Whitworth (WA) | 12 | Humboldt St. (CA) | 20 | Arcata, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Wichita St. (KS) | 21 | Villanova (PA) | 6 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Wichita St. (KS) | 12 | Oklahoma St. | 43 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Wichita St. (KS) | 15 | North Texas | 13 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Wichita St. (KS) | 0 | Houston (TX) | 44 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Wichita St. (KS) | 14 | Bowling Green (OH) | 20 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | T | Wichita St. (KS) | 16 | Cincinnati (OH) | 16 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wichita St. (KS) | 6 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 13 | Abilene, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wichita St. (KS) | 32 | Drake (IA) | 8 | Des Moines, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Wichita St. (KS) | 26 | George Washington (DC) | 12 | Wichita, KS | |
| 1958 | L | Wichita St. (KS) | 6 | Tulsa (OK) | 25 | Tulsa, OK | |
| 1958 | L | Widener (PA) | 12 | Lycoming (PA) | 13 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 13 | McDaniel College (MD) | 0 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 27 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 7 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 20 | Wilkes (PA) | 14 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 13 | Wagner (NY) | 8 | Staten Island, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 14 | Moravian (PA) | 8 | Chester, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 15 | Drexel Institute (PA) | 6 | Philadelphia, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Widener (PA) | 1 | Swarthmore (PA) | 0 | Swarthmore, PA | Swarthmore Forfeits |
| 1958 | L | Widener (PA) | 18 | Hampden-Sydney (VA) | 24 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Wiley (TX) | 0 | Texas Southern | 14 | Houston, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wiley (TX) | 25 | Mississippi Valley St. | 7 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Wiley (TX) | 4 | Jackson St. (MS) | 23 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wiley (TX) | 32 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | 6 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wiley (TX) | 46 | Bishop (TX) | 8 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Wiley (TX) | 15 | Grambling St. (LA) | 19 | Shreveport, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Wiley (TX) | 74 | Alcorn St. (MS) | 0 | Lorman, MS | |
| 1958 | L | Wiley (TX) | 6 | Southern (LA) | 21 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | L | Wiley (TX) | 0 | Prairie View A&M (TX) | 13 | Marshall, TX | |
| 1958 | W | Wiley (TX) | 19 | Texas College | 12 | Tyler, TX | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Juniata (PA) | 47 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 8 | Moravian (PA) | 30 | Bethlehem, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Dickinson (PA) | 12 | Carlisle, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 14 | Widener (PA) | 20 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Ithaca (NY) | 27 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Lebanon Valley (PA) | 12 | Lebanon, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Wilkes (PA) | 8 | Ursinus (PA) | 0 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Lycoming (PA) | 39 | Williamsport, PA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilkes (PA) | 0 | Scranton (PA) | 25 | Wilkes-Barre, PA | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 40 | Puget Sound (WA) | 7 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 27 | Pacific (OR) | 14 | Forest Grove, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 27 | Lewis & Clark (OR) | 0 | Portland, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 33 | Linfield (OR) | 0 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 41 | Whitworth (WA) | 6 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 20 | California-Davis | 0 | Davis, CA | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 39 | Whitman (WA) | 0 | Walla Walla, WA | |
| 1958 | W | Willamette (OR) | 54 | College of Idaho | 7 | Salem, OR | |
| 1958 | L | Willamette (OR) | 0 | Northern Arizona | 7 | Yuma, AZ | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 7 | Boston (MA) | 33 | Boston, MA | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 15 | Virginia Tech | 27 | Blacksburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 7 | Davidson (NC) | 16 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | T | William & Mary (VA) | 6 | Virginia Military Institute | 6 | Bluefield, VA | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 0 | Navy (MD) | 14 | Annapolis, MD | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 0 | George Washington (DC) | 7 | Washington, DC | |
| 1958 | W | William & Mary (VA) | 13 | North Carolina St. | 6 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | L | William & Mary (VA) | 6 | West Virginia | 56 | Williamsburg, VA | |
| 1958 | W | William & Mary (VA) | 18 | Richmond (VA) | 15 | Richmond, VA | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 33 | Iowa Wesleyan | 27 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 19 | Northwest Missouri St. | 7 | Maryville, MO | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 20 | Baker (KS) | 7 | Baldwin City, KS | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 32 | Tarkio (MO) | 6 | Tarkio, MO | |
| 1958 | L | William Jewell (MO) | 0 | Oklahoma Panhandle St. | 9 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 32 | Ottawa (KS) | 26 | Ottawa, KS | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 34 | Culver-Stockton (MO) | 26 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | William Jewell (MO) | 25 | Graceland (IA) | 0 | Lamoni, IA | |
| 1958 | L | William Jewell (MO) | 3 | Missouri Valley | 21 | Marshall, MO | |
| 1958 | L | William Jewell (MO) | 20 | Benedictine (KS) | 21 | Liberty, MO | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 26 | Westmar (IA) | 7 | LeMars, IA | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 28 | Illinois College | 14 | Jacksonville, IL | |
| 1958 | L | William Penn (IA) | 13 | Graceland (IA) | 34 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | L | William Penn (IA) | 14 | Dubuque (IA) | 32 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 28 | Eureka (IL) | 0 | Eureka, IL | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 21 | Central (IA) | 0 | Pella, IA | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 47 | Central Methodist (MO) | 12 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 14 | Burlington JC (IA) | 7 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | William Penn (IA) | 21 | Carthage (WI) | 20 | Oskaloosa, IA | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 40 | Union (NY) | 6 | Schenectady, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 46 | Colby (ME) | 6 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 16 | Wesleyan (CT) | 7 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 31 | Middlebury (VT) | 0 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Williams (MA) | 0 | Trinity (CT) | 12 | Hartford, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 48 | Bowdoin (ME) | 28 | Brunswick, ME | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 37 | Tufts (MA) | 8 | Williamstown, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Williams (MA) | 12 | Amherst (MA) | 7 | Amherst, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 13 | Georgetown (KY) | 35 | Georgetown, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 0 | Ohio Northern | 24 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 0 | Bluffton (OH) | 42 | Bluffton, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 6 | Centre (KY) | 7 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wilmington (OH) | 20 | Ashland (OH) | 18 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 12 | Defiance (OH) | 21 | Wilmington, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wilmington (OH) | 6 | Findlay (OH) | 57 | Findlay, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 43 | Chowan (NC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Wingate (NC) | 20 | Fork Union Military Academy (VA) | 21 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 28 | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 13 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 25 | Gardner-Webb (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 25 | Lees-McRae JC (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 25 | Lees-McRae JC (NC) | 12 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 12 | Mars Hill JC (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | W | Wingate (NC) | 13 | Mars Hill JC (NC) | 0 | ? | |
| 1958 | L | Wingate (NC) | 6 | Texarkana JC (TX) | 21 | ? | Pine Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Winona St. (MN) | 6 | Michigan Tech | 26 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Winona St. (MN) | 8 | Si Tanka (SD) | 19 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | T | Winona St. (MN) | 6 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 6 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Winona St. (MN) | 20 | Wisconsin-Stout | 12 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Winona St. (MN) | 22 | Loras (IA) | 8 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Winona St. (MN) | 42 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 0 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Winona St. (MN) | 12 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 38 | Winona, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Winona St. (MN) | 13 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 38 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Johnson C. Smith (NC) | 14 | Charlotte, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 32 | Elizabeth City St. (NC) | 14 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Saint Augustine's (NC) | 26 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 0 | Bluefield St. (WV) | 22 | Bluefield, WV | |
| 1958 | T | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 18 | Kentucky St. | 18 | Frankfort, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 6 | Hampton (VA) | 16 | Hampton, VA | |
| 1958 | L | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 12 | North Carolina A&T | 14 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 54 | Fayetteville St. (NC) | 6 | Winston-Salem, NC | |
| 1958 | W | Winston-Salem St. (NC) | 54 | Saint Paul's (VA) | 6 | Lawrenceville, VA | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 9 | Michigan St. | 7 | East Lansing, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 50 | Marquette (WI) | 0 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 17 | Northwestern (IL) | 13 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 31 | Purdue (IN) | 6 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 20 | Miami (FL) | 0 | Miami, FL | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin | 9 | Iowa | 20 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | T | Wisconsin | 7 | Ohio St. | 7 | Columbus, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 31 | Illinois | 12 | Champaign, IL | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin | 27 | Minnesota | 12 | Madison, WI | |
| 1958 | T | Wisconsin Tech | 6 | Northland (WI) | 6 | Ashland, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin Tech | 12 | Benedictine (IL) | 8 | Lisle, IL | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin Tech | 0 | Loras (IA) | 53 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin Tech | 18 | Lakeland (WI) | 0 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 0 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 70 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 12 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 8 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 17 | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 14 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 30 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 6 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 7 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 27 | Wisconsin-Stout | 6 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 6 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 27 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 8 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 34 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 13 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 12 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 8 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 12 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 26 | Macalester (MN) | 7 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 19 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 12 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 22 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 6 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 29 | Wisconsin-Superior | 32 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 40 | Wisconsin-Stout | 0 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 6 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 21 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 12 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 13 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 41 | Wisconsin-Stout | 0 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 13 | Ferris St. (MI) | 0 | Big Rapids, MI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 12 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 19 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 19 | Moorhead St. (MN) | 6 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 0 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 22 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 3 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 8 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 6 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 18 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 35 | Wisconsin-Stout | 14 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 20 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 21 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 14 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 20 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 44 | Northland (WI) | 0 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 7 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 6 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 22 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 0 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 20 | Wisconsin-Superior | 15 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 19 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 8 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Platteville | 26 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 28 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Platteville | 26 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 28 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Platteville | 0 | Bethel (MN) | 19 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Platteville | 12 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 19 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | T | Wisconsin-Platteville | 14 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 14 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Platteville | 8 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 3 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Platteville | 8 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 19 | Oshkosh, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 28 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 26 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 25 | Wisconsin-Superior | 0 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-River Falls | 14 | Minnesota St.-Mankato | 20 | Mankato, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 32 | Wisconsin-Stout | 13 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 31 | Augsburg (MN) | 6 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-River Falls | 2 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 12 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 14 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 0 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 27 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 6 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-River Falls | 21 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 6 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 21 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 20 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 19 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 12 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 28 | Hamline (MN) | 14 | Saint Paul, MN | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 12 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 2 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | T | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 14 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 14 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 22 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 14 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 34 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 8 | Stevens Point, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 32 | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 14 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 35 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 0 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 41 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 13 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 32 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 12 | Winona St. (MN) | 20 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 12 | Saint Cloud St. (MN) | 24 | Saint Cloud, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 6 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 27 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Stout | 0 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 40 | La Crosse, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Stout | 14 | Wisconsin-Superior | 0 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 0 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 25 | River Falls, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Bemidji St. (MN) | 48 | Bemidji, MN | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 17 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Minnesota-Duluth | 6 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Superior | 30 | Northland (WI) | 0 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Superior | 32 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 29 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 15 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 20 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 0 | Wisconsin-Stout | 14 | Menomonie, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Superior | 14 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 32 | Superior, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 70 | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | 0 | Eau Claire, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 28 | Wisconsin-Platteville | 26 | Platteville, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 34 | Saint Norbert (WI) | 8 | De Pere, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 20 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 14 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 13 | Carroll (WI) | 26 | Waukesha, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 0 | Wisconsin-River Falls | 14 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | L | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 14 | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 22 | Whitewater, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 18 | Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 6 | Milwaukee, WI | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 37 | Denison (OH) | 0 | Granville, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 27 | Heidelberg (OH) | 20 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 7 | Ohio Wesleyan | 6 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 6 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 26 | Berea, OH | Baldwin-Wallace Forfeits |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 41 | DePauw (IN) | 7 | Greencastle, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 36 | Marietta (OH) | 0 | Marietta, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 66 | Mount Union (OH) | 8 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 28 | Akron (OH) | 6 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wittenberg (OH) | 51 | Washington & Lee (VA) | 0 | Springfield, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 20 | Davidson (NC) | 21 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 14 | Presbyterian (SC) | 18 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 3 | Catawba (NC) | 14 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Wofford (SC) | 18 | Citadel (SC) | 6 | Orangeburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Wofford (SC) | 29 | Western Carolina (NC) | 15 | Asheville, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 0 | Lenoir-Rhyne (NC) | 20 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | W | Wofford (SC) | 22 | Elon (NC) | 16 | Burlington, NC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 39 | Furman (SC) | 40 | Greenville, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 20 | East Tennessee St. | 24 | Spartanburg, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wofford (SC) | 13 | Newberry (SC) | 21 | Newberry, SC | |
| 1958 | L | Wooster (OH) | 6 | Ball St. (IN) | 14 | Muncie, IN | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 33 | Mount Union (OH) | 6 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 27 | Denison (OH) | 8 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 19 | Ashland (OH) | 0 | Ashland, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 33 | Kenyon (OH) | 0 | Gambier, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wooster (OH) | 20 | Akron (OH) | 28 | Akron, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 38 | Albion (MI) | 14 | Wooster, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Wooster (OH) | 0 | Muskingum (OH) | 34 | New Concord, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Wooster (OH) | 28 | Oberlin (OH) | 0 | Oberlin, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 26 | Rensselaer Tech (NY) | 6 | Troy, NY | |
| 1958 | L | Worcester Tech (MA) | 13 | Middlebury (VT) | 14 | Middlebury, VT | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 33 | Norwich (VT) | 12 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 18 | Bates (ME) | 6 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 19 | Central Connecticut St. | 6 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 20 | Wesleyan (CT) | 8 | Middletown, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Worcester Tech (MA) | 14 | Coast Guard (CT) | 8 | Worcester, MA | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 25 | Utah | 20 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 15 | Denver (CO) | 12 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 41 | Utah St. | 13 | Logan, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 28 | Oregon St. | 0 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Wyoming | 14 | Kansas St. | 17 | Manhattan, KS | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 21 | Montana | 14 | Billings, MT | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 7 | Colorado St. | 6 | Fort Collins, CO | |
| 1958 | L | Wyoming | 12 | New Mexico | 13 | Laramie, WY | |
| 1958 | L | Wyoming | 6 | Air Force (CO) | 21 | Colorado Springs, CO | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 22 | Brigham Young (UT) | 14 | Provo, UT | |
| 1958 | W | Wyoming | 14 | Hardin-Simmons (TX) | 6 | El Paso, TX | Sun Bowl |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (LA) | 6 | Alabama St. | 12 | Montgomery, AL | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (LA) | 6 | Clark Atlanta (GA) | 22 | Atlanta, GA | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (LA) | 0 | Southern (LA) | 50 | Baton Rouge, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (LA) | 27 | Tuskegee (AL) | 26 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | T | Xavier (LA) | 12 | Alabama A&M | 12 | Normal, AL | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (LA) | 28 | Knoxville (TN) | 0 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (LA) | 28 | Bethune-Cookman (FL) | 20 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (LA) | 14 | Dillard (LA) | 6 | New Orleans, LA | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (OH) | 14 | Marshall (WV) | 6 | Huntington, WV | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (OH) | 22 | Miami (OH) | 8 | Oxford, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (OH) | 34 | Toledo (OH) | 8 | Toledo, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (OH) | 8 | Cincinnati (OH) | 14 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (OH) | 8 | Saint Joseph's (IN) | 0 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (OH) | 0 | Kent St. (OH) | 6 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (OH) | 20 | Quantico Marines (VA) | 31 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (OH) | 6 | Detroit (MI) | 31 | Detroit, MI | |
| 1958 | W | Xavier (OH) | 16 | Dayton (OH) | 0 | Cincinnati, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Xavier (OH) | 6 | Kentucky | 20 | Lexington, KY | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 14 | Dartmouth (NH) | 22 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 29 | Brown (RI) | 35 | Providence, RI | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 6 | Pennsylvania | 30 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 0 | Columbia (NY) | 13 | New York, NY | |
| 1958 | W | Yale (CT) | 8 | Connecticut | 6 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 7 | Cornell (NY) | 12 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Yale (CT) | 14 | Colgate (NY) | 7 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 14 | Princeton (NJ) | 50 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | L | Yale (CT) | 0 | Harvard (MA) | 28 | Cambridge, MA | |
| 1958 | L | Yankton (SD) | 7 | South Dakota-Springfield | 19 | Springfield, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 13 | South Dakota Tech | 6 | Rapid City, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Yankton (SD) | 0 | Si Tanka (SD) | 26 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Yankton (SD) | 0 | Northern St. (SD) | 19 | Aberdeen, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 6 | Dakota Wesleyan (SD) | 0 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Westmar (IA) | 6 | LeMars, IA | Westmar Athletic Field |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Black Hills St. (SD) | 6 | Spearfish, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 7 | Sioux Falls (SD) | 0 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | W | Yankton (SD) | 40 | Dakota St. (SD) | 21 | Yankton, SD | |
| 1958 | L | Youngstown St. (OH) | 12 | Eastern Michigan | 21 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Gustavus Adolphus (MN) | 26 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Western Kentucky | 6 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Youngstown St. (OH) | 0 | Ohio | 38 | Athens, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Southern Connecticut St. | 15 | New Haven, CT | |
| 1958 | W | Youngstown St. (OH) | 14 | Eastern Kentucky | 9 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | W | Youngstown St. (OH) | 20 | Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 12 | Youngstown, OH | |
| 1958 | L | Youngstown St. (OH) | 8 | Toledo (OH) | 21 | Toledo, OH |